Thread #25197495
File: image 7432.jpg (116.7 KB)
116.7 KB JPG
Jade-like Edition
Stubbed >>25192230
>What is /wng/ — Web Novel General?
A general for readers and authors involved or interested in the growing phenomenon of 'web novels', serialized English fiction posted to websites such as: Royal Road, Webnovel, Scribblehub, Wattpad, Archive of Our Own, Spacebattles, HFY, various personal author websites, and more
>Why read web novels?
Not for prose or tight editing or deep themes, frankly. As a whole, web novels are infamous for content sprawl and pacing issues. If you enjoy having millions of words to sink your teeth into to get to know the world and characters, though, you may be interested. Keeping up with other readers on a weekly basis to discuss the story's events unfolding is another perk, in the same way discussing an ongoing TV show might be.
>Why write web novels?
Ease of access & potential for Patreon earnings. Many successful authors gain an audience on their website of choice and funnel their readers into a Patreon. See graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators/writing for an idea of what some are earning.
Also, once an author has earned a fanbase, transitioning into an Amazon self-publishing career is several orders of magnitude easier than starting 'dry'.
>/wng/ authors.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vSNZali-jIk2MASsAWVf8N 7A8BlSyzPbAFV_BhsA5Ip3SWfMPWKxaXf8P db7f0TgFyWis31BzirtPeR/pubhtml
>Advice for Noobs!
##READ THE FOLLOWING BEFORE ASKING FOR HELP##
Running your story like the business it is:
www.royalroad.com/forums/thread/116847
On writing web serials:
alexanderwales.com/how-to-write-a-web-serial/
Sanderson's Writing Lectures 2025:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MEUh_y1IFZY&list=PLSH_xM-KC3ZvzkfVo_Dl s0B5GiE2oMcLY
Recommended web novels
rentry.co/d2yvczro
Anon's guide to success
rentry.co/RRBasicGuide
FAQ
rentry.co/pytefpxn
483 RepliesView Thread
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25197503
transhumanism is a cool theme and im eternally annoyed that every story featuring it is trans allegory
that being said you couldn't make me read a space opera under threat of torture
I yearn for unapologetic edgekino. everything out there is blunted with all the edge taken off
write the edgekino
>>
>>
>>
https://youtu.be/onKtEPy1U48
Horror sci-fi mix straight from Romania. Enjoy anons!
>>25197513
There's some transhumanism in my book (mostly later) that's arguably a bit different...
>>
>>
>>25197520
could be kino
brings to mind ridiculous martial arts manga like baki and kengan
so long as there's overly elaborate explanations on the martial art forms that presents them as if they're the coolest shit ever I'd be on board
>>
>>
>>
>>25197527
He’s describing his own ideas as slop.
Without passion, without pride, without the belief in one’s worth, why bother doing anything at all?
It’d be another thing if he says, guys, I have so many great ideas, I don’t know which to start first!
>>
>>
>>25197576
I call my own stuff slop too, and it's slop I like. I'm not under any delusion I'm writing high literature, or even high quality genre fic. I'm making sloppy greasy hamburgers and I love both grilling and eating them
/wg/ is that way btw
>>
>>
>>
>>25197591
>>25197576
You're being disingenuous and obstinate on purpose.
Please don't insult our intelligence by pretending otherwise and instead skip to explaining the why.
>>
>>25197591
you missed the point. slop is a perfectly valid way to describe a lot of webfic. it's not degrading the work, it's calling a spade a spade
nobody would argue that most of these stories have lasting artistic merit like real literature does. they're made to be sloppy fast food consumed for fun. and we like that here
again, /wg/ is that way. you're in the wrong thread
>>
>>25197577
I'm the opposite. I keep starting shitty ideas.
>last idea: world where elves have almost no sexual dimorphism and males and females look and behave almost the same; MC is a prince that is unlikely to inherit the throne, but as he is seduced by a male elf he is caught in some political intrigue and a war
This idea has been copyrighted, don't bother stealing
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Screenshot_20260409-015702.jpg (278.1 KB)
278.1 KB JPG
>WN Updates
>ancient Alien Aryan schizo posting out of nowhere
>>
>>
>>25197591
>>25197582
I have no idea what you homos are arguing about, but I suggest you get a discord together to cyberbugger one another.
>>
File: 1761974845858569.jpg (220.1 KB)
220.1 KB JPG
>>25197630
see >>25197611
>>
File: ashbiemage.png (1.2 MB)
1.2 MB PNG
>>25197468
TFW I don't have an aspie mage gf
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25197479
I just don't see how they wouldn't end up being mages of some sort. Even if you give them their own "internal energy" they would still end up being similar to mages in some sense.
Perhaps as the other guy mentioned: the way they use mana differs, therefore it's not that warriors "cast punch" but their punch carries mana with it.
>>25197458
Yeah that sounds about right. It's just a different application of magic.
Then again, maybe those two aren't that similar after all. Radio waves, microwaves (and their ovens), gamma radiation, and visible light are all "electromagnetic radiation" but they're also quite different things in the real world.
>>25197595
Things don't work that way. Nobody gets to decide what has "artistic merit" and what doesn't. In the long-term it's a question of what survives. Popular stories are far more likely to survive, therefore they will automatically have "artistic merit".
High brow literature isn't any more valuable than genre fics are. Snobbish people just pretend that's the case and nobody cares enough to tell them their current-popular-idea allegory is boring.
>>
File: 1774814014003465.png (32.2 KB)
32.2 KB PNG
>>25197697
okay thanks anon
>>
>>25197342
Go check out Arcane Exfil, it might scratch this itch.
>slop report
>Beware of Chicken v7 c46
Fun chapter. I enjoy the meme of "cultivators do regular thing, but extreme." Reminds me of the drinking game scene from Sky Pride (several volumes ago), where a bunch of drunk cultivators are abusing their superhuman speed and reflexes to cheat at drinking games, while also playing high speed martial arts footsies under the table.
>Sky Pride v6 c23
Bit of an exposition chapter, but we gotta get the new cultivation art at some point and now is as good a time as ever.
>Max Level Archmage c139
Vivi picks her nose while the Archbishop heals a kid. Snore. I could do without the narration reminding me every third paragraph how hardcore and godly the dude is.
>Archmage Coefficient c34
Lesbians. Can't help but see the guy from The Good Doctor in my mind's eye through half these dialogue exchanges. Sometimes I'd like more wizarding and less autism, but I understand that it's settling into a School Fantasy rhythm which usually means more talking and less wizarding.
>William Oh c259
I love the stupid debuff sickle. It's such a fun item. I'd put it in a D&D campaign or something.
>Saintess Summons Skeletons c850
I didn't like the city building hook when it first arrived and then we fucked off on an adventure for a while. It's a little better now. I like the worldbuilding as vague as it is sometimes, because it strikes that balance of there being threats for low level characters but also a broad cast of high level assholes who just couldn't be bothered to clear out every rat infestation. Gotta leave some stuff for the lowbies.
>Stray Cat Strut v9 c21
RavensDagger tends to annoy me for not enough happening in any given chapter. Maybe that's due to the author juggling twenty stories or something. That trend continues here, but at least we finally got to the bottom of the situation in Montreal.
>Re:Deity v4 c16
For the "grand finale" it rushes through the actual fun bit. Too many characters, as usual, most of whom are irrelevant or boring. Not enough time is spent to really appreciate the trap or the reveal of the boss monster, so the fight feels like it ends before it really gets started. Maybe its my fault for speed reading this story sometimes but man there's so little at this point that actually makes me want to slow down and smell the roses here.
>>
>>
>>25197698
>High brow literature isn't any more valuable than genre fics are. Snobbish people just pretend that's the case and nobody cares enough to tell them their current-popular-idea allegory is boring.
I read a lot of slop, write it myself, and have way more fun with it than literature, but not a single web novel has remotely made me sit back and think about the human condition in the way various literature has.
>>
>>
>>25197698
uncritical and stupid
there's a lot more to the merit of a story than whether or not it's popular, and those merits can be present in slop as well
many great novelists were sloppers of their times
not to say that webnovels should strive to be literary or anything but you're taking the reductionism too far
>>
>>25197708
My autism isn't quite that powerful, sorry to disappoint.
>>25197717
It's in a low point at the moment but not drop worthy at the moment. Re:Deity, Draka, and Chronicles of an Isekai'd Legion are on the cut list at the moment. The latter two I'm already not up to date on, which is usually a bad sign for my continued engagement.
>>
>>
>>25197758
Probably? I've only been reading these threads for like a week now, in a bit of a gush phase since I don't have anywhere else to talk about the silly web stories. I posted my (too long) follow list here >>25193133.
>>
>>
>>25197718
I didn't say that it's all about popularity, but rather that popularity makes it more likely that a story survives.
>>25197710
Why not? It's not like traditional literature is all that more insightful about what humans are truly like. They're not written by people who are experts in some field that factually knows what humans are like. All the oddities you see in web novels are about as true as your average traditional novel when it comes to the human condition.
Take Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment. People talk about it as though it's some incredible insight into the human mind, but it isn't. It's just fiction. If you look into how criminals behave then Raskolnikov's behavior is unusual. Regular people commit horrific crimes and rarely seem to get eaten up by it.
>>
>>
>>25197688
The chapter I wrote today came out boring, too. I've got too much set up to get through. I think I'm going to add some b-plot padding to keep things interesting while the MC progresses his preparations.
