Thread #152340684 | Image & Video Expansion | Click to Play
File: 1761837950298.jpg (58.7 KB)
58.7 KB JPG
481 RepliesView Thread
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152340698
>>152340715
Good morning sir
>>
>>
>>
>>152340684
Because boys are treated like defective girls so catering to them is frowned upon, but mostly >>152340748
>>
>>152340684
Circa 2012, /co/ is a huge part of it by championing worse shows then the action shows
/co/ watched Gravity Falls over Motorcity and Tron.
/co/ watched Steven Universe and Adventure Time over Generator Rex and Ben 10 and Sym Bionic Titan and so on.
/co/ watched Loud House over Korra.
And yes, by then companies decide to no longer make action shows because they underperform, then the shows directly lead to the crying over feelings daycare and TTG era, then animation in television is dead entirely. Congrats.
>>
>>
>>
>>152340684
Making action cartoon is expensive. These shows all existed to sell toys first and foremost and when kids stopped buying toys they lost their main source of financing.
There was another factor, which was ratings. CN in the early 2010s had some action cartoon like Ben 10, Generator Rex, Thundercats, Symbionic Titan, Young Justice and Beware The Batman and they were all being outperformed by Adventure Time, Regular Show, Gumball and Teen Titans Go! that were all cheaper and could be rerun more easily. In other networks it was worse with Korra being outperformed by SpongeBob *reruns*.
Nowadays all action cartoons you see are just vanity projects or exist to promote larger IPs/franchises. Arcane was basically a very expensive commercial for League of Legends (that they admitted they would never get their money back), Invincible is financed by Kirkman's Walking Dead money and exists to promote Skybound, X-Men '97 exists because Marvel wants to promote X-Men before their live-action movie, Creature Commandos exists to promote the DCU, etc.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152340684
>On my contry:
-The governament pass a law that forbid "propaganda aimed to Kids
-Biggest TV conglomerated stop showing cartoons and start showing LGBT+ degenerancy
-At some point they try put all comics in black cover
-Cable TV die (as they just give up against Netflix)
- Anime is easy to find in internet piracy
>>
>>152340806
ATLA was an action show
>>152340820
Nobody truly fears women and never will
>>152340835
Go watch Steven Trannyverse, faggot
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 2000.jpg (240.9 KB)
240.9 KB JPG
>>152340913
Not really?
He does not act feminine at all, he is just skinny and does not need muscles since he transforms anyway
>>
>>152340820
It's not fear, but rather a complete disinterest in a lie.
Coming in and pushing that women are strong and competent while men are the opposite, draws about the same level of interest as somebody trying to sell you that the sky is actually green. All it takes is a quick glance up to realize this is bullshit and not worth your time. So it killed the entertainment industry, and retards will blame the fake covid plandenic for it.
>>
>>
>>152340768
>>152340748
This but here's food for thought
One thing I noticed is that Western cartoon censors were squeamish around action shows even at the height
And that's a simple reason. Stuff like the DCAU was already here by the time Dragon Ball Z really took off here but Dragon Ball Z was still the one that scared the shit out of parents with how "violent" it was.
There's a simple reason, you can see it in 90s cartoons, a bit less in 2000s cartoons, then way fucking more in CalArts era.
The core thing that always got censored in action cartoons was always the actual impact of a blow, you had the "flash of light" in Batman among other things while by the 2010s, there was rarely a punch in Steven Universe that felt like a punch.
Speaking of, even as the 2010s took from the "graceful dance" fight scenes of anime, they forgot said anime had combat sport and kung fu movie inspiration and can't into the functional side of one. Be it a death match, a western gun fight, or a power level match. Good fight scenes have combat psychology, principles like "the fatal opening" and "the decisive moment".
Avatar, Ben 10, TMNT' 03 et cetera all still had this. Even unconventional fights like in JJBA are sure to include this.
OK KO and Miao Miao had to be the only current era kids shows that remembered this basic principle of fight scenes.
>>
>>
>>152340785
>There was another factor, which was ratings. CN in the early 2010s had some action cartoon like Ben 10, Generator Rex, Thundercats, Symbionic Titan, Young Justice and Beware The Batman and they were all being outperformed by Adventure Time, Regular Show, Gumball and Teen Titans Go! that were all cheaper and could be rerun more easily. In other networks it was worse with Korra being outperformed by SpongeBob *reruns*.
Yeah, there is a huge factor nobody wants to admit, which is that by then action cartoons were giant flops for the most part. Also Motorcity and Tron.
>>
>>
>>
>>152340785
>these shows all existed to sell toys first and foremost
Pretty sure Samurai Jack and Avatar: The Last Airbender weren't made to sell toys first and foremost. Ben 10 was a toy commercial, but Samurai Jack and Avatar were not really toy commercials. I don't even think Avatar had any toys during its first year on air
>>
File: 1769971461622.jpg (56.6 KB)
56.6 KB JPG
We need more action cartoons to turn boys into straight furries!
>>
>>
>>152341088
>>152341088
>OK KO and Miao Miao had to be the only current era kids shows that remembered this basic principle of fight scenes.
>Okok
This isn't true at all
>>
File: unclegrandpa_finished.jpg (127.8 KB)
127.8 KB JPG
>>152340785
>go back in time
>stop greenlighting comedy cartoons after 2012
easy
>>
>>152342550
Anon, if that is your plan you would need to go back in time 100 years to stop Micky mouse, Popeye, Looney tunes, tom and Jerry, felix the cat, etc and force animators to make action or action comedies
>>
>>
People want to avoid this, but the reason is because American shows are still beholden by American censorship standards which is poison for action cartoons, especially in a world with like three dozen new action anime shows a year.
When you have an action cartoon that can't show blood or use weapons or show sexy girls or have some adult elements, kids above like age 9 will see it as baby shit.
>>
>>
>>152340684
Too expensive and can’t be played episodically. Comedy shows with little budget were easier to greenlight. Also lore shows replaced action shows because they were very popular and profitable at the time. Now tv is dead. But the good news is that streaming has been greenlighting a lot of action shows.
>>
>>152342685
>>152340698
Why do some people think having fanservice would make action cartoons more popular? Look, I would love to see sexy cartoon women in something beyond off-model fanarts but sex doesn't sell as much as a plot (or the idea of a plot), cool characters and half decent fights. When people think on Dragon Ball they don't think about Bulma's bare tits. They think about Vegeta, Frieza, Majin Buu and the figths against them. When people remember Naruto they think about Itachi, Madara, Kakashi, etc. Tsunade the titty monster is basically a joke character. What action cartoons need is having a plot and giving people the idea of progress.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152343425
Tbh I don't remember sexy furry girls other than this >>152342484
Everything else is off-model art.
>>
>>
>>
File: image_2026-02-02_070622726.png (347.1 KB)
347.1 KB PNG
Anime appealed to pre-teen boys more
>>152342550
They probably going to do that eventually thanks to pic related's dominance
>>
>>
>>
File: 3534523.jpg (131.7 KB)
131.7 KB JPG
>>
File: the rube does some really cool shit.webm (2.9 MB)
2.9 MB WEBM
We'll get RWBY volume 10 soon at least.
>>
File: 1e2e8988158de80340038b9fa39a2a27.jpg (161.4 KB)
161.4 KB JPG
>>152343497
What meme? I prefer off-model because it improves the original design but it's a fact that there aren't cartoon girls with thick bodies and big tits.
>>
>>
Because they spend too much time catering to miserable old bags rather than boys. Can't have much action because a kid gets in a fight at school and Doris blames that cartoon she saw him watching last week. Don't want the complaints, don't want the potential legal action, don't want the expensive fight scenes.
