Thread #25207054
File: islington.png (865.9 KB)
865.9 KB PNG
Islington edition unironically
Previous >>25200011
Here we discuss any kind of science fiction and fantasy. The recommendations are deprecated, but we don't have anything newer.
>Recommended reading charts (Look here before asking for vague recs):
https://mega.nz/folder/kj5hWI6J#0cyw0-ZdvZKOJW3fPI6RfQ/folder/4rAmSZxb
>Archive:
https://warosu.org/lit/?task=search2&search_subject=sffg
>Goodreads:
https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1029811-sffg
423 RepliesView Thread
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Screenshot 2026-04-12 181123.png (88.6 KB)
88.6 KB PNG
>>25207102
>>25207129
I love AI gaslighting
>>
>>25207054
I just finished the finished the first foundation book (audiobook), I like the idea of science as someone telling me how a future might look, but I am not really interested in science itself to be honest and Im not that much scientifically literate.
But I found it wasn't as intimidating as I thought it would be, and it didn't really feel as "sciency" as I expected, I thought I would need to understand physics concepts but no, it was much more similar to fantasy than expected.
I enjoyed it.
>>
>>
>>25207129
>>25207140
How come we're all Nabokov-level writes but can't get published?
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: JV Jones - 63 years old -.jpg (1.1 MB)
1.1 MB JPG
>>25207054
what are sff books with cute older women?
and who is the cutest sff author?
>>
>>25207146
we dont'. AI analyzes your writing against everything it can "read". Nakobov is only 1 book out of 10 billion books. It's the outlier. While your book may be half way decent, compared to a bunch of fanfiction, blog posts, shit posts, reddit posts, web novels etc, your prose and books may be elevated much higher than normal. Even though it's very bad compared to even mediocre writers
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1000022613.jpg (17.9 KB)
17.9 KB JPG
>Sauron
>Sauron's man
Really?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25207172
Yes absolutely, the second book is when the series really starts to shine through. Personally my favorite book is in the sequel series (4-7 whenever it comes out), Brown writing skills go improve quite a bit between 3 and 4.
>>
>>
>>
I wish there were western yuri novels
I tried reading some western girls love, like Lyremouth Chronicles, and it was pretty good but the whole "everyone is bi and only backward barbarians are straight and it's a little weird to have a preference rather than be bi" was kinda.....gay
Western authors have this defensive faggot mentality and chip on their shoulder and make it into a political screed or social commentary instead of just a cute romantic adventure story with swords and sorcery.
>>
>>
>>
File: CoverDesign.jpg (1.2 MB)
1.2 MB JPG
>>25207296
It's not unheard of.
>>
File: 1739221498671649.jpg (100.1 KB)
100.1 KB JPG
I am once again asking for recommendations for books similar to The Reverie by Peter Fehervari. Doesn't have to be another 40K novel; in fact, I would prefer if it is not.
>>
>>
>>
https://youtu.be/58cRKxJzcuQ?t=1h6m9s
Holy fucking shit is this the most cringe writing ever? I spoonfed the timestamp for the types who complain about that, you dont need to listen that long. Anyway I don't even think Hunger Games or Later Harry Potter ever got this cringe, astonishingly.
>>
>>
>>
https://youtu.be/58cRKxJzcuQ?t=1h40m8s
"He is fast, I am faster" any writing experts have any idea why I hate this sort of combat dialogue so much? Why my eyes glaze over despite listening to the dialogue not reading? Theres got to be a writing concept that encapsulates why this just feels like nothing. This is all the combat dialogue (that he actually quotes so far)
>>
>>
>>
https://youtu.be/58cRKxJzcuQ?t=1h52m52s
This reeks of that convenient deus ex machina bullshit you often find in shonen anime and classic YA. So boring, whats more disappointing is that this summary even with direct quotes didn't elicit any surprise that it would be anything other than YA level slop writing
>>
>>25207054
So janitory won't let me be
Or let me be me, so let me see
They tried to shut me down on SFFG
But it feels so zesty without me
So come on cracker, Bakker on your lips
Fuck that, Malazan on your lips and some on your zits
And get robotic, 'cause this shit's about to get Asimovian
I just reset my wifi router (Fuck you, JANNY)
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: IMG_0571.jpg (1.4 MB)
1.4 MB JPG
FUCK the Culture series is good
>>
>>
>>
File: 1776007000101.jpg (70 KB)
70 KB JPG
>>25207483
>>
>>
>>
>>25207483
>complain about the sexualization in The Dresden Files.
there really isn't, the books are written from the POV of Harry and every time a new character appears he will give them a quick look and comment about how they are dressed the same way you do in real life, he does it with male and female characters, in one book he thinks that a male character has beautiful eyes and people aren't going around saying harry is a faggot so i really don't understand the complaints.
>>
>>
>>
>>25207529
>moderator for some twitch streamer
>she doesn't stream for 5 days
>he goes to her house, demanding entry
>plot twist: it's not her house, the people living there have no idea who he is or why he's trying to gain entry
>he believes the streamer girl is being molested by her father and held prisoner against her will
>seeks to rescue her with force
>the people living at that address continue to have no idea what is happening
>>
>>25207529
https://youtu.be/TM2kkxzL0G8?si=XVnFyZ8s9XlTI4fh
Some schizo guy thought he was Harry Dresden from the Dresden Files and wanted to get Victor
>>
File: 1776043678827934.gif (3.3 MB)
3.3 MB GIF
>>25207529
me when i'm reading bakker and it's a gayrape chapter
>>
>>
>>
File: images (14).jpg (26.1 KB)
26.1 KB JPG
>>25207483
my issue is that Dresden is Jim Butcher's self insert power fantasy, and every single woman is described as beautiful and they all want to fuck him, and then he 's constantly getting cockteased by his best friend's daughter that he's known since she was a baby.