I want to just summarize it but it doesn't quite fit the pacing to do so even though current events are kind of dragging. I dunno I might just rewrite the entire thing tomorrow.
>>
>>
>>25197779
crime and punishment is both a thriller and insightful to the particulars of people's experiences and thought processes. raskolinokov isn't supposed to be a realistic depiction of a statistically average killer. I've met, known, and to lesser or greater extents, been raskolinikov, marmelidov, and svidrigailov
of all the entertaining novels you could've used as evidence of the form lacking insight, this is probably the worst
>>
File: 1746051029153996.jpg (39.6 KB)
39.6 KB JPG
I'm gonna introduce a high fashion arc in my esoteric doomsdays wizards novel and I don't give a shit.
>>
>>
>>25197885
i would probably skim it but having the soul to give your web novel personal flair makes it endearing to your readers even if they don't like the current arc. readers can sniff out generic soulless sloppa
>>
Would you read this story
>Incredibly ugly incel gets summoned as a hero
>Beats the demon king after being promised the princess's hand in marriage
>Princess immediately commits suicide because of how horrific he is
>The kingdom tries to find him alternate wives, but they all reject him.
Plot arcs would include:
>His fiancee trying to poison him on his wedding day
>His wife sobbing uncontrollably on the marital bed and lamenting being married to a monstrosity
>A gold digger who's just in it for the cash and status, who leads him on but never lets him do the deed
>The kingdom starts using him to clear up red light districts because his mere presence causes brothels to close up shop
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25197962
The problem with this is you're too focused on le funny rejection scenes and not enough on the MC and his desires and how he acts to achieve them. He has barely any motivation and you've just put him in a position to suffer meaninglessly.
Give him a child and make him a single parent and he wants a wife not just for his own happiness but because he believes his child needs/deserves a mother figure, and then all that stuff happens, and it's WAY more compelling. Maybe the kid is adopted or some shit, or the kid got accidentally isekai'd with him so he feels responsible.
Now all the commentary about how he's ugly and incel has emotional weight, and the shallowness of the women comes through. Make it even more meaningful by having the women agree to it BEFORE he kills the demon king, and then AFTER when they need to fulfill their end of the bargain, they try and renege.
>>
>>25197980
>deconstruction
unless you have examinations to make about the underlying principals or values or what have you then it's not a deconstruction, it's just satirizing
>having women fawn all over him for no reason
I was reading an isekai set up where OP MC normal guy-man gets summoned by the demon queen because the forces of humanity were summoning typical isekai protagonists who were all sex pest murderhobos and it was fucking up the whole world
not really my thing so I dropped it but I suspect what you're going for has already been done in a more interesting (and fun) way
>>
>>25197980
I was talking about this earlier, actually, where some anons think because they can make a greentext about their premise that it's a good premise
You could maybe make a short story (2-5k words) that takes the piss out of this idea. It's a punchline premise and it has the same longevity as a joke: set it up, knock it down, and then your whole story is over
Completely unfitting for a proper web novel
>>
>>
>>25197980
>It's supposed to be funny, a guy who is the saviour of the world can't even get laid
Misogyny alone isn't that funny. You gotta have a joke beyond
>wimmen shallow and bad, amiritegaiz?
Is his isekai cheat power based off his collection of SSR Pepes or something?
Also at some point you're just straddling the setups of Shield Hero and Redo of Healer, which is certainly an authorial path to take.
>>
>>25197998
>Also at some point you're just straddling the setups of Shield Hero and Redo of Healer, which is certainly an authorial path to take.
Shield Hero and Redo are revenge fantasies which actually has a path toward a larger narrative. Anon's greentext was just misery suffering with no payoff.
>>
>>25197996
Sure, but if anon is seeking advice on whether his idea works he needs to give an idea about where it stretches to rather than just the premise. Silly premises are very easy to make, it's how to extend them into a multiple book series
>>
>>
>>
>>25197962
Sounds like misery porn.
>>25197980
>deconstruction
What are you deconstructing here?
>>25197998
His idea is shit, but it isnt misogynist.
>>
>>25198038
>His idea is shit, but it isnt misogynist.
>women refuse to interact with the man who saved the world, is extremely powerful, wealthy, favored by king
>because he's UGLY lol
>women are soooooo shallow
don't kid yourself incel
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25198089
Neither of those are like anons green text
The MC of Redo was actually driven insane and the first revenge target is is the princess that was sexually abusing him.
Shield hero is a little edgy at first but he turns into the standard anime protag that forgives everyone.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
It's a male feminist. They haven't actually read either and are just going off of what they read on reddit.
They think if you depict a woman in any negative light (including a literal villain) it's misogynistic.
Something that even actual feminists don't think.
We need to gatekeep more so they don't slither in here.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
Last night I had a dream that while walking down the street some jihaids were preparing to throw Tina Troon off of a building.
Tina was insisting he wasn't actually a homosexual. He recognized me and called out to me for help. "Anon! Tell them I'm not gay!".
The Jihadis asked me if that was true, so I replied "I've never seen this faggot before" and then they threw him off the building.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 500x500.jpg (95.7 KB)
95.7 KB JPG
>>25198169
>so you are saying that you dream about transexuals
Intentional misunderstanding
> I'd brag about that
Passive aggressive use of sarcasm
They're here
>>
File: View Award.jpg (13.9 KB)
13.9 KB JPG
:D
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25197603
The MC has to look like Guts and the Elven trapboipussy has to look like Griffith for the ultimate pandering.
Easy money for you and thank me later (Please I legitimately need stories with a deeper dive into Male x Male relationships)
>>
>>25198038
>>25198049
>His idea is shit, but it isnt misogynist
Everything is misogyny for women and white knights.
>>
>>
File: tenshi eating a corndog.png (350.2 KB)
350.2 KB PNG
>>25198195
Congrats anon!
Keep up the good work! More chapters equals more views!
>>
>>25198208
how did you get to be such a gaylord. this isn't one of those gay or bi curious deals, no way, not dreaming of fags like you do. No, there was an uncle involved, wasn't there. Yeah, the drunken weird uncle used to babysit you. But you got to like it, and didn't really wanna tell on him. you're so fucked up, anon.
>>
>>
>>25197962
Your one and only joke has already been done by Japs in Tsukimichi. The goddess who summoned the MC made him appear like a hideous monster in the eyes of all humans. But his solution wasn't to keep failing like a retard. He went to bang monsters, since they see him as appealing (of course all the monsters are just hot girls with transformation powers).
>>
>>
>>
>>
I thought this was original. Just an off the wall existential adventure kind of deal. I mean I'm tired of the same tropes all the time. so I went looking for a breath of fresh air to read.
https://www.scribblehub.com/series/2244075/cursed-crowned-crimson/
>>
>>25198261
It's actually in the spreadsheet already. It's The Dragon And The Author. I just didn't want to be obnoxious about it.
>>25198263
Thanks, and will do!
>>
>>25198276
oh, wonderful. its the threadly anon that manages to be more annoying that tina and kino put together by crying about it every 25 posts. I bet the no feMC ass anon will be along too. Be a fucking three ring circus and these clowns can juggle.
>>
>>
>>
File: 137312-song-of-the-gift-giver.jpg (101.1 KB)
101.1 KB JPG
>Selkie declares he's taking February off
>still plans 8 full volumes of Song
>current volume nowhere near any kind of resolution at 64 chapters over 500 pages
>radio silent through February and most of March
>comes back with a chapter in April saying he's busy and he's only guaranteeing chapters on Mondays, maybe Fridays too if he's feeling generous
>misses this last Monday's chapter on RR
>"busy with other projects"
He's totally dropping Song. Which is crazy because it has almost 2.5k followers and is in the top like 500 or some shit, crazy high. Although his patreon has dipped below $10k/mo.
The new chapter wasn't even good. Obviously no attempt to polish or edit the stuff that was already up on patreon.
My guess is he's making enough from KU and the publishing company he started that he doesn't actually need the income from his personal writing anymore, and since it's more of a vanity project if it's not peak success it's not worth continuing.
My opinion is that this just shows that half of success is just showing up. Taking that long break to start Song, and then a huge break after the initial launch is just not showing up, and it's hurting results. Shoulda just kept grinding.
>>
>read a western fantasy webnovel by a chink/jap/gook
>character introduced
>names are like
>Jamal von Aryan
>Shalom ibn Himmler
>Sungwhon ap Guinness
>Garfunkle Bigglestein
>Ælfric du van der Piňole
>Aymer Hasta La Vista
>Baruch Linley
>Kahlua de la Boston
>Pleiades Dom Perignon
>Old Jim
>Old Carl
>Old Karl
>Carlos Heinekein Stella Artois
every single time
>>
>>25198291
you're the same weirdo dreaming about faggots. aren't you. there's always one asshole shitting the thread up. I guess tonight that's (you). you must be a tranny. only reddit trannys can be this fucking annoying. YWNBAW.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25198275
The misogyny is the implication that the women of the world collectively owe the Hero love, affection, and sex for saving their lives (directly or indirectly), which is a bit of a fucked up transactionary way of thinking about relationships. But then, he is called out to be an incel, so maybe he's just being written to the type. Hunchback of Notre Dame this plot is not.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25198460
They already did that when they trained them.
I asked it about the "Soul lens" from Monte Cookes Arcana Unleashed.
It told me that's not in Arcana Unleased and linked me a fucking pdf of it hosted on neocities.