Boys want more violence in their cartoons, their mothers want less (none). Nobody has a louder voice than the shrill, joyless cunt demographic, so here we are.
>>
File: 1757598718873025.gif (95.2 KB)
95.2 KB GIF
>>152340684
Mainly because action cartoons are expensive and by the early 2010s the more comedic and cheaper shows were getting higher ratings and were more easier to show reruns, so action cartoons got killed slowly. Also add on the fact that children don't buy toys as much in the 2010s and 20s compared to the 80s, 90s, and 00s so action cartoons weren't able to rely on toy sales to keep them going either. So unless your action cartoon is to promote a bigger ip like most DC and Marvel cartoons, or Arcane with League of Legends your not going to get funding. So like all things in show business its all about the money.
>>
File: 1769978921060.jpg (34.7 KB)
34.7 KB JPG
>>152343461
>>
>>
File: 1769979186824.jpg (174.8 KB)
174.8 KB JPG
>>152343425
>>
>>
>>152343361
I don't think >>152342685 was referring exclusively to fanservice, I think he just means content in general.
You take a typical modern shonen, and in terms of content it's comparable to a modern adult cartoon, which makes it a lot more appealing to a tween or teen.
>>
File: 1769161657733.jpg (46 KB)
46 KB JPG
>>152344020
Nobody remembers what 80s Thundercats actually looked like most of the time. It had good animation sometimes, but the intro was like a psyop.
>>
>>
>>152340785
I'm honestly surprised it took up until Gumball and Teen Titans Go! for CN to realize that 11-minute comedy shows were overall more profitable than action cartoons. As >>152343489 said, Nickelodeon had already noticed (with Spongebob) those worked much better than any expensive action cartoons.
Well, I guess they tried with stuff like Camp Lazlo and Chowder, but they failed to catch on.
>>
>>152344392
>As >>152343489 said, Nickelodeon had already noticed (with Spongebob) those worked much better than any expensive action cartoons.
I mean, has Nickelodeon had any action cartoons at all besides ATLA and Korra?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1740289021435.jpg (373.5 KB)
373.5 KB JPG
>>152340684
They went to tiktok
>>
>>152344392
Pretty sure CN already was prioritizing comedy over action in 2010 by mostly airing action stuff once or twice a week and playing shows like Adventure Time, Regular Show, Gumball, Johnny Test, etc. everyday. Hell, before Adventure Time and Regular Show had enough episodes to air everyday, there was a brief time in 2010-early 2011 where they relied on Kids Next Door reruns as a filler and Kids Next Door was a comedy as well.
>>
>>
>>
>>152340768
>>152340684
Tumblr basically
Everything is Tumblr's fault
>>
>>
>>152340684
their creators weren't getting or making new shows
>Genndy went off to make Hotel Transylvania for Sony, still made Samurai Jack S5, Primal, Unicorn Warriors
>Derick J. Wyatt's last relevant work was Ben 10 Omniverse and then he died in 2021
>Avatar crew made Korra (and it sucked) and then haven't made an animated project since
>McCracken (who isn't primarily an action guy) only made two major projects after leaving CN in '08
combined with the cheaper, easier-to-animate fixation of beanmouth and anime filling the demand for action cartoons, it's basically dead even though there's no good reason for that to be the case
>>
File: wario_gb.jpg (4.2 KB)
4.2 KB JPG
>>152340684
Obligatory "muh manga/anime" aside, people really underestimate the impact videogames had on boys' action cartoons. When you're a young teenage boy with too much energy and have the choice between
>sit still and watch cartoon about cool guy who does cool things
or
>play game and BE the cool guy and DO the cool things
the choice is obvious. Action cartoons always played into power fantasies, videogames just do that more hands-on.
>>
>>
>>
>>152346213
It's a vicious cycle. Guys preferring vidya to cartoons might not be innate, and I'd say most boys want both (or wanted). The problem is cartoons fail to satisfy where games do, so they watch cartoons less, so cartoons stop trying to appeal to them.
>>
>>152340785
>>152342194
You got to realize that CN's comedic originals (aside from TTGo) were outperforming them because CN actually promoted them and put them on decent times. They were blatantly playing favorites and ensuring that their stuff would take priority over third-party shows.
For instance, both Adventure Time and Scooby Doo: Mystery Inc. premiered around the same day and the latter had higher ratings than the former. The higher ups got pissed about this and starting fucking over MI with the schedule.
>>
>>152345564
>>152345854
Nah, they were episodic comedies. The thing with Adventure Time is that it stopped being episodic halfway through while Regular Show skewed too old and once Stuart Snyder left in 2014 you could tell the new management at CN resented the show and tried to bury it.
>>
>>
>>
>>152346583
Exactly: Add the fact that barely any man really fights for the revival of action cartoons anymore and you realize how successful videogames have been in completely usurping the action niche. When videogame developers stop catering to the male demographic, the outrage is much higher because men haven't moved on from the medium like they did with action cartoons.
>>
File: 1769979335447.jpg (24.5 KB)
24.5 KB JPG
>>152343425
>>
>>152340768
Wasn't Tron and Motorcity cancelled because they were banished to ungodly airing hours?
And iirc Generator Rex had bad toy sales. If it was the case of people watching AT and SU over it, we wouldn't have gotten Ben 10 Omniverse which lasted 8 season mind you.
>>
>>152346213
If cartoon producers were smart they would have tried to capitalize on that the way anime did by making animated video game tie-ins that aren't made by people who clearly fucking hate the original games, or at least making video games and using the money made from those games to make animated projects (ala Cygames).
Making all these shitty Netflix animated shows that shat all over the original source material did nothing to attract gamers, most of them just see a cartoon adaptation and immediately think "Oh, this is going to be shit made by people who hate video games."
Cartoons had plenty of opportunities to have some crossover with other industries outside of comics and they've fucked them up almost every single time because people who run the companies that produce cartoons in America have nothing but utter contempt for anything they didn't personally have a hand in making, and soulless MBA elites have never made anything of worth, so they hate all media.
>>
File: 1755454024271573.png (29.6 KB)
29.6 KB PNG
>>152346566
>Danny Phantom and My Life as a Teenage Robot weren't action cartoons
>Danny Phantom is basically a capeshit show for nickelodeon, and it and Teenage Robot had some sort of action in every episode like a fucking action cartoon.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152340684
Some of them got too far up their own ass and kinda lost the audience (Ben 10 Alien Forces, Samurai Jack s5? 4?). Nevermind that LORE shows get fucking boring.
But also, as the Billy & Mandy guy said, suits don't want proper villains anymore because even the villains are supposed to be "relatable" for kids or some shit like that. That kinda cripples the whole process.
That said, the second Max Steel show is a bit more recent and still had proper villains. Wasn't perfect, kinda ripped off Ben 10 and the designs weren't all that great, but hey, it exists.
>>
>>
>>152349584
Ben 10 alien force was setting CN records at the time the fuck you talking about? The live action movie broke every ratings metric it hate beating out the Clone wars. It was more popular ratings wise that the original eries.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
At some point the Californian animation friend circle decided all kids just need mundane gender neutral cartoons for entertainment. Boys decided they would just take their business elsewhere and discovered anime/Crunchyroll.
Now there's no real way to win them back with the current standards and quality in western animation aimed at kids, outside of bug expensive movies.