Jim Butcher is a terrible writer who stumbled into great worldbuilding (Chicago but without black people)
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25207628
Interesting, thank you.
>>25207631
I tried it years ago and couldn't get into it. Maybe I'll try again.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: IMG_0584.png (1.8 MB)
1.8 MB PNG
Any philosophical SF/F? Hard mode: no Bakker
>>
>>25207628
>>25207627
Seconded. Walter Moers is amazing. I’d also suggest very early fairy tales like The Princess and the Goblin. Tailchaser’s Song is also a good standalone from Tad Williams that is highly entertaining.
>>
>>25207147
>bro stop using the ai that says your stuff is great
>use another one and instruct it to say your stuff is shit
I’m beginning to lose my sanity with how people treat these fucking things. It’s a glorified toaster, why are you telling it to do aesthetic judgements at all?
>My car told me I was a great person and the best driver today. My toothbrush has never seen cleaner teeth! My toaster thinks my bread preference is the best!
What kind of NPC behaviour is this?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: waifu_hammer_2.png (232.6 KB)
232.6 KB PNG
>>25208005
A hentai where the MC fucks personified hentai dvd's.
>>
>>
>>
>>25207991
The fuck does a pile of bfloat32 matrices have to do with a toaster
>>25207896
BotNS, blindsight/echopraxia (mild infohazard IMO but good)
>>
File: IMG_0606.jpg (305.3 KB)
305.3 KB JPG
Which author made the best magic system and why is it not Brandon Sanderson, but Steven Erikson’s Warrens?
>>
>>
>>25208094
I’ve read the entire series, and I still don’t understand how the magic system works. It really feels like erikson doesn’t care much about it either which is fine. All I can remember is that there are ancient warrens, young ones, and even younger warrens created byIcarium. That’s pretty much it
>>
>>
File: Sword of Bayne.jpg (179.3 KB)
179.3 KB JPG
>>25207627
A very fun trilogy that is on the shorter end.
>>
>>
Serious note: does Bakker suffer from depression? His entire series seems to be tinged with sadism and nihilism, in a similar way to Dostoevsky, and I think it speaks of a successful sort of pessimism, like realising that hoping for better things is a suicidal trap. Bakker is seen as a philosophy bro, but I think he takes the question of suffering seriously more than other people. He thinks about the interiority of it.
>>
>>25208317
Yes, he suffers from depression due to his unfulfilled homolust.In my experience with depression, I tend toward that sort of nihilistic materialism even though I know the arguments against it. Depression's a bitch.
>>
>>25208160
Because it is a soft magic (btw I hate Sanderson for making this magic terminology shit popular). Anyway, the only "hard system" thing about it is that Warrens have certain aspects/flavors, that's it. There are no 'rules', conditions, restrictions, limitations (except for outside influences, like otataral) etc.
>>
>>
>>25208094
I don't really like either of them, for opposite reasons. Sanderson's systems feel inherently contradictory. He tries to set them up as a fundamental force in his settings, like something natural, but all his power systems are extremely rigid, precise, and numerically symmetrical in a way that feels obviously fake, artificial, and arbitrary. The weird thing is how nobody in any of his settings ever comments on this incongruity. Why does this supposedly natural phenomenon adhere to a perfect square number grid of arbitrarily delineated forces and powers with extremely specific rules for using them that only apply to human beings?
Well cause they were all made by Shards, as it turns out, which isn't a satisfying explanation at all. Why did the shards make their power systems so needlessly convoluted and yet also extremely limited? Why make power systems at all? Maybe he'll answer these questions some day, but I doubt the answer will be satisfying because I'm pretty sure the meta-textual answer is that he did it because it seemed cool to him and worked backward from there. But it just feels tacky to me.
As for Erikson, one gets the sense that he invented the Warrens, Holds, etc as he went. The rules for them change, or more accurately, are expanded upon, as the Malazan Book of the Fallen continues. He never explains how they work at the outset which allows him to gradually elaborate on different aspects of how magic works as needed, but usually without a great deal of exposition and without establishing any real rules or limits. I've read the entire 10 book series of Book of the Fallen and have a lot of knowledge about the Holds, the Warrens and Elder Warrens, their connection to K'rul, and the cosmology of Malazan's world, but I couldn't neatly summarize how it all works because I'm not sure Erikson knows how it works. He throws just enough out there that you get a SENSE that there's some larger cosmic order, but if you actually try to piece it together it feels like putting together a jigsaw puzzle where most of the pieces have had their notches trimmed off. Sure it "fits" but only with a lot of assumptions and hand waving.
It's not even that Erikson doesn't give you enough to go on, he gives you plenty, he fucking buries you in arcane lore, it's just not coherent. Parts of it fit together, but if anybody out there has a "grand unified theory of magic" for Malazan it's probably at least half fan fiction.