When I asked it to do that again it said it couldn't post copyrighted material like that and even denied having done that at all.
>>
>>
Weekly-ish chapter review
Pale Lights (patreon) : ouch , brutal chapter. Also , yay! We reached the cover art scene. 8/10
Years of the Apocalypse (patreon) : i like the new cover. I also loved the naval battles. 9/10
100 Reigns (patreon) : first of all , most patreon commenters are morons. Completely missing what tbe author is going for. The chapters themselves , hit and miss. The miss is mostly "this is what you patreon voters missed" teasing. Casval doing stupid dragon things is a good counter to the bleakness that Simon is going through. I hope the author can has the skill to manage the emotional character progression. 7/10
Attorney to the Villainess : ugh , third week we are stuck in slice of life chapters. Gets boring. 5/10
Looping MorronMagus : It feels really wierd to read from an MC is that is way stupider than the average reader. Especialy in a webnovel/timeloop story. Awseome finale though. 7/10
On Trial
Tbe Nanoapocalypse : I love the premice (not-Star Trek stuck on a Sysapocalypse planet) but the story is a borefest. I'm just sticking with it a bit more in case the author magicaly gets better. 4/10
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25197962
You sound like you absolutely hate isekai. It's evident in your premise alone and readers can sense that as they read your slop.
as the other anon said, tsukimichi has already done that as a premise and found its answer to solving the MCs hideousness.
you however, want to string readers along with your misery porn but without the payoff.
You're even worse than KR webnovels and I hope you use my disdain as fuel to write your dogshit premise and prove me wrong.
>>
>>
>>25198257
This is an interesting thought. I don't really consume gay media, but how do you envision this sort of relationship? I'm guessing what makes it interesting in the power dynamic as the male elf manipulates NotGuts in a more wicked way than a real woman would.
>>
File: IDEAL MALE ENDING.jpg (118.7 KB)
118.7 KB JPG
>>25198879
Part of what makes Guts and Griffith's dynamics hot is that Guts wanted to grow and stand equal with him so he can be a worthy friend and comrade since he viewed Griffith in pretty high standards pre-Femto while Griffith wants to keep him on a leash yet could never do so.
Had Guts been more communicative with his plans, Griffith probably would've understood it but still reluctantly lets him go since he is a possessive megalomaniac narcissist whatever. Think of him as a power bottom.
Griffith sees Guts as a pawn, maybe even more than a pawn, something too dangerous that he can't let go. That for the first time in his life, his tireless pursuit for power, he couldn't imagine achieving that world without Guts by his side. He almost made him forget his dream, which was to obtain his own kingdom.
Would Guts be the knight in shining armor by his side? or would Guts be the ideal King for his power bottom behavior?
Anyways, I'm lovesick again knowing I'll never form a brotherhood with another man so straight that it ends up being gay in the eyes of many.
>>
>>25198283
It's one of the general-mandated threadshitters who purposely tries to sabotage any actual attempt at discussing literature. He's the same kind of newfag who took it as a personal attack that /sffg/ had discussion prompts in the OP instead of a generic stock copypaste so people can talk about the same books every single thread.
Reminder >>25198276 this faggot is worse than a nigger; he's a wigger.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25198588
I appreciate these mini-reviews, anon. It's interesting to see what people are reading and how a reader reacts on a chapter by chapter basis. It helps me keep in mind I need to be entertaining with every single chapter.
>>
>>25198943
>Reminder >>25198276 this faggot is worse than a nigger; he's a wigger.
i just know imma going to regret asking but if we're anonymous how does anyone know. this just sounds silly. i keep popping in here. one time itll be a decent writing and reading discussion. next time its gradeschool. its like this board has no real culture of its own that can be depended on.
>>
>>25199110
I can't help it. BTDEM was one of my first, if not my actual first, webnovels and I followed it for years until the end. I've got fond memories of going on vacations and spending all day in a hotel bed binge reading/re-reading the earlier good arcs.
I actually really want to do the same for Azarinth Healer but I can't bring myself to do so for some reason. And I still haven't checked out Journey to Veresavir, though I've meant to since it launched.
Anyway it's fun to follow Selkie's career since he's so... I don't know. I disagree with much of his personal politics and even some of his narrative decisions, but his prose is enjoyable enough to read and the settings are more interesting than not.
>>
File: pearls before swine.png (532.1 KB)
532.1 KB PNG
>>25199259
>anon discovers /[board]/ is more than one person
Look, you're supposed to lurk for at least two years before you start posting. If you want homogeneity, there are much gayer forums for that.
>>
>>
>>25199317
>>25199277
for TWELVE YEARS IN A ROW
>>
>>25199277
oh fuck off. I'm no tourist. I go many places and I absorb all kinds of little writing tips and tricks here there everywhere. you faggots act like you know something special. This is a great place to lurk and sort through the bullshit to find the diamonds in the rough tips. Its just cancer to try to engage here. I literally mean cancer. If you can imagine cutting off the whole hand to get rid of one tip of one finger that has cancer, that's it. The way you try to deal with anything is worse than what you're trying to deal with. plus its obviously ineffective. spectral soul will do, will be back. so will no fem MC. Hell last thread I saw dick pics. You're just making it worse. And no I don't have your answer.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1775535355054120.jpg (346.1 KB)
346.1 KB JPG
>I'm no tourist. I go many places
That line kinda goes hard not gonna lie. I love that rhetorical flourish of a bold claim and then immediately undercutting it in the same breath. It's almost Shakespearean.
>>
Okay. How about a system where an increase in stat is reflected on the body?
Increasing your Strength makes your muscles grow bigger, and increasing your Charisma makes you more handsome/beautiful.
So high-level male and female warriors are seven-foot-tall hulking monsters, while mages are generally quite short and frail but possess ridiculously high IQs.
The problem is that increasing one’s stats isn’t as easy as killing a bunch of mobs. Leveling up works like in Skyrim, where you need to engage in specific activities to increase a skill. Swing a club often and you’ll earn Club Lv. 2 and +1 STR. Read a lot of books and you’ll earn Reading Comprehension Lv. 2 and +1 INT.
As a result, the wealthy are the only people who can afford to invest the resources necessary to become handsome mages. Meanwhile, the working class tends to end up as warriors, farmers, hunters, blacksmiths, and other STR/DEX-based classes. And not even particularly powerful ones, since they have limited resources to work with.
What you end up with is a caste system where magic users sit at the top, while warriors sit near the bottom and are valued mainly as cannon fodder. Even then, their usefulness is questionable, considering a mage can wave a hand and wipe out an entire army. Among the ruling class, even having muscle is seen as vulgar, since it’s something only the lower classes possess.
Now, the MC is the young master of a powerful mage family who learns that there are demons with immunity to magic. He must now embark on the path of a warrior and face the ridicule of those around him in order to prepare for the coming cataclysm. Along the way, he adds one buff, but self-conscious, amazoness after another to his harem.
What do you think?
(Even without the whole mage vs warrior premise, I like the Skyrim leveling system, so I’ll probably rework it to a few more ideas before commiting.)
>>
>>
>>
>>25199375
>Now, the MC is the young master of a powerful mage family who learns that there are demons with immunity to magic.
Make it a bit more personal. Like have a magic-immune demon come and kill his entire family while he's away so he's knocked down a peg and has a reason to seek revenge against that demon in particular and all others like him.
MCs need concrete motivation to drive their actions and give them a sense of agency.
>>
>>
>>
File: brainlet.jpg (31 KB)
31 KB JPG
>>25199409
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25199398
That’s good advice, but I kind of want to go with the rising genius turns family’s disappointment trope.
Growing up, he thought he was hot shit and looked down on the lower classes, just like everyone else. Until he found himself face-to-face with a demon and learned what helplessness felt like.
Some STR-based character, maybe his female bodyguard, rescued him. And now he’s the only one who takes the demon threat seriously, while everyone else waves it off and says it’s fine. Demons are so rare that worrying about them is like being afraid of a shark attack every time you go into the water. Besides, that’s what having a cannon-fodder bodyguard is for.
But who knows, maybe I’ll end up going with something like what you suggested.
>>
>>
>>25199442
Well if you make the demon threat that rare it really isn't worth worrying about, especially if normal low class warriors can handle them. It's like the rock paper scissors of psychopaths autists and normalfags.
I think it could be good with some fine tuning.
>>
>>25199460
No, that’s what the ruling class believes. Only, the MC understands that the demons are a real threat, like a volcano waiting to erupt and bring down their entire civilization.
Like how in JRPGs, the end game, world ending bosses tend to be immune to magic. Sure, in the early game, there are a few weak monsters with immunity to specific spells here and there, but after a while, the difficulty ramps up, and STR and DEX are far more valuable stats in the long run.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25199582
>Dimming by a few degrees
Could be read as just moving into shade. I think you need just one extra beat to make the reader certain of what's happening. Something unambiguously not normal. Just mentioning something like that once and moving on will keep the understated energy I think.
>>
>>25199582
Why be understated when you can add more words to pad out the word count?
He shifted a second forward in time, the sun dimming as space and time warped around him. One moment, he was there. Then, in an instant, he reappeared to the side, avoiding the slash by a hair’s breadth.
>>
I am nearing the end of anon's book and I have been invested enough to hope he sticks the landing. I do like the back half more than the front, it felt smoother once the plot really kicked in.