>>
>>
>>152342430
>>152342437
Because Gen X and early millennials consoom the fuck out of the merch of those franchises
>>
>>
>>152350433
>The live action movie broke every ratings metric
I mean, it IS one exceptionally good live action take on a cartoon, I don't get how most movies with huge budgets manage to fuck up so badly in comparison.
>>152351365
I think he's memeing
>>
>>
>>152350433
Bear in mind they gave away a custom Challenger via a phone number that would only air during the premiere and ran the shit out of the sweepstakes promo when you look at those ratings, no shade to the movie.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152351299
>>152346213
Video games have been around for decades and action cartoons didn't start dying out until the early 2010s.
Not to mention the obvious elephant in the room that the rise of video games has had no such effect on action anime, as tons of it is still pumped out on a yearly basis.
>>
>>
>>152340684
Japan liscenced a bunch of action anime really cheap to the US around the time of Pokémon, making it less financially promising to fund american action cartoons. Ceos had a why bother kind of attitude.
Parent groups also complained, saying action cartoons were unsafe for kids.
And nicktoons orginally started without action cartoons. Disney afternoon also phased them out right around the gun control episode of gargoyles.
There was also a push to bring in more female viewers and for whatever reason, ceos think that means more talking and less animation. This ignores that most diehard nerdy women love action characters and usually pick them for cosplay.
>>
>>152340785
>Making action cartoon is expensive. These shows all existed to sell toys first and foremost and when kids stopped buying toys they lost their main source of financing
Kids want and buy toys. The bigger issue is that inflation makes money not go as far and also encourages parents to attempt to replace toys by giving their old iphones and touch bads to their kids as some sort of trick to get out of buying their kid toys.
So it isnt that kids dont want oe buy toys. The problem is adults.
>>
>>
>>
>>152344392
>Well, I guess they tried with stuff like Camp Lazlo and Chowder, but they failed to catch on.
Anon, nick has known this since day 1 of nick toons. That whole orginal block was suppose to be comedy for kids. Snick was entirely stuff cheap to make. Comedy cartoons depend mostly on dialog and almost static shots with mouths and eye movement. Maybe some exaggerated reactions that are still cheaper to animate than a fist fight. The live action shows either used like 1 set or was dirt cheap like the kid horror are you afraid of the dark. Pete and Pete depended on cheap actors and relatively C and B grade actors that were doing it for artistic reasons.
Nick historically liscenced moat of their action cartoons with Avatar, Invader Zim and teenage robot being exceptions
>>
>>152346213
>When you're a young teenage boy with too much energy and have the choice between
>>sit still and watch cartoon about cool guy who does cool things
>or
>>play game and BE the cool guy and DO the cool things
>the choice is obvious. Action cartoons always played into power fantasies, videogames just do that more hands-on
There were action games for like 20, 30 years before the west gave up on action cartoons
>>
>>152340684
Okay, how the fuck was Animaniacs expensive to produce if that was a comedy cartoon? Usually comedies are cheaper to make than action shows, but Animaniacs was about as expensive to make as action shows were.
>>
>>152352048
You are
>>152352084
Not just that, fag
>>
>>
>>152346761
Letting creatives that hate the source material and either mock it or covertly change the show into their personal fanfixtion, only reusing names because theh are contractorly forced to isnt a peoblem specific to action cartoons. It plagues just about every property older than 20 years. Dorks out of savannah georgia imagine themselves to be the next Walt Disney or John K and dont want to make shows for other people's ideas
>>
>>
>>
>>152352631
>Okay, how the fuck was Animaniacs expensive to produce if that was a comedy cartoon? Usually comedies are cheaper to make than action shows, but Animaniacs was about as expensive to make as action shows were.
Too many irons in the fire. All those writers got paid. Steven Spielberg probably got a check for having his name on it. Think the backgrounds were still done in the US too
>>
>>152342430
>>152342437
>Transformers
>TMNT
If you cut out everyone born before 1990, those two franchises would literally fucking die overnight.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152352708
>Letting creatives that hate the source material and either mock it or covertly change the show into their personal fanfixtion, only reusing names because theh are contractorly forced to isnt a peoblem specific to action cartoons.
Geez anon, you might want to adjust your keyboard.
But yea, that's true, I don't disagree, I was more talking about the aspect of having a crossover with video games or other industries, it's a lot harder for cartoons because there historically hasn't been as much crossover and because a lot of the people working in cartoon types are Hollywood types who give no fucks about anything they didn't have a hand in making, because they're narcissists.
>>
>>
>>
>>152353634
Video games have had serviceable visuals that could emulate the look and feel of cartoons since the early 90s.
I know this is hard to understand for a zoomer such as yourself, but pixel art has been more than enough for that for decades, and pixel art has been capable of looking great since arcades in the fucking 80s with games like Outrun.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 800px-Earthspark-AOE1-SayCheese.jpg (62.1 KB)
62.1 KB JPG
>>152344337
There's still some stuff like Primal.
But the action cartoons you find on major networks nowadays are very, I'm not sure how to put it, soft I guess.
Like they don't actually want to make cool characters and they're going out of their way to make the characters as uncool as they can get way with.
Look at the latest Transformers cartoon, did they genuinely think they could sell toys with designs like these?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1770062809607.jpg (44.7 KB)
44.7 KB JPG
>>152351280
I'm pretty sure that the Centurions counts as an action cartoon.
>>
>>152340684
Action cartoons kind of sucked, anon. They are all about fighting but they can't actually show fighting because that would make parents uneasy. They have no idea how to sell action, only toys, so once the toy market dried up the shows no longer had a reason to exist.
There is no passion or pride in action cartoons. What modern action focused cartoons we do manage to get are infested with cynicism, and a certain baseline level of disrespect for the source material where they can never afford to let you forget that you're too old to be enjoying this stuff anymore but we'll look past that wink wink nudge nudge.
Meanwhile, anime with no budget can sell action just fine. No flashy energy blasts or particular effects or dizzying camera flips needed.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HBAvbMkK0f8
Tojima wants to be a Kamen Rider is a stupid show. Its plot is dumb and its often more comedy than it is action. But you know what I can tell you for certain? The people who made this show *love Kamen Rider*, and thats more than I can say for any western action cartoon trying to adapt any source material.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TTPYIRUffA
>>
>>
>>
File: foid.jpg (56.6 KB)
56.6 KB JPG
>>152340684
Instead of watching cartoons, boys are playing more video games, especially mobile games. Also, the industry has been invaded by women, so even the theatrical stuff is for girls now.
>>
>>
>>
File: Zombie fight.webm (2.5 MB)
2.5 MB WEBM
>>152340684
Probably my most guilty pleasure action cartoon series from my area of time as a kid that has sadly never went into popularity.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152354678
Yea, a lot of these shows seem to be more like "action shows you want your kids to watch" in the mind of adults, which automatically makes them extremely fucking lame for any actual kids.
No 10 year old wants a show that's made with their annoying mom's tastes in mind.
>>
Kids are too busy on their TikTok. They also refuse to socialize.
Same applies to /co/. We should kick out all gen-alphas including the bad side of gen-Z who kept sucking trannycock. /co/mblr has always been known for its leftist opinions compared to the other boards.