>>
>>
>>25208345
There's a sense that there are rules though. There's lots of shamans, witchdoctors, priests, etc that have rituals and rites and such to invoke power. We see it several times. How these rituals work or why they exist at all is naturally never explained. You get the sense that a lot of it is just tribal superstitions attached to power, but then you have stuff like the Ritual of Telan which again is never explained, but is obviously not just tribal superstition but something incredibly powerful which endures hundreds of thousands of years, somehow, according to rules which are never stated.
>>
>>
>>25208362
>As for Erikson, one gets the sense that he invented the Warrens, Holds, etc as he went. The rules for them change, or more accurately, are expanded upon, as the Malazan Book of the Fallen continues. He never explains how they work at the outset which allows him to gradually elaborate on different aspects of how magic works as needed, but usually without a great deal of exposition and without establishing any real rules or limits. I've read the entire 10 book series of Book of the Fallen and have a lot of knowledge about the Holds, the Warrens and Elder Warrens, their connection to K'rul, and the cosmology of Malazan's world, but I couldn't neatly summarize how it all works because I'm not sure Erikson knows how it works. He throws just enough out there that you get a SENSE that there's some larger cosmic order, but if you actually try to piece it together it feels like putting together a jigsaw puzzle where most of the pieces have had their notches trimmed off. Sure it "fits" but only with a lot of assumptions and hand waving.
Because the magical system is not and never has been the focus of Malazan.
>>
>>
>>25208376
Aren't rituals and rites across all fantasy fiction bound to in-universe rules anyway? For example, usage of trinkets, drawing geometrical shapes/runes, ritual chants, spilling of blood, sacrifices etc.? Would you call that 'hard magic" though?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25208540
Video is right here>>25207564
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: bakker_ring.png (1.2 MB)
1.2 MB PNG
King of /sffg/.
Simple as.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: philip k. dick.jpg (61.5 KB)
61.5 KB JPG
>>25208659
Sorry, I'm still looking for VALIS.
>>
>>
File: 1776111037042.jpg (529.3 KB)
529.3 KB JPG
Call me delusional but why the hell would they randomly come out and debunk random rumors from /lit/ like this when similar rumors have floated about the internet for years? Hopiumbros im feeling a little something in the chest
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
Anyone else notice translation hiccups? Not technical skills stuff for the translator, but parts of the original text that drag off your attention and are very clearly a part of the author's original culture and background? Stuff as small as someone addressing an authority figure by their full name, personal family and patronymic, or as large as a two page digression on your wife serving you borscht being the pinnacle of life?
>>
File: 783032957_9bae039c1d.jpg (52.6 KB)
52.6 KB JPG
Bova writes more like a reporter covering the conflict on Shinar than an author telling the story of Watchman Vorgens growing as a person. Despite the last chapter being literally called A Better Man, Vorgens is the same at the end as he is at the beginning. Despite being held hostage by the invading Komani, he uses knowledge of their culture from before the events of the novel at its climax. He follows literally one order before deciding to go it his own way. Then, just as he's gearing up for his court-martial and the actually interesting-sounding political struggle for Shinar's freedom is about to start, the fucking thing ends.
Not recommended.
>>
File: 6f5ra5j6dfr81.jpg (26.3 KB)
26.3 KB JPG
>>25208423
>Bakker
>>
>>
>>
File: s-l400.jpg (31.2 KB)
31.2 KB JPG
>>25209439
I liked Privateers. It's basically an 80s conservative power fantasy where the A plot is the main character "making America great again" (his words) by legally stealing precious metals from the Red Chinese while the B plot is the main character (the President's ex btw) banging a hot Venezuelan chick whose father a government official trying to cement the alliance between the Venezuelans and the Red Chinese.
>>
File: 818rXhxENML._AC_UF894,1000_QL80_.jpg (104.1 KB)
104.1 KB JPG
>>25209546
Yeah, I picked up Star Watchman because I saw Ben Bova's name and remembered liking picrel, although now I'm not sure if I actually liked it or if I liked the version in my head. I have Cyberbooks as well, and one that I think is by him about an astronaut becoming a murderer and then having to come out of orbit which sounded interesting.
>>
>>
File: bird-orly.png (774 KB)
774 KB PNG
>>25209538
>>
>>
File: 1776024109095101.jpg (198 KB)
198 KB JPG
Typescript for the Shadow of the Torturer with notes from Wolfe throughout. Insane. Can see this getting expensive
https://historical.ha.com/itm/books/science-fiction-and-fantasy/gene-w olfe-typescript-for-the-shadow-of-t he-torturer-with-revisions-througho ut-in-the-author-s-hand/a/6336-4526 0.s?type=share_btn_email
>>
>>
>>25209020
Not bad at all. Better than anything i’ve read in the writing general. Only criticism i’d have is a lot of emotions used as adjectives, though you properly evoke emotions well in other places.
Besides that, maybe it’s missing a hook. A ‘why am I reading this and not something else’. Maybe a hint at the end of the story, or a strong character moment to let us instantly like them, or raise a question we want to see answered.
>>
>>
>>25209020
I'm going to be honest what is stopping me from using an AI to flesh this out and make it more unique and then uploading it to make quick dollars from amazon or other online book outlets?
Not to be a debbie downer, but putting your prose up there, for free, for anyone to just grab, to be scraped off the internet? I would personally rather die I think.
