Thread #2986357
File: Screenshot From 2026-04-16 10-59-17.png (1.6 MB)
1.6 MB PNG
For an office worksurface (desk) in solid oak, would you recommend polyurethane based varnish or oil based treatment of the wood?
40 RepliesView Thread
>>
>>2986357
I have years of experience with this, so bear with me here.
First of all, consider using deskmats for the mouse and general work area. This will greatly reduce damage to the surface. The deskmats don't have to be gamer-level designs, unless that's your thing.
As for the finish, use the precum that is dripping out of your tiny dicklet when mommy tells you to clench like a good boy. Just leak all over the surface and rub it in.
>>
>>2986357
I always cover the corners with a clean transparent tape because over the years my skin oils seep into the wood and wear down the corners my hands touch, this has happened with every desk I own, I just know to place tape right away now
>>
>>2986357
Just don't
It won't turn out as nice as something you buy from a company unless you already have prior experience doing this and know what to expect
>inb4 I don't want to pay $800 to a company
You're gonna spend $300-400 on the wood, $50 on stain and other supplies, you'll have to do the labor yourself, and you risk fucking it all up. Spend the money goy
>>
>>
>>
File: 20260416_115139.jpg (2.6 MB)
2.6 MB JPG
I ordered a sample (happy that I did before pulling the trigger) where PU based varnish is used
I lightly scratched it intentionally with my nails to put the "scratch resistance" qualities to the test.
My light nail scratches are seemingly immediately and permanently visible. Wow this is not meeting the claims
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: IMG-20260416-WA0000.jpg (1.5 MB)
1.5 MB JPG
>>2986363
Lol what a shitty product. Meanwhile things made 100 years ago don't fucking age,it's awesome.
>>
>>2986357
For office- definitely poly. Oil will soak into papers and make a mess. Oil is the nicer finish but you need something that dries to the touch. May I suggest a mette finish rather than glossy- will hide scratches and the like. Spray for nice finish. Pay a pro.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>2986371
Oil. But my advice is :look on ebays for stuff made between 1900 and 1945 in oak. Import them from europe if need to even if you'll pay a lot.The bed i showed you were the bed of the grandparents of my neighbor,he's 60. It will outlast me and my children.
>>
>>2986372
Thats a light coat of finish. Either apply multiple coats (takes longer but more likely to meet you scratch requirements) or accept that wood scratches. Notice that the pores are still open/ exposed in your sample. If you want true scratch resistance, build up the poly such that the wood grain/ wood pores are completely closed and the poly receives 100% of objective contact and the wood none.
>>
>>2986374
Agree that oil is a beautiful finish, but not appropraite for office use. If not 100% dry, it will soak into papers, or bottom of anything touching it. If it is 100% dry, it has to be touched up with more oil or the wood dries out- much like happens with leather.
Use mousepads.
One extra tip to OP- if time/ budget allows, have the finisher coat all sides of the wood (bottom doesnt have to be perfect) so that the wood doesnt soak up ambient humidity at different rates, especially if building up the layers of finish. Poly is not vapor permeable like oil can be. Coating all side prevents warping, particularly if you live in humid environment. But dont get too lost in details- get your desk up and running and make some money and have some fun.
>>
File: 20260416_115637.jpg (95.9 KB)
95.9 KB JPG
>>2986366
It's a fucking shitty varnish then.
I have a vintage desk coated with some random floor varnish I got from Leroy Merlin and I can't scratch it with my nails at all (but I still have a transparent mat over it so I don't have to think about putting hot mugs, sharp keys etc. on it)
>>
>>2986375
I feel like this company must not have very good standards, think about it, this is a sample on which potential purchase decision is going to be made. There is even a damage near the label which I did not make
fucking shit, not ordering from them
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: IMG_0401.jpg (2 MB)
2 MB JPG
>>2986366
Pic rel is my staircase handrail, cheap oak and 2 coats of Skylt after 2 years of daily use. Not sure how you managed to scratch it. I think it’s a great product, very natural look, hard to scratch.
If going with oil be sure to use a desk mat consistently or acidic fatty sweat will stain the parts where you put your hands. And don’t spill any orange juice or tea on it
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>2986510
yeah on the one hand I am sick and tired of garbage but it would suck to shell out like 800 bucks on something that turns out quite shitty as well
I think the company that sent me the sample is not serious, as someone mentioned, there are open pores, so they must have not done a good job
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>2986519
The wall socket and power cable help. Anyway, what I can't figure out is how the fuck you're supposed to grab the rail.
>>