If /co/ was /co/ and not a bunch of trannies then everyone would be doing vid related.
but trannies don't like cartoons or anything really, all they like is gay sex, to hate on women and to complain about the world while being a tranny. And the other portion are browns who don't buy toys and can't finance cartoons.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzUckHYc2No
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152340684
>kids are (were?) buying fewer toys (now it's more about "merch" rather than toys, but I guess that includes a few toys too)
>rise in "grrrl power" for the sake of "grrrl power", meaning shows might have a female lead with nothing going on for her and turns off viewers unless she's hot (she often isn't)
>action figures in general are falling apart due to kids playing "real" games on their phones and not needing to have to play pretend; action figures are the main reason a lot of action shows exist, so without them, there's not much draw to make them
>"toxic masculinity" being something most people on the left (aka, most writers in The Industry) avoid like it's made of feces and uranium, leading to cancellation of various shows, or the softening of reboots
>children's media dying in general as more people move to Youtube and TikTok
>knockoffs are eating up what's left of the action figure / toy sales
>violence is banned a lot of the time, even cartoony slapstick isn't completely safe
>fighting in general, even cartoonier, blood-free stuff, is banned a lot of the time because it can be imitated
>>152340820
Most "strong women" are crammed into that position artificially, and kept there too, IRL.
In the case of fictional media, the strong woman character will often be an insufferable cunt too, as she outperforms all the men who then run off crying (or they die / get captured / etc.)
Plus it's not like strong men can do anything about strong women, any well-raised man knows not to hurt a woman in any way, whether they deserve it or not, whereas most "strong women" will just go ahead and chuck the men under any bus they can whenever possible.
I mean obviously not everyone's like this, but it's common enough to be an issue.
>>
>>
File: Super_Friends.jpg (24.8 KB)
24.8 KB JPG
>>152354780
>quality of fights is what makes an action cartoon
Doesn't make sense if you look at the history of action cartoons.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152356006
At one point before you were born, toys were a way to see cool characters "doing" things, fighting monsters, saving cities, whatever.
Nowadays, if you want to see shit fight, you download the tie-in game on your phone, or have your parents buy the $70 shovelware of it and play it yourself.
>>
>>
>>
File: marvel-super-hero-squad.png (1.8 MB)
1.8 MB PNG
>>152355875
Super Friends wasn't an action cartoon
>b-but it had fights
No one calls Marvel Superhero Squad and Teen Titans GO action cartoons just because they had fights
>>
>>152355684
I feel like there's a midpoint between toxic masculinity and crying about your feefees.
The concept of "Being a real man" is a corrosive one because it creates stunted, hollow human beings. The same goes for daycare bullshit that cannot discuss real issues in a mature way.
What we need is something in between that manages to discuss issues in a mature, thoughtful, and understandable way that speaks to the actual human experience
>>
>>152356169
You like being disingenuous huh? Next you'll say all those toy cartoons from the 80s aren't action either.
>>
File: Still-from-Teen-Titans-Go.jpg (88.6 KB)
88.6 KB JPG
>>152356196
If that is the case, what is the point of this thread? We have this super successful action cartoon with over 400 episodes and two movies
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152356193
The issue is "toxic masculinity" should and does mean shit like beating/raping women, drinking too much beer, punching holes in walls, cussing everywhere, getting into fights, shooting huge guns in places not meant for that, etc.
...but instead the media just labels masculinity itself as toxic.
Lifting weights? Toxic.
Wanting to be straight? Toxic.
Owning any gun? Toxic.
Standing your ground and shooting a home invader? Toxic.
>>
>>152351325
>Now there's no real way to win them back with the current standards and quality in western animation aimed at kids
I mean there is, but that would require the people who brought us to this point to admit they were wrong.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: FEJxYMeX0AE0mUp.jpg (85.3 KB)
85.3 KB JPG
Anons have all provided valid reasons like vidya and the internet and falling toy sales or just the fact that there's not as many kids anymore but I think another core distinction is that showrunners from that era wrote cartoons KIDS would like to watch while showrunners from Korra (And Korra was the cutoff point) onward write cartoons THEY would like to watch.
And they don't get punished for it cause they're nepo babies and the whole cartoon was a tax writeoff anyway so who gives a shit if kids would rather be on they phone instead of watching le accurate panic attack for the millionth time.
>>
>>152356649
There’s a massive difference between confidence and an utter lack of emotions or ability to connect with other people, which is what I’m talking about.
Stuff like American Psycho is an example of true toxic masculinity because it depicts a man who refuses to connect with others
>>
>>152356659
I disagree. I feel like children need to be inched away from anime and cheap flashy stuff so they can accept something better.
Force them to watch Garouden over Demon Slayer, thus forcing them to watch slower paced and more well choreographed fights.
Ban the Spider Verse movies and brainrot content
>>
>>
>>152356743
If you want them to watch the good stuff you need to provide it. You can't expect a kid to go from watching something like JJK to watching Transformers Prime or TMNT or some other very kiddy show.
Kids watch that stuff because other kids at school tell them about them, usually because it has stuff that their parents wouldn't want them seeing, so kids watch it because it's the "cool stuff" that other kids tell them about that their parents wouldn't want them to see.
>>
>>152356732
>Ban the Spider Verse movies and brainrot content
Anon that pandora's box has been opened and there's no turning back now.
I have no doubt corpos would've replaced cartoons with flashing images back in the day if they could get away with it but they still had to face some accountability. There was the FCC and angry soccer moms to answer to. Now that there's no way to regulate online content it's optimized without ethical constraints and you can't roll that back with anything short of a total internet blackout.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152356829
>Something legitimately cooler
Like what? JJK is shit but it sells the idea of coolness just like Naruto and Bleach sold the idea of worldbulding and good characters in the 2000s when, in reality, there were trash. Like Megamind said: presentation.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Starfire.jpg (45.7 KB)
45.7 KB JPG
>>152356997
Yes
>>
>>
>>152340785
The fucking sad how every western cartoon since 2020 is about feels, divorce trauma and lesbians.
>>152340785
The problem is cartoons are always 100% original productions, ignoring lots of books in Public domain (before of 1920), stage plays and comics (No Marvel-DC), for an adaptation. The problem is when modern cartoons get hype with periods of inconsequential episodic; people expect a huge wait of 6 weeks between episodes and years between seasons.
>>
>>
File: amane_kanata_5.jpg (254.8 KB)
254.8 KB JPG
>>152357025
That ugly shit doesn't look like it's for adults. Can you even make something of quality like pic related? Anything less than this looks like shit.
>>
File: 1.jpg (206.8 KB)
206.8 KB JPG
>>152357072
Anime statuettes exist, your post doesn't have a point.
>>
>>152357152
>>152356997
Imagine thinking this shit is made "for adults" and not for people who are mentally 15.
>>
>>
>>
>>152357152
>>152357025
That a inherent problem with cartoons, they are designed are for be easier to draw for the animators, most are huge heads with 1-pixel arms and "Clothes" are geometric shapes.
Anime clothes are made by a tailor, following the proportions of real humans
>>
>>152357152
>>152357177
What kind of people buy this?
>>
File: 5.jpg (205.3 KB)
205.3 KB JPG
>>152357217
Not western animation, westerners want people who are physically 8 year olds. Anime targets people who are physically over the age of 30 and have money
>>
>>
>>152357217
>>152357243
You deserve your dead industry, FAGGOT
>>
>>152356997
I understand this one. Evangelion is iconic and Rei is an interesting character.
>>152357152
>>152357177
>>152357279
But shit like this is for subhumans
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152356429
>>152356628
>>152356670
Toxic Masculinity is like Retarded. What it is meant to describe is obvious, but in the never-ending arms race of internet hyperbole any infraction, no matter how minor, gets the nuclear option as the method of first resort.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152357550
It's generally a pittance, most of the actual money comes from retail sales and deals with publishing/licensing companies, usually related to existing source material sales.
It's why a studio like A-1 lost money on Solo Leveling even though it was one of the most-streamed shows ever on Crunchyroll.