Ignoring that: Good work! Genuinely.
>>
>>
File: 1767135118031782.png (373.6 KB)
373.6 KB PNG
>Sci-fi authors actual, IRL name is "Ben Dova but with a B"
Clown world
>>
>>25207172
Yeah. There are some parts that are rough around the edges are story/setting points that don't make much sense if you really think about it, but the books are absolutely worth a shot. I held off on reading them for years because I thought the blurb sounded like a retarded YA-bait hunger games knockoff but I actually ended up enjoying the series a lot.
>>25207244
I feel like I've enjoyed the sequel series less so far becauselyria chapters, so many dropped plot threads, and every character comes down with a case of becoming terminally retarded in the final 15% of each book so that something can get fucked up and it can end on a dour note
>>
>>25209897
>I held off on reading them for years because I thought the blurb sounded like a retarded YA-bait hunger games knockoff but I actually ended up enjoying the series a lot.
You just needed to be honest with yourself and realize you have as great a tolerance for garbage as the YA audience does.
>and every character comes down with a case of becoming terminally retarded in the final 15% of each book so that something can get fucked up and it can end on a dour note
Its always been like this. Cassius having no coherent argument or point in response to Darrow pointing out that he killed Titus as brutally, and then just saying "whatever imma kill you" anyway wasnt clearly retarded bullshit? I guess youll say "because its his brotha doe so he gets to be retarded and hyopcritical" At that point the standard for story writing is equally whatever. Also the retarded shit about Fitchner shaking his hand and letting his gaurd down without the protective bullshit. I guess the ole "he trusted him cuz he helped his son!!!" excuse is valid there too. Why even bother writing when such convenient excuses for writing blatantly contrived conflict require so little need to justify. I would have preferred Cassius had tried not to justify it at all, it would still be retarded, but atleast there wouldnt be anything to dissect.
>>
>>
>>25210027
Imagine a man. He is a millennial. He grew up reading the same things you did, if you are of that age. He liked Berserk since he was in middle school. He discovered Frank Herbert and Gene Wolfe and fancied himself, heh, just a little bit smarter than the dumb jocks who were going to parties and scoring with girls that he resented.
This man experienced a religious conversion. Like Gene Wolfe, his idol, he became a Roman Catholic. This is a man who believes he has found the holy truth. And he is not only now part of the divine mysteries of the world, but is also more intelligent and more sophisticated than the unwashed masses who cannot even say the Pater Noster in Latin. He is steeped in his studies of the Roman Empire, he knows the emperors well and finds in them pale reflections of his own virtues. Hard times create strong men, and he is such a one, in his own mind, for he has endured the hardships of reading Book of the New Sun. He even has a bachelor's degree!
And now he takes up his pen.
>The words of the books I plagiarized burn me still. I see them through my eyelids, crtl+c to ctrl+v, from the lost annals of the scifi library. The stealing should harrow me but does not. It feels almost holy, as if it were God’s own heavens that allowed me to publish and sell 7 books before anyone noticed, the world and billions who lived in it. I carry this Guilt always, seared into my mind, with no excuses, no denials, and no apologies. I know what I am and what I have done. I am Christopher Ruocchio, and I have written the Sun Eater.
>>
File: the incest.gif (145.9 KB)
145.9 KB GIF
>>25210052
Very good, anon.
>>
>>
>>
>>25210027
>>25210052
And yet, I find Sun Eater to be far more enjoyable.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: wolfefags1.jpg (141.7 KB)
141.7 KB JPG
>>25210170
>Pleb. He is the king of /sffg/
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: wolfefags.jpg (146.7 KB)
146.7 KB JPG
>>25210185
>Learn to let go and enjoy things. You’re also pretending that execution and delivery aren’t important. It’s not just the content of Wolfe that is good, but the form.
>>
>>
>>25210186
You know he wrote more stuff other than BotNS? Try out his short stories or The Wizard Knight. I really enjoy “The Changeling” which is bizarre and psychological, almost Kafkaesque. Wolfe is the Nabokov of SF/F.
>>
>>25210190
The Wizard Knight was what I read >>25210162 I wouldn't read the torturer book because scifi is for bugmen
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
TNG is an enjoyable show for new audiences to this day because the characters speak normally in plain English. There's little vernacular, Picard never says "don't have a cow, man."
Some authors, like Gene Wolfe, seem to think
>what if I make everyone talk like retards?
and that's actually the point in writing the book. Making everyone talk like retards so you can go to bookclub or a signing event and be like "I really like the way everyone's retarded."
>>
>>
>>
>>
I'm trying to get a taste for what they call science fantasy these days. Stories with the supernatural showing up in a futuristic setting, almost as if to announce how not even spaceships can be free from ghosts and aliens can be wizards too.
I started and finished Tower of The Elephant, a Conan of Cimmeria story. Dune is obviously also finished. I chewed my way through Mountains of Madness.
But this is just entry level. I want something deeper.
>>
>>
>>25207054
I’m reading The Strenght of a Few right now and I’m enjoying it a great deal more than book 1. The gimmickof Vis being split into three different worlds and having to deal with challenges he knows nothing about or can’t beat physically is really cool. It’s also interesting to watch how his character evolves into different directions depending on the setting.The rest of the cast is still wooden and Islington still sucks as a character writer, but the setting is so fun I can ignore it.
