Thread #152353565 | Image & Video Expansion | Click to Play
HomeIndexCatalogAll ThreadsNew ThreadReply
H
What could be a good story of Kamala being a mutant that her fans would actually like?
And let's try something that would have her not forget every ting about she was human before being a mutant.And not everyone beside her acting like a typical US citizen in a typical X-Men book about mutants .
+Showing all 88 replies.
>>
>>152353565
>>
>>152353565
Trying out sexy and skin showing mutant fashion. It’s sexy and tight for mutant girls to wear it out and proud.
However, it conflicts with Kamala’s conservation Muslim clothing dichotomy.
>>
>>152353565
You can't do it. People liked only the first run because it was the only one that kept things simple until the end.
>>
Nothing. They've explored the extent of her character as a high school student in Jersey City. They're limited in what they can do with the character without ruining what makes her unique. Let her float around the X-Men books till they're ready to send her off to college, then put her and Miles both in the freshman dorms at Empire State in their respective titles.
>>
>>152353565
Since she’s a mutant, she has to have sapphic chemistry with a fellow mutant female. Be it fellow teen or older woman.
As OP’s pic shows, the Stepford Cuckoos are the best bet.
Yes, all 5 of them.
>>
>>152354499
I nearly did he cut off porn image of her doing the five of them as the off image but I figured I want some actual discussion and for this not to get deleted.


>>152353565
What about her original before X-Men villains trying to do something and she's trying to stop it but both of their efforts are being constantly interfere with or complicated by either some mutant supremacist bearing trying to change what's going on into a mutant thing when it's not supposed to be or some anti mutant group or person trying to basically do the exact same time of thing against mutants? What about something like that?
>>
>>152353565
>>152354109
>>152355117
I hate ESLs.
>>
>>152355117
>>152354499
>>152353565
>>
>>152355490
I think it's weird how they killed 2 of them off, had them as a trio for a long time, had a period where two of them dyed their hair to look different, and then later brought the other 2 back, and pretended like it all never happened. Them all dating the same guy simultaneously is obviously fetishy, self-insert wish-fulfillment.
>>
>>152353565
I honestly don't think her fans will ever accept Kamala as a mutant. The very concept will be rejected.
>>
>>152355918
>Them all dating the same guy simultaneously is obviously fetishy, self-insert wish-fulfillment.
Does the guy know he's dating more than one girl?
>>
>>152355490
Source?
>>
>>152356353
Yes.
Both young Cable and Old Cable knew.
So did Pixie and Armor. “Sharing is caring” was the Krakoa motto.
>>
>>152356425
Having a young Cable as a whole was retarded. It's also hard to even learn surface level questions about the character form the wiki because the jannies refuse to treat young and old cable as separate characters.
>>
>>152353565
Have Kamala confront the X-men on a lot of their attitudes as an outsider.

The problem with the X-Men currently is they're takingna sort of one size fits all approach to being maringalized, and every individual is different and in different circumstances.

You're going to tell someone with ADHD thst being neurodivergent is nothing to be ashamed of, but you shouldn't say "You're not a real Neurodivergent if you get medication".
You can tell gay or Trans people that they are who they are and should love who theynare, but insisting they be out loud and proud in a small deep red county is a great way to get them fucking killed.

Have Kamala be the one to call these approaches out.
>>
>>152353565
The hive mind forgot that the Cuckoos don't do telekinesis.
>>
>>152353565
bring them back. kamale needs her harem.
>>
her getting hypnotized by another x-man
>>
>>152353565
The truth is, she's whatever Disney needs her to be so they can profit of any one type of people.

Aka

She has no identity.
A tool is not a character.
>>
>>152353565
>Kamala
>Fans

Nice joke. Nobody cares about that worthless Indian.
>>
>>152356814
>>152356976
Not even paying attention to the evidence of all the people who commented before you.
>>
>>152356772
Kamala isn't allowed to just do Jersey things anymore. It's gotta be Young Avengers shit, Champions shit, X-Men shit, and so on and so forth. Can't just be about trying to finish homework and punching dumb bird people in Jersey.
>>
>>152356772
>>152353565
>>152353565
Okay only counting Kamala from 616 but including people she interacted with outside of her own solo series who would be in her harem? And do include females also please.
>>
>>152357351
Miles Morales
Sam Alexander Nova
Moon Girl
Bruno
Red Dagger
>>
Kamala learning about one of Krakoa's laws. Feeling squeamish knowing all the mutant boys see her as a walking womb. Leaving mutant society to find a man who loves and respects her...