I was sitting on the shitter getting a couple pages read during my morning shit, thinking about my own black sun amirite fellas
>>
>>
>>25199645
>He shifted a second forward in time, the sun dimming as space and time warped around him. One moment, he was there. Then, in an instant, he reappeared to the side, avoiding the slash by a hair’s breadth.
>Dia bergeser maju sedetik, matahari meredup saat ruang dan waktu berputar di sekelilingnya. Suatu saat, dia ada di sana. Kemudian, dalam sekejap, dia muncul kembali ke samping, menghindari tebasan sehelai rambut pun.
One of you tell me if bottom is hard to read. Or did you mean it's hard for esl to write?
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1767841097855986.jpg (56.9 KB)
56.9 KB JPG
>>25199755
Wrong it should actually be dopamine delivery by number going up.
Sentences should describe number going up.
Chapters should be about number going up a lot.
Volumes should be about new ways number can go up, and those numbers going way up.
>>
>>
>>25199711
I meant it's hard for ESLs to write like >>25199624
Talking about specific things or a subjects is managable but just writing nice sounding and coherent sentences (with correct grammar) basically about nothing is hard. Same with having a small talk irl, ESLs suck at it.
>>
File: Screenshot_20260409_225800.jpg (56.4 KB)
56.4 KB JPG
>>25199820
>10k words of glossary
Holy
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25199853
These pigs have read my words, and enjoyed them. When they do now know who wrote them, they did extol their virtues. Their lamentations will be great when I make it. Their tears will fuel my joy. My ascension shall be messianic.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25199889
nta but it's precisely because it's impossible to answer it fully without writing a 10 page essay that makes it a supremely retarded question and come off as bait
it's only one sliver more specific than "how do I write well?" and I desperately hope you see how retarded that question is to just drop into a 4chan thread apropos nothing
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25199889
>>25199738
You’re serious?
Alright, then.
Think about where you want the story to go, then break down the steps needed to get there.
The hero needs to kill a dragon.
Chapter 1: Idyllic village life, ending with a dragon’s sudden attack.
Chapter 2: Surviving the attack, with the MC losing his family.
Chapter 3: The MC wrestles with what to do next, then ultimately decides to hunt the dragon despite others warning him not to.
Chapter 4: He sets out through the forest and comes across a merchant surrounded by goblins. He defeats them and gains his first companion.
And so on, and so on.
>>
>>
>>
>>25199917
pretty much. if you're assigning cultivation to china then the west should be assigned tolkien/sanderson fantasy
>korea has system
I'd ascribe hunters to korea over systems. systems are a japanese light novel thing
>>
>>25199738
>>25199889
>simple question
>only ever engages past pinching off the turd of his shitpost to defend it
get a friend group to talk to holy shit
>>
>>25199777
>>25199991
It's likely the "don't reply to tinashit" threadshitter.
>>
>>
File: BEING_TARGETED_BY_HYENA-CHAN_-_Chapter_11_-_2.jpg (61.9 KB)
61.9 KB JPG
Hello. I'm not necessarily looking for a web novel, but I reckon a web novel is more likely to fit my criteria than a regular book.
I'm looking for monster romance with a female monster, preferably in the modern times and with urban fantasy elements. Horror is welcome. I'd also like there to be a good plot besides the romance itself. A yandere-esque monstergirl is a bonus but not required.
Thank you very much for any recommendations.
>>
>>
>>25199738
I preplanned it in the 1sentence bullet point outline I did. And had it rewritten in the first draft already, so what I am writing is either the second or third draft that arrives in reader's hands already.
>>
>>
>>25200001
>random tina defense
I have no idea which of the two thread retards you are since the only ones who like either of you are each other, but please shut the fuck up
you're both tolerable when you find it in your medication to act normal
>>
File: 1768495658723346.jpg (17.8 KB)
17.8 KB JPG
>people saying don't reply to bait are trolls
It's really so hard to just talk about webnovels, not talk about/to thread personalities (actual trolls), or let the general be silent when nobody has anything to discuss.
If only there was another hit novel like MLA to discuss and keep us all sane.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25199917
Superheroes fit the bill the most, yeah.
Up and including the part where making a comparatively "normal" story into a superhero one might be the price exacted by a publish or audience in order to gain traction/non superhero stories IH might be absorbed into superhero verses later on.
Komandi was a legally distinct planet of the apes/Tarzan but they regularly cross it over with the main verse nowadays Just Because.
Constantine needs to routinely refresh his existing license by being in proximity to the Justice League.
Etc.
>>
>>
File: aiharamai-3.png (24.2 KB)
24.2 KB PNG
>>25200076
We're getting raided?
>>
>>25200053
I know you're just baiting with the femc remark but it's genuinely insane the stats MLA pulled. It broke almost every record by a landslide. It's #6 most followed on the entire site in less than a year. Everything above it is more than 3 years old (MLA is 10 months). And that 3 year old one, Super Supportive, is its ownmassive unusual hit.
The rest are 5+ years old
A freak hit even compared to other freak hits. Seems like it's falling off hard on Patreon though
>>
>>
>>25200053
>>25200102
also every single other story in the top 10 most followers is Male MC. so it did all of that while being femslop which doesn't fit the mold
to this day I wonder how it happened, most people call it mid when they talk about it
>>
>>
File: objects-in-motion-aadaxxwwxhc.jpg (178.8 KB)
178.8 KB JPG
>>25200047
Objects in Motion. Somehow I missed that the author of Paranoid Mage started another new fiction and it's actually something that piqued my interest unlike the sun scifi thing and system delenda est. It's super hero capeshit but decent, I like inertia as a theme and thing he did a great job incorporating it as such. It's going to stub soon so it's worth downloading now.
Otherwise not much. I'm behind on a bunch of japanese LNs and some stuff on RS that I followed and read a few chapters of, like Five Element Overlord. I still haven't even finished Dungeon Diver and that guy's up to chapter 28 already and posting daily, so I just fall further and further behind.
It doesn't help I want to write reviews but feel bad not reviewing at the latest posted chapter so I feel it hanging over my head all the time. Today I won't read shit either I'm watching a bunch of anime instead.
>>
>>25200111
I joke about it a lot but I honestly believe it was a money laundering operation. Sure it picked up hard but I think at least half the money it made was money laundering and then fake it til you make it kicked in and everyone was reading it just because it was topping every chart.
>>
>>25200139
I wonder why more people don't do that if it's so easy
I can't even imagine the headache of botting so many financial transactions, though. Are there services that make that easy in a smooth curve so it's not super obvious?
>>
>>
>>
File: 1756664039153169.png (214.8 KB)
214.8 KB PNG
>>25200007
>monster romance with a female monster
>preferably in the modern times and with urban fantasy elements
>Horror is welcome
>A yandere-esque monstergirl is a bonus but not required.
What the actual fuck, are you me? This is literally what I'm trying to write rn. Plot is about a flesh eating harpy that keeps reviving her lover after they die. Probably gonna be Yuri though I've gone back and forth on it. Here a rough draft of the opening if anyone's interested
>>
>>
>>25200199
I've been wanting to write a story for myself, since I just can't find something to scratch that itch, but looks like you got it. I'm interested, please drop the title you're gonna use so I can find it when you decide to publish. Shame it's gonna be yuri, but you do what you think best.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1298579801808.jpg (28.9 KB)
28.9 KB JPG
I got a nice comment
>>
I don’t understand why Westerners love the sound of their narration so much.
I don’t care about sunlight beaming through the leaves and painting dots of gold on your buttcheeks, or the rain hammering down like sheets of nails on the chalked earth, and I especially don’t care about that time your uncle took you on a hunting trip in the Appalachians after you lost your tooth in a fistfight.
I don’t care about you. I don’t care about your trauma or what brand of autism you have swirling around inside your head. You are a faceless camera I use to see the world. You could be a limbless, dickless nugget for all I care. So get to the point and move the story along already!
Or take a page out of older books and focus on the dialogue and banter. At least there would be some kind of interplay going on, instead of some millennial fuckface’s poorly disguised rant against capitalism.
God, four hours wasted and I couldn’t find a single good book on Royal Road or Amazon to fill the void. Why the fuck was Eminence in Shadow book 7 so damn short?
>>
File: 1770852945925152.jpg (73.2 KB)
73.2 KB JPG
>>25200689
>went to royal road
>somehow found contemporary litfic and apparently memoirs
Skill issue.Try Beware of Chicken, 1% Lifesteal, or Dungeon Crawler Carl. I don't know what your taste is other than LN. Saga of Tanya the Evil maybe? Or Ascendance of a Bookworm.
>>
>>
>>25200651
>bad, writers can evolve / improve
It was their 9th book and not only did both main conflicts make no fucking sense (one of them for three separate, crippling reasons), but the writer kept forgetting shit they wrote and having plot progressing conversations offscreen while the story would just follow fights with unclear stakes and small talk.
Also just a shitton of obvious twists just for the sake of having twists that did nothing but harm the story.
Honestly, I gave the writer more of a chance than I should have given they very obviously weren't planning their story out properly. I'll give you an example. The story starts with the MC going grocery shopping. As she enters the store, she's confronted by 3 security guards that tell her she needs to leave because she's making the other customers uncomfortable. She refuses so
>they pull batons and guns on her
and
>she executes them with magic swords she had hidden on her person, gets her groceries, and robs the register
At this point I'm thinking, oh, they could tell she was a demon and she wasn't going to starve in the face of racism, so she just did the pragmatic thing and killed/robbed the violent racists.