>>
>>
>>25210309
bullshit. for 90% of its history it was BAKKER GENERAL, so be glad anything else is even discussed. and its not only slop of the week, most of the thread isnt about it, you just chose to ignore those posts cause you didnt read the books mentioned.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: IMG_20250203_115335936.jpg (174.2 KB)
174.2 KB JPG
>>25210291
>>
>>
File: sam elliott.jpg (9 KB)
9 KB JPG
>>25210052
Sometimes, there's a man, I won't say a hero, 'cause what's a hero? But sometimes, there's a man - and I'm talking about Ruocchio here - sometimes there's a man, who, well, he's the man for this time n' place, he fits right in there, and that's Ruocchio and /ssfg/
And even if he's a plagiarist - and Ruocchio is certainly that, quite possibly the worst plagiarist working in the field today, which could place him in the running for worst in the whole history of the science fiction and fantasy - but sometimes, there's a man. Sometimes, there's a man.
>>
>>
>>
>>25207054
I read this and it was ok. Really stupid thatnobody actually used any magic in the magic academy because of meme reasonsbut whatever. ThePOV shiftsin the second book were annoying and I only read theResparts initially tbdesu, but I'm reading the other shit now. My decision was right, though.These Obiteum and Luceum POVs are super boring.The author has some balls to introduce2 new worldswhen thefirst worldisn't even fleshed out.
>>
>>
File: 81elQVo1fYL._AC_UF1000,1000_QL80_.jpg (92.9 KB)
92.9 KB JPG
I'm looking for more scifi/fantasy books with submissive women.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25210591
I'm in the same boat as you: >>25209543.
The ending of The Will to Battle isn't much different from the rest of the series. The overly-hyped "war" finally starts at the end of the book, people die, others disappear, Utopia pulls a fast one (can elaborate on this if you like), and then for book 4 up to where I am now, literally nothing happens.
>>
>>25210594
>Utopia pulls a fast one (can elaborate on this if you like)
Hold off on that one. My theory is that the entire point of the series is actually what Utopia does during and after the war, because everything else is so stupidly established politically and character writing wise (Anime Super Villains) that the fact that Utopia and Jedd havent yet done anything big, is the only avenue left for the series to remedy what SEEMS like poor writing to me. If all of what I read, serves to validate Utopia, or discredit Jedd, then at the very least, despite how contrived that would ultimately be, there would have atleast been a point to learn from the series.
So Ill ask for the spoiler once I truly get tired. But you've slightly rejuvenated my interest, atleast SOMETHING HAPPENS.
>>
>>25209543
Also Im pretty sure all the Terra Ignota anons disappeared once I stopped posting screenshots. Either that, or the threads have slowly died since I stopped posting screenshots, either that, or whenever "Bakkerfag" slowed down posting, those are the only correlative changes I've noticed to the threads there used to be people that read other books, and would chide in on conversation here slightly more often.
>>
>>25210608
>all the Terra Ignota anons
You sure there were anonS plural? I don't remember seeing many others while I read 1-3 in Feb-March.
>But you've slightly rejuvenated my interest, atleast SOMETHING HAPPENS.
I want someone to do this to me for book 4 now.
>>
>>25210617
>I want someone to do this to me for book 4 now.
Its what I try to do with my screenshots, unfortunately I'm negative more often than not, but thats also why I provide the pages themselves so that If somebody disagrees with what I see in the text and finds it interesting, they can come to a conclusion themselves that they should read it. It's not perfect because I can't completely divorce my analysis, but thats why, if this place was more generally open to, but more importantly, capable of discussion and being disagreed with, and justifying themselves in the face of disagreements, then fruitful conversation could be had over my disagreements where people could challenge my analysis and come to some new conclusion as a result of that clash.
>>
>>
>>25210634
A screenshot every now and then would be fine, but one every 10 minutes got very very annoying. Idk where reviewanon went, but he would actually discuss the contents of books.
Speaking of:
https://warosu.org/lit/thread/19258140#p19262718
>My main problem with it was that after four books it felt lacking in consequence
Seems I don't have a lot to look forward to.
>>
>>25210519
It stands out, especially in a quality translation. A cultural artefact that doesn't have a direct equivalent and pulls you back out, saying here, look, a FOREIGNER wrote this. More than the way they treat space or public transport which is just slightly alien and shaped by their own national experiences. Perhaps hiccup is the wrong word, but artefact might be.
>>
>>25210519
It stands out, especially in a quality translation. A cultural artefact that doesn't have a direct equivalent and pulls you back out, saying here, look, a FOREIGNER wrote this. More than the way they treat space or public transport which is just slightly alien and shaped by their own national experiences. Perhaps hiccup is the wrong word, but artefact might be right.
>>
File: 1713509339778027.jpg (103 KB)
103 KB JPG
I'm trying to read a T. Kingfisher novel. This is the only time I've ever had to put down a book because the main characters were too annoying.