An Asgardian Prince who'll join the Champions and make her a princess!
>>
>>152357244
>Can't just be about trying to finish homework

Didnt she already finish school?
>>
>>152357769
What about kids cyclops/adult when he got his memory from that time?
>>
File: 016_08.jpg (588.2 KB)
588.2 KB
588.2 KB JPG
>>152357958
>>152357769
>>
>>152357769
>>152357958
>>152357982
Viv Vision also said she was interested in kissing her, but Kamala said "Not now".
>>
>>152355989
I don't think anyone should accept a character being recast like Kamal was to be part of the marketably acceptable subgroup in a comic, for outside promotion reasons.
>>
>>152354499
That's a Cuckoo? Why is she telekinetic?
>>
>>152357351
Gwenpool but she hates her while trying very hard to remain cordial
>>
>>152357769
Plus Viv Vision
Sophie Cuckoo
Robbie Reyes Ghost Rider
Skunk Girl
>>
>>152358508
That run of NYX was just really, really bad.
>>
>>152358508
Lanzig and Kelly don't give a fuck about continuity. There was tons of shit like that in NYX. Kamala shouldn't even know who Sophie is because she has been dead until like a month prior.
>>
More,
>>
File: Zoe.jpg (1.1 MB)
1.1 MB
1.1 MB JPG
>>152356772
Is that a girl friend hug or a girlfriend hug?
>>
>>152359798
Girlfriend hug.
>>
An entire issue dedicated to her losing her virginity to me. It would be controversial, provocative. Drawing outrage from Muslim groups and tumblrinas alike. But shes a woman now. She has sexual feelings and desires. Explore her internal want for male companionship. And if we want it to be some educational PSA, I promise to wear a condom, because safe sex is heroic!
>>
>>152354499
Hot
>>
>>152358508

The Cuckoos always had teleknesis, they just dont use it
>>
>>152353565
Kamala's fans don't want her to be tied up with anyone except maybe the champions. Tying her with either the inhumans or the x-men and trying to make her the most important person in marvel history has damaged her character beyond repair.
>>
>>152361676
Not beyond repair.

They just gotta stop doing it.
>>
>>152361676
Marvel has bigger problems like the whole krakoashit

If you ignore that there was a time that Kamala was the most import person ever, it whold heal.

The stupid Morales clone is a wrost case.
>>
>>152353565
She gets cracked by Miles and has to hide it from her friends, her folks, and most importantly -- Bruno. The X-Men all know and approve, because they're degenerate psychics with no morals and personal boundaries.
>>152357934
She's a senior in high school.
>>
>>152359798
Nakia is straight.
>>
>>152354499
>>152355490
Kamala being the sexual plaything of horny blonde girls is a great idea.
>>
>>152355167
what? how this >>152354109 picrel esl?
>>
>>152361806
>She's a senior in high school.

Why she was in Oscorp Lab in a interniship?
>>
>>152363501
Summer high school internship program.
They literally say it on the page.
>>
>>152362638
Not after Zoe eats her pussy
>>
>>152363519
Not gonna lie, it was a boring comic, i skip some text
>>
>>152363043
The Cuckoos are straight.
>>
>>152361610
That is one scene in which sophie had cerebro on against 20 years of not having that power. Even in that scene they using telepathy to beat quire. So all the debris flying about comes off as artistic liberty.
>>
>>152363737
Not since Krakoa
>>
>>
>>152353565
Here’s a clean, level‑headed summary of the page’s main points, keeping the noise and explicit content out while capturing the actual discussion thread’s themes.
Source:

Summary of the Main Points
1. The Original Question
The OP asks:
How could Marvel write a good story about Kamala Khan being a mutant—one that her fans would actually like—without erasing her human background or forcing her into typical X‑Men tropes?

2. General Sentiments About Kamala as a Mutant
Many posters argue her fans won’t accept the retcon and see it as a marketing move rather than an organic story choice.

Some say the change has damaged her character, especially when Marvel tries to make her “the most important person ever” in multiple franchises.

Others believe she could recover if Marvel stops forcing cross‑franchise importance and lets her be a grounded character again.

3. Suggestions for a Better Story
A few users offer actual narrative ideas:

A. Kamala challenges X‑Men ideology
She could call out the X‑Men’s one‑size‑fits‑all approach to marginalization, pointing out that different people have different risks and needs.

She could act as an outsider perspective on Krakoan attitudes and policies.

B. Conflicts involving her old villains
One idea: Kamala deals with her original Jersey City villains, but the situation keeps getting hijacked by:

mutant supremacists, or

anti‑mutant extremists
turning a non‑mutant conflict into a mutant political flashpoint.

C. Let her grow naturally
Some suggest letting her float in X‑books until she’s ready for college, then pairing her with Miles Morales at Empire State University.