>>
>>152357152
>>152357177
what's the point of collecting these other than having your older relatives think that you are a faggot that plays with dolls?
>>
>>
File: macross chogokin line.jpg (156.4 KB)
156.4 KB JPG
>>152357217
>>152357279
The anime figures market honestly highlights how strong anime as a medium manages to be. Yes, the manga and shows themselves are aimed at a teen to young adult audience. Those kids could never afford a $300 figure of their anime waifu. But the adults with disposable income who also like the show, or are years later STILL invested enough int heir favorite series to buy something from a show that they liked when they were younger, can buy those things.
Gunpla serves an important normalization role here. They are cheaper, seen as a not unusual hobby, and make the idea of having anime figures less unusual by normalizing the idea of kids building plastic robots. And then you get older and you're spending hundreds of dollars on metal-jointed chogokins.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: dixrtkj-b102f5c1-1f2d-481d-8e62-48bfeb17d63b.png (351.7 KB)
351.7 KB PNG
>A lost art
not really
>>
>>152357729
Holy fucking shit you're fucking retarded, it's not just the exclusivity. We don't need more faggots like >152357243 or >152357186 to tell us how figs are le bad and try to censor them. It's best if normalfags simply don't know
It's genuinely baffling how retarded your post is
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152357881
>>152357895
>>152357913
> Just over a minute apart each
Probably nothing.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 91nunbvU04L._AC_UF1000,1000_QL80_.jpg (227.1 KB)
227.1 KB JPG
>>152356908
>>
>>
>>
I think the actual reason is that the main audience, young boys, moved to video games. The viewership just isn't there anymore. The love for it is, as you can tell by how much coverage and love the old greats get on YouTube and TikTok and the like, but cartoons in general don't turn much of a profit these days anyway, let alone cartoons for a market that almost doesn't exist anymore.
>>
>>152359469
>he love for it is, as you can tell by how much coverage and love the old greats get on YouTube and TikTok and the like
Don't mistake millennial content creators still dicksucking ATLA like its high art for some kind of indicator of what the target audience of today wants. Thats just nostalgia with a platform.
>>
>>152359463
That's pretty typical of isekai in general since it's usually aimed at a Japanese audience and tends to be almost exclusively watched by Asians.
Personally, I find it kinda funny when white people and Americans get mad about shit like slavery or when isekaiman just wants to grill dangit.
>>
>>152359586
It is definitely high art and nostalgia isn't an invalid form of support. The reason Korra failed is because people wanted something that meets the standards ATLA set. The reason both live action ATLAs failed is because they weren't nearly as good as the cartoon. It's not a riddle, anon. In addition to that, look at how popular shounen anime is and always has been. There's no way you could reasonably say the young male audience doesn't want fighting cartoons, but anime is willing to write stories that the west is afraid to.
>>
>>152359671
People don't get on MT's case for slavery. They get on MT's case for it being actual pedophilia. A 40 year old man, who sees himself as a 40 year man in his head, groping young girls and who was kicked out of his house after his family found the camera he installed in the bathroom to spy on his 8 year old niece.
Like, there's no ambiguity about it. The only way he could be more of a pedo was if he was if he went to Epstein island. But the story just sort of asks that you brush that off and forget about it.
>>
>>152359737
The pedo grandstanding has become kind of toothless now that we know without a doubt that the entire power structure of the western world is run by pedophiles being blackmailed by the king of pedos.
It's mostly just noise at this point, kinda like bitching about a show being "mean-spirited" and other dumb shit.
>>
>>152359737
I only watched the first season, but isn't the point of the story that the guy gets a second chance at a life he never had? I'm not oblivious to him being an actual adult (and canonically a perverted porn addict) but emotionally and mentally he might not have aged past his middle/high school years. He's stunted. Definitely weird either way, though.
>>
File: images.jpg (47.8 KB)
47.8 KB JPG
Action cartoons never went away. You just kept watching channels that don't make them currently.
>>
>>152359714
> There's no way you could reasonably say the young male audience doesn't want fighting cartoons, but anime is willing to write stories that the west is afraid to.
I don't disagree with that at all. I will got to bat any day of the week for the weird, hyper-specific anime that could never be made in the west because they are too weird, too ambitious, or too niche. But that doesn't negate the fact that there are a lot of people who grew up with ATLA and just... never grew beyond it. Yes, its good, but its not SO good that it should still be your primary point of reference for good storytelling 20 years later.
>>
>>152359112
Good point
>>152359469
...And not even good ones
>>
>>
>>
>>152359818
>but its not SO good that it should still be your primary point of reference for good storytelling 20 years later.
Yes, it is. To this day I don't see much children's media that comes close to atla's complexity. It's superior to much adult media and mogs the entire young adult genre. Cartoons today hope they could be a fraction of what atla is.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1557137343279.jpg (27.6 KB)
27.6 KB JPG
Anime. Action cartoons used to capture kids, tweens and teens. But then anime came in and was better and different. A lot of people like Samurai Jack but I always kind of hated it because I knew it was ment for kids and would never show any actual violence or have any real stakes due to it's re-run format. Anime on the other hand had tons of action and violence, even the tamer ones like Pokemon. Sex is a big thing too since anime does not skimp on the sex. Even the animes aimed at tweens still have lots of lewd moments almost as if they are trying to get some middle school boy his first hard on.
The ending arch format helps a ton too. It means anime is constantly evolving. New shows will have to replace old ones. When you look at it there are VERY few long running animes compared to how many new animes come out every year. Anime seems very much built for this as well. They do not make series to last forever it seems while the west LOVES to milk their shows and IP to the ground.
>>
>>152360383
>while the west LOVES to milk their shows and IP to the ground.
This was nowhere near as bad 10-15 years ago as it is now.
CN from basically 1998 to 2015 produced a lot of new shows almost every year, but post-2015 there's been very little, and things have gotten so bad that every major cartoon network is now pushing endless reboots and spinoffs because they can't get anyone to give a fuck about their new offerings.
And the sad part is, it's not even working, Nickelodeon already cancelled the shitty Rugrats reboot and that CG Spongebob spinoff.
>>
>>
>>152340684
This isn't related to OP's question but I have to ask if anyone knows if an artist draws these thumbnails. I've seen this style so much on those youtube videos with "What if Character Were Charged for their Crimes?" and it feels so weirdly AI. They claim it's not, but they don't credit who the artist is, so it's hard to gage how truthful they are.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152360576
>Ben 10 Classic had a lot of underwhelming fighting scenes
I don't remember any satisfacting big cartoon fight.
>Aang vs Ozai ended with the Avatar state coming back because of a random rock plus the asspull bending
>Zuko wasn't allowed to beat Azula
>The DCAU ended with Superman losing (again)
>Every S5 Samurai Jack fight
Etc.
>>
>>152360733
If you can't survive in a competitive environment, the problem isn't the competition. Getting rid of anime won't make cartoons any better. If anything they might get worse, because they can afford to be even lower quality.
>>
>>
>>
>>152360383
>would never show any actual violence or have any real stakes due to it's re-run format.
This is why comics are unable to beat manga. Yes, there is violence but there aren't real stakes in a medium where the status quo is god
>>
>>
>>152355195
>They are all about fighting but they can't actually show fighting because that would make parents uneasy.
I'm so sick of soccer moms forcing cartoons specifically to follow their narrow idea what a cartoon is. They'll let their kid shoot people in Fortnite or Call of Duty, but heaven forbid Spider-Man punch a crook.