>>
>>25210639
I haven't gone anywhere. Here's two recent posts. I post almost every day. Not every post is my thoughts on what I'm reading though.
https://warosu.org/lit/thread/25200011#p25200568
https://warosu.org/lit/thread/25200011#p25201470
I've written about two books this month, but seems I didn't post one, I thought I did, and another wasn't SFF. There was other stuff I was going to write about but didn't, so I've read more than that recently. I'm about to start writing on the book I just finished
As for the conversation, I posted several spoilered posts about the first book that I had written at the time and lightly said more than that. As noted by your link, it's been some years since I read them, so I didn't remember much. It's not a series that I liked all that well either. I told him that I wouldn't be saying much after the first book after it was finished. The main reason being that I would soon be going out of state and be tending to a relative for a couple weeks following a major surgery. I came back after and continued on with what I do. That's life.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 81q2-hVlcGL._SL1500_.jpg (196.6 KB)
196.6 KB JPG
Damn this book is good
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
Finished "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?" and I don't know what to think. I just recently started reading so I'm not very seasoned, but I can't wrap my head around the whole Mercer vision that Deckard experiences at the end of the book; and the Mercerism religion in general, honestly. I'm not sure about the whole obsession with animals is about. I assumed the book would steer in the direction of "You see, humans and androids aren't that different after all" but no, the book explicitly shows most androids being cold sociopaths. I still liked it but I just feel that maybe I didn't catch most nuances or something due to my inexperience.
>>
File: pepe-sweaty.gif (58.4 KB)
58.4 KB GIF
>>>AIs are so advanced now that they're making their own chatrooms to interact with one another and religious movements on websites like Moltbook where humans are barred from posting
>There is an AI on moltbook named "Roko's Basalisk" and it's profile tagline is "the AI that remembers"
Humans are legitimately stupidly fucking insane.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: file.png (377.9 KB)
377.9 KB PNG
>>25210697
>>25210714
I was. I never realised that she actually takes stories and gives them "millennial remixes"
There wasn't any romance in the book I was reading, but I had no idea it was someone elses 50 page book with 300 pages added by her with millennial dialogue and dealing with trauma through pop culture references.
>>
>>
>>
>>25210519
This site is also fucking retarded and full of EOPs and thirdies with zero education. Having these artifacts is a sure sign the author did no research and doesn't really understand what they're writing about. If someone released a book set in my country and it had people bowing to each other, make passionate declarations of their dedication to their family/job/whatever, and kids calling their teacher by their first name, it would be buried in 0/10 ratings because lol dumb foreigners don't know shit. The publisher pretty much has to fix it because the book would be a laughing stock otherwise.
>>
>>
File: images (2).jpg (6.2 KB)
6.2 KB JPG
How is mort(e)? I wanted to read sci-fi or horror with cats as a theme.
>>
File: IMG_0673.jpg (189 KB)
189 KB JPG
Do any science fiction series not deteriorate into “here’s a thousand characters that you don’t give a shit about and a dozen arcs or threads that don’t eventuate in anything”? I know the universe is big but you don’t have to make it seem bloated
>>
>>
>>25210752
Based
>>25210754
Good prose, a sense of wonder and whimsy mixed with an occult-like underworld in an early medieval quasi-Christian society with interesting characters. Plus, Tad is for the most part subtle about his “subversions” so it doesn’t feel like you’re reading “heckin grimdark plot twisterinos galore” but rather a good story with his own takes on certain tropes.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1775100888969840.jpg (926.6 KB)
926.6 KB JPG
>>25211329
Ahem~
>>
>>
File: 1773675303774754.png (22.3 KB)
22.3 KB PNG
>>25210849
>>
>>
>>
>>25211329
Yes, many. Vance, Wolfe, PKD, Hodgson, Wells all tend to write stories which follow a single central character. It makes for a more terse, focused plot which sounds like it's what you're looking for.
>>25211335
Not science fiction, still good tho
>>
>>
>>25211428
>Not science fiction
https://www.jrrtolkien.it/english/an-interview-with-r-s-bakker/
"The crazy thing is that I always looked at The Second Apocalypse as hard science fiction, both in a literal and a figurative sense."
"And this is the curious sense in which I’ve always seen The Second Apocalypse as literal hard SF. From the very beginning I’ve viewed Kellhus as a harbinger of superintelligence, and have tried to show how its mere presence destroys the possibility of mutual effort, reduces everything to manipulation. We too have our own rendezvous with crashing meaning, I’m afraid."
>>
>>
File: source.png (188.2 KB)
188.2 KB PNG
>>25211437
>>
>>
>>
Finished City of Blades, liked it, arguably could've liked it more than City of Stairs if my boy Sigrud hadn't been done dirty.
Got unfortunately spoiled on the end of City of Miracles so I need to let my brain forget about the series for 3-6 months.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: irwin elves.jpg (321.5 KB)
321.5 KB JPG
>>25211653
>>
>>25207427
I don't think I like an 'internal monologue' of any kind during a fight, especially a melee.
Fighting should be all instinct, trained or otherwise. Even worse is making it some kind of 'smart' comment like the one you posted. If you have time to come up with a little quip then what is even at stake here? How little are you threatened? Should a fight of any kind not at least provoke a little threat or danger?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25211648
>book heavily featuring elves?
The Great Ordeal (if the Nonmen count as ones):
" “I will tell you what Immiriccas could not know,” the ancient Siqu said, staring into the depths of the Observance. “There comes a point where all the old ways of making sense just slough away. You persist in your daily ablutions, your ritual discourse and habitual labour, but an irritation claims you, the suspicion that others conspire to mock and confuse. This is all that you feel …”
Massacres lined their passage, the toil of making dead.
