File: 1745615519440550.jpg (24.8 KB)

24.8 KB JPG

>>129991804
Is it prog?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LK9JjW2noo

File: images.jpg (29.2 KB)

29.2 KB JPG

Prog

File: phil form.jpg (125.2 KB)

125.2 KB JPG

It's time to apologize

>>129992188
Not filling out your stupid form, he can't dance which is pretty important for a musician to be able to do

File: Roger the feminazi.jpg (39.6 KB)

39.6 KB JPG

Has Roger Waters taught you to be a better man yet?

File: traffic.jpg (232.2 KB)

232.2 KB JPG

This one goes out to the fuckface in the classic rock thread who said Traffic were the worst band ever
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ow1yz0P84E

>>129992625
I saw that too and was equally befuddled and upset. Even ignoring their quality, they're such a non-entity in the classic rock scene I don't understand why anyone would call them out. I could count on one hand the number of times I have heard Traffic on a classic rock radio station. Maybe they get a lot more play in the UK, I dunno.

>>129992625
I saw that too and was equally befuddled and upset. Even ignoring their quality, they're such a non-entity in the classic rock scene I don't understand why anyone would call them out. I could count on one hand the number of times I have heard Traffic on a classic rock radio station. Maybe they get a lot more play in the UK, I dunno.

>>129992988
>Maybe they get a lot more play in the UK, I dunno.
On the contrary they were probably a lot more successful in the states, at least in the 70s. Four of their albums were gold top-10 sellers, and two of those didn’t even make the UK charts. Low Spark was probably every FM jockey’s favorite piss break song for a few years.

>>129992302
why you so obsessed?

File: 1769266463533645.jpg (49.9 KB)

49.9 KB JPG

>>129992188
>Fripp
>Collins
Ofc both of these hacks need to have apology forms

>>129993111
I might ask you the same question. Why are you obsessed?

>>129993160
Tony will get one someday

He's so frail and tired ;_;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bcnSWY4EdcY

>>129991804
Gem

File: snakes&arrows.jpg (115.8 KB)

115.8 KB JPG

Shakes & Arrows is underrated

File: Tarkus.jpg (352.9 KB)

352.9 KB JPG

>Holy freakin' crap, Lois - it's Tarkus!

>>129993928
Sneakers O'Tarkus

File: IMG_3304.png (816.2 KB)

816.2 KB PNG

Can 10CC be considered prog? At least progressive pop?
https://youtu.be/GW76HfE_zm0?si=jHqOGv92YF7ACvrg

>>129993967
no

>>129993967
progressive pop, yes

>>129992625
>>129992988
I’m that Anon and I refuse to take it back. Traffic are boring and stale and this song you posted just reinforces that. Mr. Fantasy is one of the worst albums I’ve ever heard.

File: LiamTwitter.png (211.1 KB)

211.1 KB PNG

>>129992188
Not a potato a b eautiful godlike young man apologise nowe heethen chemical

>>129994117
I don't think even Traffic fans consider Mr. Fantasy one of their strongest albums. Great title track, a couple of highlights, but overall pretty scatterbrained.

>>129992188
Home by the Sea (both parts) is one of the best Genesis songs.
It's also 11 minutes long, has a giant instrumental section, is split into multiple parts and the lyrics are retarded so I don't care what anyone says, it's prog.

>>129992188
I won't apologize to someone that was like
>You fuck
>You fuck

>waysis posting
just when I thought this general couldn't get any worse

>>129996925
Waysis world dont like it get stufft

>>129996925
>This dead general
It needs to
>LIVE FORVER

>>129995817
This but Driving the Last Spike

File: chart.png (3.5 MB)

3.5 MB PNG

I finished the chart

>>129991984
and once we were on talking
Jesus turned to me and said
I've give you temptation with these things
these things that are hard to see

It's 1 o'clock and time for lunch

>>129998618
Love me some Giles, Giles & Fripp
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JgNxvEiZCQs

>>129999075
We gotta get in n out

>>129999161
KEK

>>129995817
But he already was inducted for that. It's Sussudio time now

File: 1728843537860627.jpg (106.5 KB)

106.5 KB JPG

West is Mike and Susie

File: 1759767633169687.webm (2.1 MB)

2.1 MB WEBM

STAND BACK

I wish the fountain of Salmacis was real
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rSpNh93pFbI

>>130002091
Kitaposter...