Except no, the author confirms later on that magic ISN'T public knowledge, and the MC just executed those guards who were just doing their job because they were in her way...with supernatural powers...in a public place. Also she's apparently killed thousands of people before, but she hasn't been arrested/revealed magic somehow. But it's okay because she was just doing that shit because she was magically stripped of her emotions including empathy and also she only killed evil people and people that threatened her. Literally the second paragraph is her going over her moral code.
And none of this resolves why the fuck everyone in the grocery store thought she was a threat.
Also this random murder has fuck all to do with the rest of the plot. She leaves town because her father who abandoned her for no reason and is pretending to be dead for no reason and pretending to be a rebel against his own dynasty for no reason sent assassins after her for no reason shortly after this. Seriously, the assassins only exist to misdirect the audience away from the fact that the person in charge of Hell is actually a traitor against her Satan dad who decided to fight them by...defecting with virtually all his closest supporters, faking his death, and starting a civil war instead of just arresting/killing them with the overwhelming support and force he actively enjoyed. Their existence makes no fucking sense. The traitor sends a guard to get her to hell alive so she can be a figurehead in the civil war she is badly losing and her father wants her to either stay on Earth or join him, not to die, and he could and eventually does easily achieve that with a simple conversation the second his minions stop trying to kill her for no reason. Neither side wants her dead. The plot happens for no reason.
>>
>>
>>25200689
>I don’t understand why Westerners love the sound of their narration so much.
Helps break up the dialogue. If you go too dialogue heavy, your writing can feel dry, contextless, and too fast paced. Generally scenes will either have a dialogue focus or an action focus, and including elements of the other helps slow the pacing down.
Also some of us have rich imaginations that are helped by more details. I just finished a novel where the author never even gave the hair/eye color of the fucking main antagonist despite him being a twist antagonist present for most of the fucking book. I get that he's tall, muscular, and has broad shoulders, but I need fucking more than that. FFS.
>>
>>25200765
>AI mayhaps
It read more like just regular bad writing mistakes than AI. This is the sort of shit I'd expect from a half-assed CW show. They were narrative inconsistencies, like a writer changing their mind about something, but forgetting what they wrote.
As an example, the main character worked as an assassin for a while and reveals this in passing to another character in an early scene, but then much later it's revealed they met while she was working as an assassin so the reveal makes no sense in retrospect. Obviously the writer forgot they wrote her finding out about that shit for the first time in an earlier chapter. They were writing 3 serialized books set in the same universe at the same time, so it's easy to imagine they forgot what they wrote months ago, but sitting down and reading one book through and it was obvious they were doing a half-assed job.
>>
>>25200806
Honestly as godawful as the book turned out to be, it at least made me appreciate the next thing I read that also turned out to have a ton of twists in it, since they all fit together fine other than 1 plot hole you could handwave away.
The writer obviously fucked up, but at least I'm still able to construct a coherent narrative even with their fuckup with a believable if not necessarily reasonable assumption. In comparison, that shitshow I read before it was in no fucking way salvageable.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25200870
writers block is real and its retarded
dumbass mental block that never truly goes away. the arms race between my coping mechanisms and my mental block's ability to come up with pointless hurdles is a constant back and forth
good luck
>>
>>25200882
but holy shit anon it is a REALLY boring place
i just need to get them from the outside into the inside
i need to use words to move their BODIES into a HOUSE but im too RETARDED to do so
it feels so awkward to just say it when my narration up until this point has been marching on in real-time cataloguing every action and movement
it made sense then because there was a lot of action and talking about important things that were worth narrating but now all the important things and actions have been said and done and they just need to fucking MOOOVE
>>
>>25200885
>my coping mechanisms
one of my coping mechanisms has been to try and flesh out the flavour of the setting and the worldbuilding and different institutions but i fucking hate doing it
and the more i do it the more i realise i don't want to tell a story in this world i've accidentally made i just want to tell a story about my guy
so the thing i do to feel productive in the time i'm not writing is making me not want to write even harder
>>
>>
File: Dialogue.png (355.2 KB)
355.2 KB PNG
>>25200852
How old are we talking here?
>>
File: V1_.jpg (1.5 MB)
1.5 MB JPG
>>25200755
This description makes me so sad while I autistically memorize all of the parts of naval rigging to reference them accurately, and study the construction of said vessels to I know what parts of the boat aren't needed for ship that flies so that I can remove them.
Then you go an tell me that some author writes 9 books, with basic major logical inconsistencies. While, and let me stress this, the main character is "grocery shopping".
It's not like they are writing Shenmue here where that would make a modicum of goddamn sense.
>she wasn't going to starve in the face of racism
What is the fucking Bright is this bullshit?
>>
>>25200889
Sneak it in as part of a sentence that actually moves the plot along.
They walked through the yard and into the house and Billy turned to Mandy with a horrified expression on his face. Oh my god, he said.
What? She replied.
The plot. The plot. The fucking plot is happening aaaaaagh.
>>
>>
>>
>>25200916
The Journey of Billy and Mandy
Appears to be the only evidence of "oh my god" being used anywhere throughout the Billy and Mandy series and includes the following lines.
>Billy: Grim, if you keep standing in my way, I swear to God, I'm going to beat you until you're unrecognizable. Got it?
>Billy: Thank god!
>Billy: God, shut up! Everyone just shut the hell up!
>Mandy: Billy? Billy! Oh my god!
Given his references to god in this context, and his frequent proximity to Mandy. It's almost certain that he would actually utter "oh my god".
>>
>>25200689
> Why the fuck was Eminence in Shadow book 7 so damn short?
Didn't know it released, by going by how long it took for vol 6/7 to come out, and the quality of vol 5-6 compared to previous vols, we can safely assume it's because the author ran out of ideas
>>
>>
>>
File: 1774276056642166.gif (116 KB)
116 KB GIF
>>25200918
a horrible but deserved fate
>>
>>
>>
>>25198049
>>25197998
>>25197977
>misogyny is when you make fun of a man
>>
>>
>>25197603
Oh, like Bernard Boursicot and Shi Pei Pu.
>Boursicot first met Shi Pei Pu in China while posted to the French Embassy in Peking as an accountant in 1964. They met at a party just before Christmas held by Claude Chayet at the French Embassy and shortly began a relationship.[2] Reporter Joyce Wadler, who wrote the book Liaison about the affair, would later attribute Boursicot's belief that Shi was a woman to Shi's unique ability to retract his own testicles, which, combined with the manipulation of his own penis, created the illusion of labial lips and a clitoris and allowed for shallow penetration.[2]
>In 1965, Shi claimed to be pregnant and was able to use a baby boy called Shi Du Du (later called Bertrand by Boursicot and his family), who had been bought from a doctor in Xinjiang,[3] and was a Uyghur.[4] Boursicot believed he was a mixed-race Chinese and French, and that there was a family resemblance between him and the boy.[2][5]
>Over the next decade, they continued their on-again off-again affair as Boursicot moved from posting to posting in Southeast Asia. During this period Boursicot embraced his own bisexuality, having multiple liaisons with women while also engaged in a long-term relationship with a Frenchman named Thierry, with whom he one day hoped to form a family including Shi Pei Pu and Bertrand.[2] Boursicot has stated that he began passing documents to Shi when the Chinese Cultural Revolution made it difficult for him to see him. He was approached by a member of the Chinese secret service, "Kang", who offered him access to Shi in exchange for his passing documents. He believed Shi's safety was at risk if he failed to participate.[5]
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25201222
Absolutely yes. I have 0.5 star ratings on chapters 1, B, C, and 45. 1 is obviously someone felt betrayed in that chapter compared to the blurb/cover/premise. B had a moment where I can see the comment by the guy who obviously rated. C had a long sperg out about characterization and how that's not realistic when the story is tagged fantasy to begin with: ironically I may have written too realistically up to that point and not lampshaded that this is a work of fiction and the MC is made up to be more interesting than reality.
48 I think was either someone clicking through to the end so I couldn't report their rating, or I don't know what. It's just a normal chapter. No way someone read that many chapters just to decide the story was worse than incomprehensible garbage. Although come to think of it it might have been someone mad I blocked them before they could rate, so they spun up an alt-account. Who knows?
Personally I think ratings of 1 or below should be REQUIRED to have a written review attached. It's trivial to write 50 words about why something bad is bad, and would only impact emotional retards hate-rating without a good reason. "Uhhh da main character didn't kill da bandit in chaptuh twee so he stupid ugh just like my teachuhs at schoo"
However these haters seem to be equal opportunity retards so everyone suffers from bad ratings. The good stories rise to the top of RR on the strength and size of their fanbase, not by avoiding haters. Above a 3.9 rating, only follower count and comment activity on the latest chapters really matter, in my opinion. It's also why Rising Stars is a better way to find good stories than Best Rated.
>>
File: 1772402732146936.jpg (25.9 KB)
25.9 KB JPG
>>25201521I don't actually know what people are talking about when they say "genre fiction." Doesn't every book have a genre? Memoir is a genre. Scifi is a genre. Why isn't "literary" a genre? (I think it is: classical, like music.) I get that people are using the phrase as a pejorative I just don't understand what it means semantically.
>>
>>25201534
I see literary as contemporary stuff that takes place in the real world without any supernatural or fantastical force that is explained by the rules of the setting (by that I only truly mean one shy miracle is allowed if your story is religious), and you must want to say something about human nature or whatever. Your story must not be about an adventure, or an crime, or about a monster, etc. Though those things may appear, the story must really be about the human condition on this Earth.