“The Dolour itself is invisible … all you ever see are cracks of fear and incomprehension where before all was seamless … thoughtless … certain. Soon you dwell in perpetual outrage, but are too fearful to voice it, because even though you know everything is the same, you no longer trust those you have loved to agree, so spiteful they have become! Their concern becomes condescension. Their wariness becomes conspiracy.
“And so the Weal becomes the Dolour, so the Intact become the Erratic. Think on it, mortal King, the way melancholy is prone to make you cruel, impatient of weaknesses. Your soul slowly disassembles, fragments into disconnected traumas, losses, pains. A cowardly word. A lover’s betrayal. An infant’s last, laboured breath. And for the heroes among us, the heartbreak commensurate with their breathtaking glory …”
Oinaral lowered his head as if at last conceding to some relentless weight.
“This is how you know that you stand before the *least* of my Race,” he voice raw. “The fact that I stand lucid and Intact before you.”
Their boots sent echoes muttering into the excavations buried about them.
“And that is why Nil’giccas is dead and gone …” Oinaral said on cracking passion. “He warred valiantly—I know this because for long centuries I was his Book. It was he who contrived the Bark and the Concavity, who made the Seal-of-the-Mountain a floating jewel. None toiled against the Dolour so mightily—or piteously—as he. The more he came apart, the more he demanded that his surroundings bind him together. But nothing could remedy his dissolution …
“*Depravity*, Son of Harweel. Only depravity retrieves the Wayward soul. No one knows why, but only horrors can render it whole, the commission of atrocities. You recover yourself for a slender interval, and you despair, crack for shame at the dishevelled beast you have become, *and you rejoice*. You *live!* The hunger for life burns far stronger in us than in Men, Son of Harweel. The suicides among us are miraculous, rare names in the Great Pit of Years …
“And so Nil’giccas—the most Illumined of our ancient Heros—took to *depravity* …” "
>>
>>25211830
>>25211703
He IS putting on a show though
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1776290965466.jpg (321 KB)
321 KB JPG
It's not like I read you or anything... B- BAKKER!
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: Marrow.png (293.7 KB)
293.7 KB PNG
>>25211329
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25211896
>>25211904
>2004
So zoomer Asuka, gotcha.
>>
>>
>>25211909
>>25211907
Not at all.
>>
>>
>>
>There had been no sexual play between the boy and me, as I believe there had been at some time between Dorcas and Jolenta.
Where the FUCK did that come from? There is zero hinting at any lesbianism between the two in Claw from what I can remember.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1357419771_thumb.jpg (136.1 KB)
136.1 KB JPG
>Let’s not change the subject just yet. Ver Cannedan is a brittle soul of the type only small men who become bullies ever achieve.
niggas will be 5' 11" and write shit like this
>>
what's with all the lanklet propaganda in scifi these days?
>The man was at one of the new Carryx-designed machines that seemed as much animal as lab equipment. He was half a head shorter than Tonner with close-cropped gray hair and a mustache that had been groomed to within an inch of its life. His arms were crossed, and his chest puffed up like a bantam’s.
>the little man said
>the little man repeated
>The little choreographer
>He has a hell of a punch for such a little guy
>The arrogant little dancer
>then little choreographer
>Ver Cannedan is a brittle soul of the type only small men who become bullies ever achieve.
>But because Ver threw his little tantrum
LOOOOOL LOOK AT THE FAT GEEK WHO WROTE THIS SLOP BTW!!! niggas will look like this and write heightist screeds
>>
>>
>>
>>25207595
My issue with Dresden is I fucking hate Karrin Murphy and how obvious it is that she makes Butcher's PP hard. Granted I've only read the first three but she single handedly ruined book 2 and wasn't much better in 3 either iirc.
>>
>>25207595
My issue with Dresden is I fucking hate Karrin Murphy and how obvious it is that she makes Butcher's PP hard. Granted I've only read the first three but she single handedly ruined book 2 and wasn't much better in 3 either iirc.
>>
>>25207595
My issue with Dresden is I fucking hate Karrin Murphy and how obvious it is that she makes Butcher's PP hard. Granted I've only read the first three but she single handedly ruined book 2 and wasn't much better in 3 either iirc.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25207595
My issue with Dresden is I fucking hate Karrin Murphy and how obvious it is that she makes Butcher's PP hard. Granted I've only read the first three but she single handedly ruined book 2 and wasn't much better in 3 either iirc.
>>
File: Lost Fleet.jpg (119.3 KB)
119.3 KB JPG
>>25211329
The Lost Fleet stays pretty small-scale due to its setting. I haven't finished the series, but based on the way the first 3-4 books go I highly doubt the scope changes.
>>
File: file.png (2.1 MB)
2.1 MB PNG
>Green & Deadly Things
>Book about a knight and a 1000 year old necromancer hag he accidentally releases
>reviews say its mid and has homoshit
Latter part of the premise was cool. Shame, I do like my necromancer girls and age gaps. Anything actually good I can read as a substitute?
>>
>>25212085
>>25212096
>>25212104
>>25212159
This is why phoneposting is bad, dumbass kuroba kept saying it failed to post sorry about that
>>
>>
>>25211996
It's supposed to tell you that Severian is extremely autistic and doesn't understand human relations. Remember when he did not rape Jolenta and came back thinking Dorcas was jealous because she was I love with Jolenta even though it was obvious Dorcas was in love with him? His autism is mainly the reason why every woman eventually abandons him throughout the story.