>>
>>
>>
>>152361166
Better, actually. The guy who did the PSG soundtrack and others *volunteered* to do the sound track for this show, because he's a big kamen rider fan. This is a studio he's not normally contracted with, but he wanted to be part of the project.
It certainly gives each of the characters a.... unique theme song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4wSvcOJhOc
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152340684
>expensive to animate it well enough that it doesnt look like shit
>violence bad. Everyone having impromptu therapy sessions to vomit all their problems (the writers childhood whininess they never got over) good
>appeals to boys not girls and that means your show isnt diverse enough
>anyones that try just ripoff anime fight scenes rather than come up with their own
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>"shit guys we're losing viewership to anime and videogames how do we fix this"
>"maybe by being less strict with censorship and allow more violence and hot girls in cartoons aimed at teens?"
>"more cool original stories that aren't written by dykes only for themselves?"
>"more animation aimed at adults that aren't just shitty comedies? it's working for invincible"
>"NAH let's just do more calarts for babies and faux-anime that neither anime fans nor western animation fans like"
BRILLIANT
>>
>>
>>
>>152340684
Action cartoons cost more. Action cartoons originally existed to drive toy sales, but then they started to cut the cost of the cartoons and then the toy sales suffered. And because less toys sold, they cut the budgets of the cartoons. And then the toy sales suffered and then they cut the budgets of the cartoons again. Repeat, repeat, repeat, until no more action cartoons. Or, eventually, just no more cartoons period.
>>
>>
>>152356743
if you want to prevent that, then cartoons should do something more than say a witty one liner every time they punch a person through a wall. the worst anime is 10x better than action cartoons aimed at kids
>>
>>152362884
watch gundam iron blooded orphans
https://youtu.be/4pubMc45G6c
>>
File: HAF9BmRW0AAEsY-.jpg (111.5 KB)
111.5 KB JPG
>>152357582
>creating a character like Albedo and openly target horny adult white males too
Culture of prudism. Think of the children, Its Overt Sexualization, Problematic, pushes unrealistic body standards.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152361273
Sometimes I think half the reason that anime is beating cartoons in popularity is that they just have better soundtracks. Music matters. Music creates emotional attachment and if you like a track enough to listen to it beyond the show it was in, you're still thinking about that show.
>>
File: Popeye vs Sinbad.webm (4 MB)
4 MB WEBM
>>152360983
>>
>>
>>
>>152364139
What do you define as a fight? Popeye is an action-comedy. There’s real weight and impact; you can feel the punches that Sinbad and Popeye throw. They also make strong use of the environment, along with depth and perspective. Are there fight scenes that are better than this? Absolutely. But that doesn’t change the fact that this is still a fight scene.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1716687317679.webm (2 MB)
2 MB WEBM
>>152364214
>There’s real weight and impact; you can feel the punches that Sinbad and Popeye throw
You can't.
>They also make strong use of the environment, along with depth and perspective
It's nothing compared to thing like webm related.
>>
>>
>>152364247
>>152364433
You are a huge faggot
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152364417
As I said, there are better fight scenes than the Sinbad one, but that does not detract from the fact that it's still a fight scene. DBZ is an action series; of course, it's going to have better action overall.
>>
>>
>>
File: adventurepedo.jpg (87.8 KB)
87.8 KB JPG
>>152364453
>>
File: 1732913262640.mp4 (2.9 MB)
2.9 MB MP4
>>152364417
Come on, man, you’re being disingenuous. The reason the hits feel harder in the Dragon Ball clip is because of the flashes; if you added those same flashes to the Popeye clip, the impact would feel just as strong. Both scenes also use the environment in similar ways. Buu burrows underground, and Popeye burrows as well.
>>
>>
File: sword training.webm (2.9 MB)
2.9 MB WEBM
>>152364658
I don't even think the people bringing this up are even DBZ fans, to be honest. DBZ is just still the go-to point of reference for anime for people who don't watch any anime. Its not like we don't have much more recent points of reference for anime fights, the fact that they are falling back on such old pop culture reference material says they don't know anything else.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VsSdf7Jz6mc
>>
>>152340698
>>152340700
>>152343361
Young justice had these one momwnt being one of the best most supriskng and obvious pant shots in animation but the show it feels kind of odd. It feels different than like teen titans and it wasn't really promoted or watched alot the same way and the feels its kind of off and it is cool they could be edgy for 13 up but still watched for i guess 10 up and then season 3 becoming mature along with the audience from before.but it still feels off for some reason and isn't really promoted as big as some shows
>>
File: RCO006_1476979559_1.png (2.2 MB)
2.2 MB PNG
>>152364841
>Young Justice
It was a shitshow. It had potential but the writers killed the show after the first season.
>>
File: 1706842065123.webm (3.6 MB)
3.6 MB WEBM
>>152364658
>If you post examples of interesting fights you are "cringey"
DBZ is just the most popular action show ever. There is nothing wrong with using it as example. And there are endless examples that could be used. There is nothing like this in western animation. The use of multiple camera angles alone puts this above every action cartoon ever made.
>>
>>
>>152340684
the iPhone and the internet replaced toys and TV for kids, so the networks adapted to their existing audience of millennial queers. Even independent animation like Space King is marketed for maladjusted millennials of the other political bend. Shartoons die with Millennials.
>>
>>152363332
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dhfg4nr6P8o
The Bobbycola scene (HIP HIP HOORAH!) since this is the End of Evangelion of cartoons
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152367079
>>152367146
Sorry, too expensive and not enough toy sales apparently. Enjoy another 5 years of TTG
>>
>>
>>
>>152367241
But the merch sales, think about the merch sales.
And if it doesn't do that, it's not worth investing in.
Also animation is very expensive, so clearly it's not worth making anymoreThat's what all you sound like, anime deserves to be on top purely out of not forgetting its audience
>>
>>
>>152364017
>>152364606
I love Popeye, I really do, But do not for a fucking second act like Popeye's animation at all represents what action animation should be like. This is like using Looney Tunes as a study for action scenes. Fucking Tom and Jerry would be a better example if only to show the weight and character animation to make you feel like it hurt
>>
>>
File: GTm0nptWEAAl1d_.jpg (89.7 KB)
89.7 KB JPG
I've said this in a previous thread, but I've seen kids rave about anime like Demon Slayer, JJK, MHA ect
I've also seen kids get attached to live action movies, even outside of the MCU, like Predator Badlands and John Wick
The audience for action never went away, the industry DROVE them away. And I see countless excuses like those in this thread about shit like "muh budgets" and "it's too hard"
Sure, action shows for adults exist now, but those don't fill the same space and won't reach the same audience, with Invincible being the closest exception, but being gated off not because of the gore, but because some of the characters fuck, and say fuck.
To say nothing about how things like Transformers and TMNT have been mishandled
Every wound in the western action animated series sphere is self inflicted, and I can't be bothered to mourn it anymore
>>
>>
>>
File: 1740529953596.png (145.2 KB)
145.2 KB PNG
>>152352373
Toy manufacturing got priced out significantly beyond inflation by the rising quality of life in China
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152367669
You'd be shocked/depressed how out of touch and stupid they are
It says a lot when fucking K-Pop Demon Hunters is the only western thing that understands this, and Sony dumped it on Netflix expecting it to flop
>>
>>152367702
Okay, here we go. In a story I wrote, there's an entire sequence where a farmer gets shot in the face by an "Invading army" repeatedly.
Except it doesn't do anything beyond confuse and annoy him. He gets up, holding his weird-ass harvesting tool, and starts shouting at them to piss off.
This random guy yelling at them to stop making noise just tanked a gunshot to the face.