>>
>>25201534
a genre fiction is one where the genre informs the content of the work, rather than the work being... the other way around, or something
sorry i can't think of words right now but you know what i mean, the "genre" modifier means it's written a specific genre and its audience in mind
>>
>>25201521
Basically because they're such a tiny minority here. Those who would have become genre writers instead went into webnovels. Because it's basically the same thing, just with zero barrier to entry. Yes the market and audience preferences are not the same but it's close enough.
>>
>>25200571
I finished the book and enjoyed the ending. I did not see what happened... happening, so it was a very pleasant surprise. I should really write up my thoughts in a notepad file to get some organization and throw it in the start of the next thread.
>>
>>25201521
/wg/ is for both genre and literary fiction, there's just one or two vocal seethers who pretend it isn't. back in the day before the /wng/ split those seethers tried to make a literary fiction general and it died within days.
most people in /wg/ that actually write instead of talk about writing write genre
>>
>>25199413
>>25201392
samefag
>>
File: 1767504948896291.jpg (233.2 KB)
233.2 KB JPG
Today I decided to make my chapter super interesting. It has TWO cliffhangers!
>>
i'm new to webnovels, but i'm reading kumo desu ga nani ka right now and there's an incest subplot in there. does it get resolved in a normal way? is incest a common thing in webnovels or is it just a japanese thing?
>>
>>
File: 1310928078976.jpg (350.3 KB)
350.3 KB JPG
>>25201954
>does it get resolved in a normal way?
No.They don't wind up hooking up.It's more just to play up how yandere she is. Keep in mind Shun is the dense protagonist stereotype.
Incest is incredibly rare outside of Japan. I think it's against Royal Road's terms of service outright. Or at least portraying it in anything other than a negative light.
If it really bothers you, you should find a website that sorts Japanese WN/LN by tags and check before you start reading. You probably wouldn't enjoy Mushoku Tensei, for instance.
>>
>>
>>25201960
>>25202209
thanks. i don't mind incest in fiction (at least when it serves a purpose), just didn't expect it, since the novel has a focus on the female mc. i thought it's more of a male mc trope. well, since shun is kinda a male mc i guess that's still true
>>
>>25202282
i feel like i need to explain a bit more.
when i started reading the novel, it felt really fresh (probably because i'm not familiar with all the tropes, but still). i enjoyed the main character, but the interludes with shun felt really boring, like jumping from a fun new thing to a cliche story. later i understood that the author is poking fun at the mc - look how good this guy has it while she has to struggle for her life.
when katia appeared, i thought it's a funny spin on the usual anime harem tropes, having a close girl friend, that isn't actually in his "harem" because she's a guy. fei's addition also contributed to my enjoyment of his interludes - another "girl" that he can't actually add to his harem because she's an animal. but the whole deal with sue felt a bit forced, like the author just gave up on clever spins and decided to create a harem isekai for shun after all. so that's why i asked if it got resolved in a normal way. i also thought that maybe it was such a staple of the web novel genre that every one has to have an incest subplot in it, but looks like it's just the japanese mentality at work.
sorry for being verbose
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: samefag1.png (29.8 KB)
29.8 KB PNG
>>25201784
Really. Yet once again anon doesn't know jack shit but acts like a conceited asshole. Here. Look at this. PIC RELATED. Notice anything. If I same-fagged that they would both say (you). Jackass.
>>
>>
>>
>>25201621
years ago I first started lurking and popping into /wg/. Like a lot of things its a great idea on paper. Just not so much in real life. You get a lot of shouting assholes saying things like "the only thing worse than grown men reading fiction, is grown ass men writing fiction" and "reading fiction is for faggots and women only, writing fiction is even gayer". Its just a bunch of horseshit but it gets old.
>>
>>25201567
the differences between writing trad pub genre paperbacks and anything WN are glaring. Actual published authors I've seen them have melties and snap. They're (trad written) paperback WN gets them nowhere. Then, they see short choppy sentences, in single sentence paragraphs. No descriptions no metaphor no nothing. They watch these things blow the fuck up and get a million views. I can't explain it but trad genre and WN genre are like two different worlds.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25201521
/wg/ and /wng/ both. Anyone talking about trad genre writing style gets screamed at and made fun of non stop. It well might be just a small majority but they're very vocal. In /wg/ it will seem as if nothing except pretentious bullshit is real writing. And here in /wng/ you get made fun of for it just in a different way. /wg/ screams go to /wng/... then /wng/ you get told to go to /wg/. At the end of the day though /wng/ is the lesser of two evils.
>>
>>
>>
>>25202437
Read >>25202398
>>
>>25202437
I believe someone thinking about writing should already have a fairly extensive vocabulary. The kind that makes people roll their eyes in real life when they use it. But that's just my opinion. To try to accomplish that as an adult reminds me of those tiger moms that do flashcards with the toddler and brag to anyone unfortunate enough to be within earshot how their little genius is going to be a doctor or a lawyer or an engineer. You get a big vocabulary from reading a lot which honestly would seem to be a requirement for even entertaining the idea of maybe writing. I suppose if you're ESL this would be useful maybe.
>>
>>
>>25202439
/wng/ will tell you that you aren't likely to find success on WN platforms writing particular genres.
/wg/ will tell you that particular genres are for knuckle dragging retards and that you should be ashamed for even bringing it up their space for superior and refined individuals.
>>
>>25202453
>I believe someone thinking about writing should already have a fairly extensive vocabulary.
That's not really true, just read a random web novel and you'll see. Compare it to, say, Gene Wolfe. There's a great schism between levels. Or even accomplished published writers. Would you say that Sanderson has a vocabulary as extensive as Wolfe's? Yet I think extending your vocabulary is a worthy goal. And using cards or whatever may work too, since anyone writing, ESL or not, had to learn these words in the first place, and likely out of no book.
>>
>>25202459
>/wng/ will tell you that you aren't likely to find success on WN platforms writing particular genres.
it does sound mean but its just the god's truth.
>/wg/ will tell you that particular genres are for knuckle dragging retards and that you should be ashamed for even bringing it up their space for superior and refined individuals.
pretentious pseuds with their air of well practiced insouciance.
>>
>>25202462
>And using cards or whatever may work too, since anyone writing, ESL or not, had to learn these words in the first place, and likely out of no book.
People who learned and correctly use extensive vocabs ALL learned them through books.
>>
File: 1766082717173505.gif (3.7 MB)
3.7 MB GIF
>>25202472
>ALL
>>
>>
>>25202462
I hear you but here's the thing. Tell me you never read a paper in college and you can just tell that the person writing it broke out a thesaurus and its so obvious that they're inserting 50 cent words where 10 cent words would suffice because they think it makes them better. An extensive vocabulary has to be second nature and it just rolls off the tongue. No stopping to find the advanced word to nail your nuanced meaning. I rarely used a dictionary growing up reading vintage paperbacks. 99 times out of 100 context gives it. Do I like learning a new word? Sure. but forcing a vocabulary isn't the best thing. Just reading a lot gives it to you. Even genre writers a lot of them use a decent vocabulary. Now if you want to talk about vocabulary then I give you William F Buckley. WFB filtered people, lol. Carl Sagan I read a few of his books and while he has the vocabulary he seems to use it well. WFB wrote a espionage novel his MC was "Oates" but it half flopped. It was just annoying when his normal highbrow vocabulary got put to genre fiction. For my money's worth though. Dennis Miller particularly his "rants"... he was just highbrow enough it was entertaining. You can tell that anyone who hates him just had no real vocabulary.
TL;DR it has to come natural you can't force it or its doesn't work right.
>>
>>
>>25202472
>People who learned and correctly use extensive vocabularies ALL learned them through books.
maybe not ALL but most people I notice with a good vocabulary read or used to read. When I flip the switch and turn on my vocabulary I can tell from the little smile and getting it back who reads and who doesn't. To me and this is my opinion. Trying to scramble and assimilate an impressive vocabulary without reading a lot later in life is sort of akin to those self help speed reading courses. Its shit. Its snake oil only benefiting the snake oil salesman.
>>
>>25202494
So how do you think they learned it? Teachers don't speak with extensive vocab - dialogue in general, even by intelligent speakers, is greatly restricted compared to written form. So they didn't learn it orally.
You really think they used vocab apps? Come on, now. Everyone learns the nuance of wordcraft by fucking READING. There's a super-rare autist-savant out there, I'm sure, who is the exception, but I don't care about your weird proof to the rule
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202486
But how is a word you learnt from let's say the dictionary any different from a word you learnt from a book? You will say you won't really know how to use it, but isn't the job of the writer to apply words in clever ways? "It's impossible!" Is it really? Hell, there are even collocation dictionaries out there.
>>
>>
>>
>>25202511
Anon. Whatever. You do you. in my/most people's experience, extensive vocabulary used with no effort came from reading a lot. If you think you can flash-card app yourself into some higher plateau then I wish you all the luck in the world. Mind you all these flash card mommies out there annoying everyone how their little genius is going to be a surgeon or an engineer. Well most of those kids I see go on to ask if you want fries with that. You can't meme this. At least not in almost all cases. Now go and memorize your big words because you don't/didn't read enough and throw you're memorized big words out into conversation and annoy everyone even more than people with an actual natural vocabulary. But I'm done and wash my hands of this conversation. Read more or don't its on you.