>>129992625
John Barleycorn will always be THE iconic fall album for me. Nothing else compares. This has probably been my favorite song off it on recent relistens, I love how asymmetrical the guitar solo is

>>130002564
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wA0vIcESGkI

>>130002038
Peter should induct Phil into the HOF

>>129995817
>>129997631
I was going to call you retards who have no idea what prog and/or good music is, but then "Memoirs of an Officer and a Gentlemen" off Love Beach came on. Perhaps I don't get those Genesis songs in the same way others don't get ELP's best post-1973 song.

>>130002681
would be kino

>>130002681
Paul should induct Phil into the HOF

>>130002845
Genesis did prog throughout their Phil-lead albums.
Like the anons said, Home by the Sea and Driving the Last Spike are both prog. Duke's original side A was supposed to be a Supper's Ready-styled epic, but was broken up because the band didn't want to draw comparisons. Phil and Tony hated being called prog, hell, Apocalypse in 9/8 was written by Tony to make fun of ELP, but there's no denying that they continued doing prog well into the '90s.

>>129992188
I like Brand X
Euthanasia Waltz is a really funny name for a song

File: a2200346180_16.jpg (36.2 KB)

36.2 KB JPG

so we all agree that magma has the greatest late-era phase among all prog bands right? aside from maaaybe vdgg no one comes even close to magma from 2000-2019.

>>130002937
I know Phil Genesis did prog. Trick of the Tail, Wind and Wuthering, and Duke are all clearly prog. I still will gladly deny they did prog in the 90s.

>>130002906
Noel should induct Phil into the HOF

What other King Crimson is like the good songs on ITCOCK, those good songs being Schizoid Man, Epitaph and Court

File: 10 minute taylor.jpg (144.5 KB)

144.5 KB JPG

>>129995817
Taylor Swift is prog

>>130003148
Of course it's Magma in terms of volume X quality. It also depends on what you consider late-era. IQ's released a great album 26 years after debut, and their best came out 5 years after that. I'm not a big Resistance or Dominion fan, but many are. Most fans would probably take their 25-40 year output over their 0-15 year output.

Many would argue Big Big Train didn't get good until 20 years after their debut.

I'll always bring up Mike Oldfield for creating his greatest piece of art 44 years after debut (admittedly a one-off after a long stretch of mediocrity).

These are weak arguments for a distant second, but I really don't care for VDGG's 21st century output.

>>130003257
Of course she is. Why else would Steven Wilson cover her? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kUGVuqakYtE

>>129991804
>none of the prog charts on /mu/ include a single renaissance album
actually disgusting

>>130005319
Do you want me to make a prog chart of bad prog albums that are laughably overrated because they include a woman? I don't know what other chart could have a Renaissance album on it.

>>130006474
>bad prog albums that are laughably overrated
Alright let's start
>ITCOCK
>pawn hearts
>red
>starless and bible black
>still life
>a passion play
>thick as a brick
>aqualung
>tarkus
>in the wake of poisedon
>all magma

File: 1489439676412.jpg (31 KB)

31 KB JPG

>>130006486
Oh sweetie. I think /wpop/ may be a bit more your speed.

>>130006552
I DON'T WANT TO HEAR COKED OUT 70S FAGGOTS RAPE A KEYBOARD
I DON'T WANT TO HEAR YOUR EPIC IRONICFAG LE TAKEDOWN OF CONCEPT ALBUMS
I DON'T WANT TO HEAR ABOUT YOUR FUCKING FICTIONAL ALIEN PLANET IN YOUR FAGGOT FRENCH MADE UP LANGUAGE

>>130006560
see
>>130006552

>>130006486
uh zased

>>130006486
I would not call Wake overrated. The overwhelming majority of people view it as an inferior imitation of Court, even if it has some good songs.

>>130006486
>no
>no
>no
>no
>no
>yes
>no
>yes
>yes
>no
>yesn't

>>130006486
Yes.

File: mastodon.jpg (1.3 MB)

1.3 MB JPG

>>130006560
this
/prog/ has so much potential to be a great prog general and a good horror show that is /metal/, but it's overtaken by gatekeeping geriatric boomers

>>130009061
and a good alternative to the horror show* that is metal

fuck me