Thread #25063127 | Image & Video Expansion | Click to Play
File: Althusser.jpg (14.5 KB)
14.5 KB JPG
>The publication of Althusser's posthumous memoir cast some doubt on his own scholarly practices. For example, although he owned thousands of books, Althusser revealed that he knew very little about Kant, Spinoza, and Hegel. While he was familiar with Marx's early works, he had not read Capital when he wrote his own most important Marxist texts.
He wrote a highly influential Marxist analysis of Capital, without having read Capital.
You really gotta just admire the balls this guy must've had to be such an unequivocal fraud for decades and then brag about it casually in his memoirs.
27 RepliesView Thread
>>
>>
File: HKS5VDNHAUHN3XRWHNFHXY4H6I.jpg (183.3 KB)
183.3 KB JPG
Boomers could fake entire academic careers, whereas our generations are relegated to criticizing literature we haven't read on 4chan
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25063127
On the one side, that's why you stick to other continentals and take the French with a grain of salt. On the other side, you only need the first 100 pages of the first volume of The Capital to get most talking points of French marxist philosophy out of it. Volume Two and Three are for people who really get it and want to talk economics, like David Harvey and the likes.
>>
>>
>>25063127
>he knew very little about Kant, Spinoza, and Hegel
Exaggerated account if i've ever seen one, he was probably overly humble. These are not obscure philosophers, and this man studied in the École Normale Supérieure, and if i'm not mistaken graduated there. Come on now.
>>
>>25063380
>Additionally, Althusser had "contrived to impress his first teacher, the Catholic theologian Jean Guitton, with a paper whose guiding principles he had simply filched from Guitton's own corrections of a fellow student's essay," and "he concocted fake quotations in the thesis he wrote for another major contemporary philosopher, Gaston Bachelard."
Your next cope sir?
>>
>>25063388
Kek, that's called being astute, one has to earn a reputation.
Though you can't graduate from the ENS being merely astute, which is my point. Maybe because of the decadence of French academia, which I understate, he earned his recognition, but Althusser doesn't strike me as a fraud and back then you had to know your shit well. Bergson, for example, wrote two doctoral thesis, as was the norm, one in Latin.
>>
Around the time of this memoir, he developed a form of depression wherein he not only wanted to kill himself but annihilate any trace of his being, including obviously his scholarship. He was horrifically mentally ill. And anyone who buys this clearly hasn’t read him, lol, this board continues to just be retarded 20 year olds
>>
>>
>>
>>25063127
>Althusser revealed that he knew very little about Kant, Spinoza, and Hegel
This is his psychosis speaking. The title of his thesis, that he defended at one of the most prestigous universities at the time, is On Content in the Thought of G.W.F. Hegel. How would he be able to write this without knowing Hegel?
>>
>>25063127
>he had not read Capital when he wrote his own most important Marxist texts
No one did/does. It only persists in 'social theory'. Though saying so at the time took some nut. 'Overdetermination' taken back from Freud is something Lacanalists could take a note from.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: goz3p5imt0ob1.jpg (50.4 KB)
50.4 KB JPG
>>25063747
>prestigious academics
>playing Maoist dress up
Sounds like pic related
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>