>>
>>25202511
>>25202537
Tina and F anon are arguing
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202596
>>25202601
It's a legal issue you fucking morons. Allowing certain content can get them taken down or blacklisted by credit card companies
>>
>>
>>
>>25202485
I would say in fact it's the only way possible to learn proper english, because many grammatically sound phrases sound wrong when used in certain ways, or when not used in specific ways. It's why ESLs are so easy to peg. It's only when you learn a word in it's proper context that you can actually use that word correctly and why a PROPER dictionary is REPLETE with examples taken from real texts.
Fuck dry dumbed down definitions. I NEED to see the quotation from some fucking book in the 1700s that's been out of print and is basically lost media. It's the only way to be sure.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202582
>Didn't convince me. Why would a dictionary not explain the meaning of a word? 'Grin' and 'smirk' are different types of smiles, and the dictionary explains this.
to a person who is going to go on to have the vocabulary and use it naturally with no effort. The grin and the smirk are easily told apart by simple context. This all boils down to some weird ultra modern push in today's society. The notion that there's no real intelligence, and people can meme their way into anything. Its simply not so. Forcing a big vocabulary is worse than just having a more pedestrian vocabulary. Kind of like too much cologne smells like desperation.
>>
>>25202517
Did you read the entire series? I read the LN which people say isn't quite as good, and most of it was followed up on and all the red herrings I recall (I haven't done a reread yet) were foreshadowed well in advance, and foreshadowed well.
If it was all pantsed, it was some damn fine pantsing.
>>
>>
File: the trivium cover.jpg (231.7 KB)
231.7 KB JPG
>>25202620
Insufficient examples that are too divorced from their context and surrounding meaning.
Read this and get back to me.
>>
>>25202626
>Forcing a big vocabulary is worse than just having a more pedestrian vocabulary.
If the writer is using the words correctly, why is it bad? I think we are using extremes here, I think, arguing that a person will learn expensive words and use them all the time instead of simple ones. But let's say a person just learns more words so he can have a broader range to express more ideas. Why is it wrong and not proper?
>>
>>
>>
>>25202634
the issue isn't about having a bigger vocab retard it's about learning it through apps completely divorced from context and nuance and when writers actually use that word
hence why he said
>FORCING a big vocabulary
ironically you're failing to understand word nuance in this exact moment
>>
>>25202635
there's so many ways you could shit talk RR stories but weird sex stuff isn't remotely one. that site gets made fun of for autistically avoiding romance and sex. the admins there ban covers with too much cleavage
>>
>>25202639
You're failing to prove that apps can't give context and nuance. You know what, I'm intrigued now, I'll choose an app and see if they're as bad as you people say or if you're trying to be pseuds because you read a book or two.
>>
>>25202600
>You seem dishonest so I don't want to engage with you
This. Its a made-up performative argument. the sort of a person who has to generate questions for no reason other than to draw attention to themselves. They already know the answer, its just because they believe it makes them into an adult in on the adult discussion. The truth is that plenty of genre pulps have been written and published using very limited vocabulary. I've read some and they can be very powerful when done right. There's even a literary style called local color. This is when you deliberately write as if a local speaking. One novel in particular I'll never forget, was written in an uneducated style and it was extra poignant for it. Rare but when it hits the target its great.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202634
>If the writer is using the words correctly
>if
Well nobody cares IF. The problem is people TRY to use bigger words than they should, use them wrong, and sound even more stupid than they would just using simple language.
>>
>>
>>
File: laughing humanities professors.jpg (52.7 KB)
52.7 KB JPG
>>25202642
>or if you're trying to be pseuds because you read a book or two.
Bro this is /lit/.
Where do you think you are?
>>
>>
>>25202659
>It implies nothing of the sort reason my the books.
literal gibberish, thanks for proving my point
>Anyway you've resort to insults personal insults so I'll consider this discussion won. Have a good evening.
another typo, hilariously. you've done nothing but shit your pants but go ahead king, try to leave gracefully
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202634
I will entertain you with a college example. Creative writing class. The teacher read a fake assignment, twice. The first was little red riding hood. The second time, it was little red riding hood with every 50 cent word forced into it. You could tell who was using a thesaurus around the classroom by the looks on their faces. The teacher was being nice about it and asking people to stop trying that without embarrassing them one on one. In real life when people are poking for the advanced word to sound more intelligent, you detect this little pause and see this little performative gesture. When its natural it just flows out like anything. Its really a little kids understanding of the big people's world to think that if you just use big people's words you will instantly be taken more serious and be one of the smart people. Just as a little kid trying to act all "adult", it stands out like a sore thumb. I have infinitely more respect for those who don't force it and roll with what they got. I don't SMIRK at a pedestrian vocabulary when the person is otherwise being logical. I GRIN when someone is being logical and overcoming supposedly more intelligent people. Its the verbal and literary equivalent of someone pretending to be this huge bad ass. Anyone that buys into their bullshit ain't any kind of a tough guy anyways. Real tough guys don't have to pretend. That was a metaphor by the way, just in case anyone has to check their flash cards.
>>
>>
>>
File: noodle.png (155.8 KB)
155.8 KB PNG
>>25202695
>>
>>25202700
you need to reread the posts you fucking tard
>Me: Royalroad is ridiculed for being puritanical about sex
>You: Nah, that's SH
>Me: What?
>You: It's the platform where you can shit talk weird sex stuff
makes no fucking sense, holy shit, learn to talk to people you genuine bonafide autist
>>
>>25202642
>You're failing to prove that apps can't give context and nuance. You know what, I'm intrigued now, I'll choose an app and see if they're as bad as you people say or if you're trying to be pseuds because you read a book or two.
Several hundreds of books, anon. Get it fucking right. My vocabulary was earned. Look, there's this weird yet prevalent idea and its very pervasive. That a person can do little to nothing for the longest time. Then at the last minute? They just... knuckle down and get serious, and do it. As if cramming for a test. This isn't one of those things, anon.
>>
>>
>>25202695
>>25202715
4chan has this annoying tendency of reducing every discussion to the absurd to try to disprove a point.
>>
>>
File: ashbiemoon.png (301.8 KB)
301.8 KB PNG
>>25202730
>>
>>25202653
ScribbleHub has a bot that now performs the cover-check. Used to be done by a human but its automated now. They do impose their own NSFW on cover images. And despite the nick name SmutHub you can't just get away with anything. They used to sort of ignore it but they started cracking down more and more over time on content. RR is way more limiting on smut content though. I admit I have no idea what RR covers allow or don't allow. Goddamn booba anime covers get clicks.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202728
This discussion is basically:
>what if use an app to learn more words and express myself better?
Versus
>WOW you CANNOT do that! You'll end up like a thesaurus-checking mouthbreather every time you try to speak!
>>
>>25202663
>Smile - both sides go up
>Smirk - one side goes up
>Grin - both sides go up and show teeth
>It's not that fucking difficult.
Not really. You're reaching for explicit definitions. Its intent, anon. A smile? Two friends meet and one compliment the other on something, and they smile. Its more context than any formal physical measurement. A smirk? More like a sneer. I'm (in context) looking down on you. The grin can show all sorts of things and many of them are vastly different. Its A-L-L context. There's many kinds of smiles. A smirk, can be both sides go up. The grin can be just one side of the lip corner curling up. Context, grasshopper. Context.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202750
>which of them are you? nobody defends tina or f anon besides each other
I don't know how you roll. I don't give a fuck who said what. If its retarded its retarded. If its objectively right its objectively right. No one is namefagging anyways.
>>
>>25202758
Put your cock and balls on the line. No one will ever know besides you, and you can marinate in your shame if you lie, a far greater shame than whatever embarrassment you feel owning up now. Tell me: you aren't either Tina or F anon?
>>
>>25202750
>>25202760
Wigger threadshitter alert.
>>
File: IMG_7467.jpg (81.6 KB)
81.6 KB JPG
What if anon uses the flash cards but also reads?
>>
>>25202761
you do realize wigger is english slang for white nigger right? white people obsessed with black culture? I don't understand why you keep using it but I'm finally asking
you have to be ESL adopting that term without understanding what it means to english natives
also im not the anon i've seen you use this term on before, first time you've ever applied it to me
>>
>>25202761
your falseflag is transparently obvious because literally nobody likes tina or fff because they're rude as fuck to everyone and either cripplingly mentally ill or genuinely sub 90 iq
>we totally like our attention whores here!
>if you don't agree you're [flavor of the week boogeyman]
leave the thread for a month and I guarantee the thread will sky rocket in quality and attitude
>>
>>
>>
>>25202764
I read on my phone and use it lets you highlight words as you read to add to a local dictionary
every once in awhile I'll scroll through it, reading definitions, and select words to see them back in their contexts
best of both worlds
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202779
Kindles come with some dictionaries, and it saves your highlighted words so you can come back later to look them up or use them if wanted.
>tfw like 13 years of words
>>25202780
>>25202781
This is why you're a wigger. Niggers don't read nor shit up the internet. No fucking nuance like all newfags. Your type will do everything in your fucking power to prevent book discussion between here and /sffg/.