His entire species is this durable minimum. It makes sense if you read the rest, considering he's this weird smooth stone construct man.
>>
>>152367714
>Kpop Demon Hunters
I fucking hate that movie because it's a fusion of everything I don't like
>Flashy visuals
>Kpop
>"Demon hunting" done by people who ARE demonic in reality
The movie would've been better if it was about an office lady who had dreams of being an idol going up against corporate demons.
>>
>>
>>152367801
>>152367769
To be completely honest I'm frustrated with my own writing because I can't think of anything that someone hasn't already done before.
I almost subconsciously refuse to do anything "Original" because I don't respect my own creative abilities enough. It HAS to look like something that isn't mine or else it's shit, says my subconscious mind, and I don't know how to get out of it.
>>
>>152340684
Being outcompeted by anime was a big part. As a kid you would watch action cartoons half-designed by executive committee, approved by censors, and written by hacks who wish they were doing movie scripts or bestselling novels instead where they'd be shooting "stun" laser guns that never kill anyone before the main character says "violence never solves anything! don't do drugs". then you'd wait a few hours and watch Piccolo get his arm fucking blown off before he does a manly scream and regenerates a new one, and kid you would be like "holy shit!"
I'm sure the animators of the former could have made something really awesome, but everything else in the American system worked against them hard, whereas auteurs in Japan got off much more easily
>>
>>
I have this pitch for an action cartoon, but it's hard to explain because it doesn't really ascribe to anything familiar within the fantasy genre, which is the closest approximation to whatever madness I put down.
I genuinely cannot think of a concise way to explain any of it.
>>
>>
>>152367784
Nice pitch, make it a hot office lady and you have internet gold going on there, Japan would be all over it
>>152367966
>green and purple villain formula
...huh
>>152364417
Ironically, DB peaked at the very first arc and maybe until the first tournament.
>>
>>152368108
Uhhhh.... How do I put this?
>Takes place in this weird-ass plane of existence that's like half-megastructure, half-ecosystem, and so on. It's called the Abyss.
>Populated by all these weird-ass creatures and anomalies. Half of the fun is seeing what insane shit happens next.
>We follow a species called the Constructs. Constructs are these weird near-faceless humanoid horned stone-people. Their appearance is hard to describe, but they have glowing joints, spherical heads, glowing eyes, half-glowing horns, and are made of this smooth near-black stone.
>They have an entire culture and shit, and we get to see a lot of it
>More importantly, we follow a Construct doctor as he tries to find a cure for an illness that's been plaguing his people
>1/3rd character building, 1/3rd worldbuilding, 1/3rd insane bullshit, like a guy carving building sized statues with his kicks, or a guy literally squeezing snow so hard that it becomes solid ice, which he then hurls hard enough to blow a hole in a wall, or a guy just having a boat that goes on land.
And so on
>>
>>
>>152368160
>make it a hot office lady
No. If you want something really big she should be average (or even kind of ugly) but endearing. She would get progressively more attractive after gaining confidence and power ups
>>
>>
File: 1759218990456527.jpg (145.6 KB)
145.6 KB JPG
>>152367784
>The movie would've been better if it was about an office lady who had dreams of being an idol going up against corporate demons.
>>152368160
>Nice pitch, make it a hot office lady and you have internet gold going on there, Japan would be all over it
>>152368245
>If you want something really big she should be average (or even kind of ugly) but endearing. She would get progressively more attractive after gaining confidence and power ups
So basically, pic related.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Johl.jpg (747.8 KB)
747.8 KB JPG
>>152368268
I know nothing about that manga but I don't like the artstyle. I was thinking about a development like this
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Screen-Shot-2021-07-16-at-4.19.52-PM.png (825.9 KB)
825.9 KB PNG
>>152369348
Same difference. Popeye is as much action as Bugs Bunny vs Elmer Fudd is, not to say you can't take principles from it, but action is not something it was ever concerned with, it's especially egregious when the Superman shorts done by the same studio are right there
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152369448
I disagree. The action in a Bugs Bunny short and a Popeye short is fundamentally different. Both are comedic, but one leans much more heavily into action. When Bugs and Sam, or many other Looney Tunes characters, hit each other, it’s usually a single quick gag. When Popeye and Bluto fight, though, there’s real choreography to it, a back and forth. It’s not meant to be taken super seriously, but it still delivers a high-octane feeling. Until the Superman shorts of the 40s, if you wanted genuine action in cartoons, Popeye was really your only option.
https://youtu.be/1NlPCBFgzSY?si=Hn148O_f3QnOpE08&t=202
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152369829
Considering that the story wasted so much time on him, yes
Naruto spends a fuckton of time on characters that end up serving no purpose, so all the time spent on them ends up feeling like padding and filler.
>>
>>152369728
You're missing a very important core factor here. Action has stakes, that's what makes it exciting, you should feel a chance the character can lose at any time if they aren't careful. Popeye sometimes flirts with the idea of Popeye getting his knocked around by Bluto or whoever the villain of the short is, but you as an audience member know Popeye won't lose. And the reason why there were no real action shorts before Superman, was because they literally hadn't figured it out yet, it wasn't until 1937 with Snow White did they show how to make realistic humans move around to make it work. Popeye might've been a stepping stone, but it is not an action series, and even for what it did do, again I'd argue Tom and Jerry did more with making you feel the impact of a hit.
>>
>>152369855
>characters that end up serving no purpose
Whenever I read people on /co/ try to talk about writing or story or characters I'm glad you guys will never make anything, because you genuinely do not seem to understand how a story works.
>>
File: 1729958226033.webm (2.9 MB)
2.9 MB WEBM
>>152369769
You just reminded me of this.
>>
>>152369832
Its more that males are ceding influence to them. The only reason for example so much literature gets aimed at women is men just don't read anymore even for fun, and stuff like that is barely being kept afloat.
>>
>>
>>152369878
>is men just don't read anymore even for fun
But that's not even true, there's tons of fiction literature aimed at men coming out of countries like China, Japan, and Korea.
The issue is that American publishers choose to publish almost exclusively books aimed at women, so when you go to B&N and you want to pick up a fantasy book your only options are romantasy for women, old mainstays like Tolkien, or a light novel published by a company owned by Asians.
>>
>>
>>152369870
True, action does need stakes to build suspense; a show like BTAS blows the Popeye shorts out of the water when it comes to action. But the idea that “we know Popeye won’t lose, so there are no stakes” is flawed. Of course, we know he won’t lose; he’s the main character. But the same can be said for other series. We all know that if a major comic-book character dies, they’ll eventually come back, but that doesn’t erase the tension while it’s happening. We know Popeye will get his spinach, but the journey is the destination. The ending may be the same, yet how we get there is what matters. The Fleischer Superman shorts also end with Superman winning and saving the day every time. Would you really argue that means they have no real suspense or action? I see Popeye more as action-comedy, leaning more toward comedy than action, but still offering a level of energy that other shorts at the time didn’t have. Though there are outliers as seen here >>152369875 Popeye felt different, until Superman came along and showed how true action animation could be done.
>>
>>
>>
>>152370084
It's a very different kind of thing anon. Even comedies have stakes, even if minor or undermined, the difference is how they're treated. Yes, Popeye has something to lose if the bad guy wins, and yes, there is some idea of loss, otherwise it wouldn't feel satisfying at all when he wins. But Superman in contrast is a lot more grounded of a setting, helped by the character design being more realistic, this points the audience that rules aren't the same and there's more of a chance somebody could be injured or die
Popeye is a stepping stone, that much I'll concede, but it's not concerned with action, its action is in service of the slapstick. And again, part of the reason for that is because action and drama in animation requires realisitcally proportioned humans, which they couldn't do that scale until Snow White, and still needed a few more years before we got Superman.