4. Critiques of Marvel’s Handling
Several posters argue Marvel has run out of ideas for her beyond high‑school stories.

Others say she’s no longer allowed to have “Jersey City slice‑of‑life” plots because she’s constantly pulled into:

Young Avengers

Champions

X‑Men

crossovers
1.2
>>
>>152365924
5. Meta‑Discussion About Continuity
Some debate the Stepford Cuckoos’ powers and continuity errors in recent comics.

Others criticize the NYX run for ignoring established canon.

6. Off‑Topic / Non‑Constructive Posts
As is typical for 4chan, a large portion of the thread devolves into:

sexual jokes

shipping lists

insults

arguments about characters’ sexuality
These do not contribute to the actual question but dominate the thread.

7. The Most Constructive Through‑Line
The only consistent, serious idea across multiple posts is:

Kamala works best when she’s grounded, human, and navigating relatable problems.
Forcing her into mutant politics or cosmic importance undermines what made her appealing.

If you want, I can also extract:

the useful story ideas only

a “what fans actually want” synthesis

or a pitch for a coherent storyline based on the few thoughtful posts in the thread.
>>
>>152364126
They also are floting a giant globe on other issue.

They always had teleknesis, it just never is something that the writers put in the story.

Like "every eternal has every power, they just like use on of the powers more"
>>
>>152366383
>"every eternal has every power
What?
>>
>>152359798
They really need to hurry and get Nakia to admit she’s lesbian for Zoe.
>>
>>152367618
Just getting either of them to appear in a comic at all would be a tall order at this point.
>>
>>152353565
Bump
>>
>>152359798
>Is that a girl friend hug or a girlfriend hug?
What?
>>
>>152367618
>>152368174
>>152359798
Let's have Zoe and the Muslim friend who wears the Muslim outfit appear in a Kamala solo series.
>>
>>152370039
Kamala's series are all about X-Men things now for some reason. There's no room left for #JustJerseyThings.
>>
>>152370098
>#JustJerseyThings.
What?
>>
>>152355167
What ?
>>
>>152353565
>>
>>152364126
definitely not stylistic, the school is trashed after the fight
>>
>>152370098
The best part is they know people want that. They even had the gall to have Kamala claim that she still does the things from her original book and prefers it over x-men shit. Despite the last 3 years of her publication being only mutant bullshit that excludes her supporting cast, and doesn't even take place in her home town.
>>
>>152366983
Anon is sayng that all the Eternals (Ikaris, Serci...) have the same powers.
They just Specialize on one power
>>
>>152372460
Laat I checked, everybody in Jersey threatened to murder her the moment she got outed as a mutant.
>>
>>152373002
They did but that line is insinuating she is still liked by her community despite that being the first thing mutant status took from her. She didn't even have her mutant powers at the time she just wore an X-men outfit and the whole city turned
>>
>>152373063
Which reminds me: did they ever show how her family responded when she got brave enough to tell them she was a mutant?
>>
>>152353565
> A Kamala story people like
That's asking quite a lot, Anon. I think you should set more realistic expectations.
>>
>>152373090
>show
not really, in the hellfire vigil one shot they just said her parent's "didn't get it but they are trying" phrasing it like it like she came out as gay.
>>
>>152373143
Eh, still vague enough that odds are another writer will reveal that they threatened her at gunpoint to leave and never come back, because mutants aren't allowed to have anything nice.
>>
Bump
>>
>>152373143
>didn't get it but they are trying
God that's so fucking dumb. What's not to "get?" Mutants have been around for fucking ever, everyone knows what they are! Fuck, her "coming out" as a super hero would make more sense of this kind of thing!

What is wrong with these writers?
>>
>>152374413
They believe mutants qualify as their own species.#homo Superior
>>
>>152374413
It's a Marvel staple that the human public are insane and bloodthirsty where mutants are concerned. There's something amiss if they're not.
>>
File: 9.jpg (1 MB)
1 MB
1 MB JPG
>>152375838
Before Kamala becamea mutant her brother went to the Muslim Church can't remember what it's called with mostly Inhumans and he thinks maybe some mutants he didn't really care about the and he's like someone made time in superpowers and legal and the Muslim priest cared about can't remember their name he thought they look Liberal.
>>
>>152374413
They just don't want Kamala to have any life or family or friendships outside of the X-Men anymore.
>>
>>152375838
Dude, your contry has droves of crazy people jumping in front of ICE's agents and getting killed.

Marvel's human hatting genocide Mutants is based as fuck.
>>
Bump
>>
>>152376599
I think you mean getting murdered by Ice agents not doing the job correctly but illegally.
>>
I could treat her right, making her feel like a normal girl instead of a inhuman/mutant at the center of a race war drama. Spoiling her, brushing her hair, kissing her caramel skin and plump lips

Reply to Thread #152353565


Supported: JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, WebM, MP4, MP3 (max 4MB)