>>
>>
>>
>>25202783
literally what the fuck are you talking about
why are there so many posters that cannot observe the logical through line of a conversation. it's not even an ESL issue, it's just a cognitive processing issue
>>
>>25202788
how you've used the word does not at all imply white person obsessed with black culture. you just learned what that slang means and are desperately trying to rewrite the narrative. i feel such deep embarrassment for you
>>
>>
>>
File: Redd White.jpg (69.7 KB)
69.7 KB JPG
>This sheer ignormous display of hate toward eloquentificness
Splendiferous. Perhaps you are all intimidated by the use of giantesque vocabulary? And on the board of literature no less. How poeticspearian!
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Le5xqVN-oipi3GwSXXH84.png (3.1 MB)
3.1 MB PNG
I was browsingJanitor ai botsand found this gem.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202830
tina has 22 hits if you Control-F in this thread alone. fake-pretending you spend any time here at all but dont know about the thread retard is performative and just more embarrassing proof youre tina trying to masquerade as someone else
do you have a humiliation fetish or something? why do you do this
>>
>>25202842
the bigger question, is why you give a fuck.
(you) are more annoying than the person having the discussion. (you) are the more annoying faggot. (you) are more autistic, than the autistic faggot. not your general. Not your hugbox. or are you a mod, anon. Huh? Tell me, that you're a mod.
>>
File: 1307772451594.jpg (157.3 KB)
157.3 KB JPG
Anybody reading anything interesting?
I'm gonna probably read a bit of Reincarnated as a Noble Assassin (JP LN) since a volume finally dropped after what feels like forever.
>>
>>
>>25202851
no, not particularly. your power of the anonymous crowd rhetoric doesn't work when you make yourself a known quantity
you are in fact the most annoying creature in this thread by a long shot. just stop posting, you're not even sharing your work
atleast fff is starting to move on with his life now that he's completed his project
>>
>>25202852
I'm going to get started on Stranger's Fate when I lay down for bed. I love the concept of mantling and I hope it is shown well in the story. I wish I had my own deep-enough lore understanding to write TES fanfic or hopefully incorporate some of the more esoteric concepts into my own future work.
>>
File: 25475-palus-somni.jpg (111.6 KB)
111.6 KB JPG
>>25202852
https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/25475/palus-somni,lesbian_romance
just completed this. solid short story
the prose and atmosphere is quite good. the author does a good job of quickly establishing the charm of characters which makes this whole set up of "something terrible happens at a convent of cute nuns" set up compelling
drops the ball though. a lot of webnovels have issues with not being well enough planned but I feel as though this has the opposite issue. I get the sense the author had an intended ending scene and forced its arrival. might just be a me thing but it felt out of place
lots of great scenes, set pieces, and iconic characters. fun read, if anyone likes horror short stories I'd recommend it even if it ends oddly
>>
File: strangers-fate-aacakshruhu.jpg (86.1 KB)
86.1 KB JPG
>>25202859
>I wish I had my own deep-enough lore understanding to write TES fanfic or hopefully incorporate some of the more esoteric concepts into my own future work.
TES lore is cool but I don't think it was worth the thousands of hours I spent playing and posting in TES general threads on /v/ and /vg/ to learn it.
>My misadventure in Elsweyr began in the sweaty pits of the summer of 427 at a lavish Saint Alessia Day feast held at the estate of my patron and friend, Marius Publius. I had arrived ragged as a dishcloth, having trekked on foot from the imperial capital's fish market where I had been surviving for weeks in the attic of an old fishmonger who had double leased the space between a spice merchant and myself. It halved my rent but left me with a prison bunk’s worth of space betwixt the window and an unsteady wall of crates that shed all manner of flakes, grindings, and peppercorns which brought on the most dreadful sneezing fits whenever I dared to stir too much.
That's a pretty crazy second sentence to open with. I like that it's written in the native voice though, pretty cool for a fanfic.
>>
>>25202855
>I give a fuck because you derail so many conversations with your inane and incomprehensible rambling.
Not so. you have merely learned/been taught... that I'm not one of the cool kids.
>sometimes I reply assuming its a human but it turns out to be you.
see? when you don't know its me, I'm intelligent. you are beholden to group opinion, who is cool and who isn't. and that's grade-school bullshit. Honestly until someone goes "hey! that's tina!" I'm doing fine. now what does that tell you. that's normie behavior.
>>
File: IMG_5376.jpg (130.3 KB)
130.3 KB JPG
Knowing the meaning of a word is quite different from being able to call it forth to your writing. If by reading and by sweeping flash cards you can learn a word, what is the right path to mastering it?
>>
>>
File: abc of reading by ezra pound.jpg (16.3 KB)
16.3 KB JPG
>>25202867
>mastering a word
Bro start here (hint it's poetry)
>>
>>
>>
>>25202856
>no, not particularly. your power of the anonymous crowd rhetoric doesn't work when you make yourself a known quantity
>you are in fact the most annoying creature in this thread by a long shot. just stop posting, you're not even sharing your work
>atleast fff is starting to move on with his life now that he's completed his project
why would i share my work.
so some asshole (you) could say it sucked whether it did or not?
so some fuck could nuke my work, because no reasons?
the truth is that I've shared my work at times, and gotten praised or at least told it was more tha adequate.
oh, when its "tina" work? its shit.
when bit was anonymous though, it was good to passable.
that tells me all I need to know.
what *really* bugs you fuckers though, is that you literally can't get me down. You mean nothing more than barking dogs I pass walking by on the street. you mean, and indeed are... literally nothing. (you) are the joke. When I flip the switch and use a new pen name one day? You'll never know. You're literally beneath my notice. What really chaps your ass is that you can't get under my skin. Try harder faggot.
>>
>>25202867
I don’t know. Maybe try writing the same sentence with different words and see how you like it.
Pan sat on a flat rock with her frown resting on her hands.
Pan slumped on a desert slab, her pout plopped between gloved palms.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Elements of Eloquence cover.jpg (54.4 KB)
54.4 KB JPG
>>25202874
If you did poetry, you would have known to use 'loathe.'
>>25202879
>Pan slumped on a desert slab, her pout plopped between gloved palms.
This is what people are complaining about dude. Nobody likes this.
Read this.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25202893
tina is a man
why does he advertise himself as tina? who the fuck knows
>low caps
he alternates. refer to >>25202876
just don't reply to stupid, poorly articulated posts. the main thing that makes our resident dipshits stand out is that they can barely form a coherent sentence and make up for it by meandering into a long post
>>
>>
>>25202887
>This is what people are complaining about dude. Nobody likes this.
Okay. Then stop worrying about the individual sentences and focus on the scene as a whole.
Pan flopped on a flat stone, her head sagging in her hands as if it weighed a ton. Looking around, there was sand, sand, and more sand, and a boring blue sky that was too darn bright.
“Ugh, this is so lame,” she groaned.
Seriously, why was she even here? This whole quest didn’t go the way she had imagined at all.
>>
>>
File: 184934101-256-k450143.jpg (15.4 KB)
15.4 KB JPG
>>25201504
>This post really speaks to the power of putting boobs on the cover. Marketing is EVERYTHING. This guy read so much slop hoping it would justify the cover/blurb/premise.
There weren't even boobs on the cover, lmao.
>>
>>25202949
Honestly dude, you were book-simping for that? Come on now. Tell me the blurb was really good at least.
>>25202918
I remember loving the Moon is a Harsh Mistress when I read it long ago. Did it have weird prose? I think I just blasted through it and thought the idea of gravity bombing earth and cell structured networks and libertarianism were cool as hell.
>>
>>25203017
Maybew "weird prose" was wrong way of wording it, but it's how Heinlein thinks newspeak will develop in a hundred years or so with lunar colonists, I guess like how Australian english is so different from British English. The mix of Russian and Spanish accents that he does in the first person with Manual's 1st PoV and the others in general. Never read prose done in this kind of style before. I like to imagine reading Manual's voice/narrative as TF2 Heavy and Knot as Mei Ling from MGS2.
>>
>>25203017
>Tell me the blurb was really good at least
I'm not even sure I looked at the blurb. It might have gotten into my backlog from me being interested in some other book the writer wrote and just dumping all their works into my backlog. And it was a fairly short read up until the point I dropped it. Figured it was fine giving it the benefit of the doubt that the author wouldn't do the dumbest twist imaginable up until they did. Before then, some asspulls could have cleaned up most of my problems with the narrative. They'd already done one with the whole "actually the MC was magically turned into a sociopath which is why her kill count is so high".
>>
>>25203017
>>25203045
Oh, the MC was like 70 years old and had committed somewhere along the lines of 14000 murders.
>>
>>25202627
>all the red herrings I recall (I haven't done a reread yet) were foreshadowed well in advance, and foreshadowed well.
Red herring is misdirection that goes nowhere by definition. How do you "foreshadow" that, dumb esl
>>
>get a message from some business saying they want to make a short audio drama series of my story
>mildly curious
>check out their website
>nothing but an endless sea of AIslop
wow, there really isn't one honest soul left in the world
>>
>>25203048
>that goes nowhere by definition
This is incorrect. It doesn't have to go nowhere, just be misleading.
There is also foreshadowing for the correct interpretation of the narrative throughout kumo desu ga, but it subverts expectations created in the readers by the red herrings. For instance, the assumption that the human and spider chapters happen at roughly the same time. Not only is that not stated, there are explicit signs that indicate it's not the case that an attentive reader would notice. That's the foreshadowing.
Kumo Desu Ga is a masterpiece of global literature.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Bh6oWdd11Y.png (21.8 KB)
21.8 KB PNG
>>25203100
...click it?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25203457
>>25203457
>>25203457
New thread