>>
>>
Western animation refuses to divide itself by age and gender
Anime has shonen for boys, shojo for girls, seinen for men, and josei for women.
The west doesn't know how to write for one specific demographic anymore.
>>
>>
>>152370408
The west USED to do this, but now there aren't really any "boy" or "girl" shows anymore, it's all the same "appeal to everyone" gray slop.
Think about it, there's no real "girls" cartoons anymore either, not really, the most recent MLP being a good example of this, with its many, MANY, problems, one of the biggest was it not being girly ENOUGH, and outright being ashamed of its roots that even G4 found time to embrace in characters like Rarity. Even Barbie, was more of a movie focused on adult women rather than girls
This is why Kpop Demon Hunters was such a fucking hit, because it fed a whole generation of girls something that what used to be reliable sources of it (Disney, Hasbro, Mattel), stopped serving it to them.
Fuck, even anime is serving this audience better, it might not be as dramatic, but My Melody and Kuromi, and Fragrant Flowers, did very well with the female audience serving cute animals and romance respectively.
That's how fucking dire things are for western animation, it's not just action that's being underserved, it's fucking everything, in a desperate attempt to appeal to everyone at all times.
>>
>>
File: ddaaa.jpg (72.8 KB)
72.8 KB JPG
>>152367769
>>152368021
>>152368218
Are we posting our ideas now? I'm working on an autistic action comic. It's a "toons in the real world" story
>The toon world is a silver age-based action comedy.
>In the real world it's a huge franchise with several comics, movies, video games, a cartoon with 600 episodes and a few novels.
>the creator of the original comic is ""Alan Moore"". His original pitch was serious and a bit edgy but was forced to make it kid friendly by ""Walt Disney"".
>the problem starts when the villain of the first half of the story manifest in the toon world.
>he/it is the avatar of the world itself. It gained a conscience after being influenced by the ideas of the writers of the show and the imagination of the fandom.
>He asks questions like "why do you wear the same clothes all the time every day?", "why don't you just kill the joker-expy?", "Why doesn't anyone get old? We have been celebrating christmas every year for 10 years but kids are still kids" or "where do babies come from"?
>The Superman expy (a dumb catgirl with an egyptian themed outfit) ignores the questions but other characters (like the expy of Batman/Dr. Strange, some villains and many secondary characters) get mind broken.
>the imaginary world leaks into the real world and every electric based tech dies.
>Developing new tech is impossible because the radiation of the leak doesn't let it work
>*40 years timeskip*
>After a few wars and a global famine the once powerful countries are shitholes and the third world is ruled by warlords, carteles, ex soldiers, criminal gangs, etc.
>The first human main character is introduced: a sick old woman who lives alone after her son was killed by a warlord.
>As a way to cope she relives the days when she was little nerd girl who was a fan of comics and cartoons (and a /co/ user). Her nostalgia was so strong that the super catgirl and her boyfriend, the batman expy, materialize in front of her.
>>
>>152370761
>Other toons begin to manifest all over the world in similar ways
>*12 years timeskip*
>supercat and batman had a son. He is the main character. He doesn't know his father because he abandoned supercat without explanations when she was pregnant
>He did it to travel around the universe to find a way to beat the avatar.
>From here the story is the catboy and his mom fighting super villains.
>The boy starts as a Damian Wayne-like jerk who thinks he is the best at everything but once the most powerful enemies show up he loses every fight and needs to be saved by his mom and other characters.
>Other characters that are important at the beginning of the story include:
>The hybrid son of president "Trump". The mother is a dog girl but he looks like a young cartoony version of Trump. After supercat he is the most optimistic character. He believes in truth, justice, and the American way and wants to find a way to rebuild the world. He wears a mask and prosthetic gloves (toons have four fingers) because the government presented him as a human born with psychic powers.
>The Professor: the nemesis of supercat. He used to be a good guy but became evil after supercat burned his hair. He is a Zim-looking alien and his personality a mix of Lex Luthor and Doctor Sivana. He manifested in India and used its inhabitants as guinea pigs for all kind of retarded experiments. He has an assistant: a robot girl who is a mix of Rei Ayanami and XJ9.
>A yokai foxgirl supervillain that ends up as the catboy's slave because of a spell.
>the seven deathly sins: a team of powerful demons that wants to take over the world.
That is it. I imagine it as an action comedy with serious moments. Toons are immortal like in Roger Rabbit until The Dip is introduced.
>>
>>152370782
>>152370761
This isn't that cool honestly. People are sick of "Edgy deconstructions" and want something original
>>
>>152370782
Toons aren't exactly like in their cartoon because the ideas of the fans warped the toon world. For example, because of coomers and porn artists, supercat has huge tits that didn't have in the show. While she is wearing her uniform she looks flat/small-breasted but when she wears regular clothes her boobs are as big as her head. The catboy hasa crushon supercat. He gets over it at the end of the first part but heimpregnates his mom by accident. Toon women get pregnant by strong ideas and feelings. Toon men can impregnate human women like this too.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1762984769827452.png (344 KB)
344 KB PNG
>>152371128
>an action cartoon written by powerscaling schizos, tranime fags and /v/ secondaries
go and get the money
>>
File: G-bfvcZWoAEBffe.jpg (68.3 KB)
68.3 KB JPG
>>152361362
Bro, Dragon Ball doesn't even have blood anymore, and battle shonen adaptations toned down compared to the manga
>>
File: 1742760069615656.png (1.8 MB)
1.8 MB PNG
>>152371333
Anon, this may come as a shock, but there are other shonen properties besides Dragon Ball.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152371618
Yes anon, that is the point of demographics.
If girls want to read it as well, that's fine, but it's not made for them.
The same way a guy can read one of those horny fantasy romance, but it's still not for him at the end of the day, it's for women.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Chainsaw Man - Chapter 228 - 13.jpg (274.2 KB)
274.2 KB JPG
>>152367504
>Every wound in the western action animated series sphere is self inflicted, and I can't be bothered to mourn it anymore
Real
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152370408
>>152370594
The West really has it going from TV-Y7 to TV-14, then MA. TV-14 rarely gets made, kind of how PG-13 is the elusive rating for movies. But there are good movies and shows in every age rating, but the West (specifically the US) really goes all in on the mature rating or not at all. I can only think of a few things that is animated "for adults" but could very well fit in with a shoenen anime.
>>
>>152371618
Having a demographic or any label is still useful. I mean think of when people say "Calarts". Even if it could be incorrectly describing the item, it gives people certain information on what it may contain. Transformers is a boys show made for boys and the majority of its cast is male. It should stay that way because the women who are into transformers also like it that way. If they start changing it to "appeal to girls" then the women who like the current transformers wont like it. Same with men who like cute girly shows made specifically for men.
And finally, there can be cute girly shows for girls, and cute girly shows for men because the writers/animators target those demographics.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>152356732
>Ban the Spider Verse movies
You want to ban the only movies that try to do something different and worth a shit in like a decade or two in the animation scene? Because the alternatives is your usual calarts #2387 or your not-anime slop #7743 movie, like always.
>>
>>
>>152360266
>>152373114
Super Sentai was canceled because the international rights were wrapped up in Power Rangers and they wanted out.
>>
>>
>>
File: movie chase tape.webm (2.9 MB)
2.9 MB WEBM
>>152370393
*Most patrician taste