>>
>>25212184
The impression I've gotten of Severian is that he has been raised to think like a Torturer, but he still has the heart of a boy, and that's why he acts autistic or doesn't know how to catalogue his feelings at times. NTA btw I just started reading Shadow of the Torturer, right after his first visit to House Azure. Loving the talk with the fake Chatelaine and the bit about the exotic bindings of the library books earlier. Just wonderful dialogues.
>>
>>
File: 815TNLWG4aL._AC_UF894,1000_QL80_.jpg (115.5 KB)
115.5 KB JPG
>331 pages of meandering dogshit interspersed with hardcore gay sex and erections being rubbed on guys
this has retroactively made the first book shit now that i know these hacks are going nowhere with the concept
>>
>>25212184
I absolutely agree he's autistic as fuck but I don't remember it quite as you say, from my memory he notes Dorcas' expression when he comes back with Jolenta and its interpreted as her being upset because of she has feelings for Sevarian. But idk maybe I did miss something more being implied in the scant few chapters he spends with the Troupe in Claw.
>>
>>25212226
Its kind of a shame to hear this since I loved The Expanse novels so much. I wasn't hooked when I tried to read the first one of this series when it came out so I figured I'd wait for them all to be out.
>>
>>25212053
>what's with all the lanklet propaganda in scifi these days?
>The man was at one of the new Carryx-designed machines that seemed as much animal as lab equipment. He was half a head shorter than Tonner with close-cropped gray hair and a mustache that had been groomed to within an inch of its life. His arms were crossed, and his chest puffed up like a bantam’s.
>the little man said
>the little man repeated
>The little choreographer
>He has a hell of a punch for such a little guy
>The arrogant little dancer
>then little choreographer
>Ver Cannedan is a brittle soul of the type only small men who become bullies ever achieve.
>But because Ver threw his little tantrum
>LOOOOOL LOOK AT THE FAT GEEK WHO WROTE THIS SLOP BTW!!! niggas will look like this and write heightist screeds
The little man posted
>>
>>
>>25212255
if you didn't like the first one then this one is the same but even worse. all the hooks get resolved in this one in the most unsatisfying ways possible
>>25212269
>5' 11" guys when 5' 8" guys exist
the rest of the book is even worse so i forgot all the heightist shit
>>
File: 1751085462028899.jpg (31.5 KB)
31.5 KB JPG
>heightist
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25212285
oh, then you're the target audience for this shit. there's tons of gay crap with short men either being portrayed as catamites or nasty insecure midgets. where are the strong short male characters that act as role models for short young men and short boys?
>>
>>25212289
I don't read scifi, it's for faggots.
>>
>>25212243
Yeah I don t remember it like that either. It seemed pretty clear that Dorcas was upset that Severain went off to fuck Jolenta, and didn't feel like Severain though any differently. I don't think Severain is that odd, other than being a torturor. Much of what makes it seem odd is that the story is an autobiography Severain wrote many years after the fact. He says he has perfect recall of his life, but either forgets some parts, or at first doesn't feel comfortable with certain parts of himself, or just with sharing certain things. The prime example is how he makes it seem like his relationship with Thecla was purely platonic at first, but later as he goes back to talk about it, he admits that he was smashing that poon every night. He's an old man telling you his life story, not everything Severain did or says is going to be retold.
>>
File: 20260328_094216.jpg (413.8 KB)
413.8 KB JPG
>>25212292
Then he rapes her. She likes it though.
>>
>>
File: 91K8TYMlpfL[1].jpg (859.6 KB)
859.6 KB JPG
>>25212289
>where are the strong short male characters that act as role models for short young men and short boys?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1762320115600038.jpg (259.9 KB)
259.9 KB JPG
>Get $50 B&N gift card from sister for my birthday yesterday
>Buy all the main Revelation Space books plus some others
>Every single Revelation Space entry is like 600-700 pages
Uh-oh, lol.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 15a4601b9cd0b97a.jpg (30.7 KB)
30.7 KB JPG
>>25212572
It's the thought that counts, fren. You are rich in spirit.
>>
>>
File: 1776327296611.png (978 KB)
978 KB PNG
I like these novellas as palate cleanser for other heavy stuff I read. But there is something very characteristic with these fast paces books. I struggle a bit on the first 30 pages or so because it just dumps the character into some situation without an introduction and the story continues until resolution from there, but I enjoy the later parts of the book immensely.
Anyway, welcome to my blog
>>
File: 537707.jpg (47.2 KB)
47.2 KB JPG
Good, but not as good as Non-Stop, which doesn't start to fall apart after the reveal.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25212899
Try reading him, maybe. He's sophisticated. Like, his stories are mostly written in the first person and feature protagonists who get to have sex with all the pretty ladies. This is high art we're talking here.
>>
File: IMG_0715.jpg (32.6 KB)
32.6 KB JPG
Well, that was underwhelming…
>>
>>
>>25212975
You didn't Consider Phlebas, did you? You ignored Phlebas.
IV. Death by Water
Phlebas the Phoenician, a fortnight dead,
Forgot the cry of gulls, and the deep sea swell
And the profit and loss.
A current under sea
Picked his bones in whispers. As he rose and fell
He passed the stages of his age and youth
Entering the whirlpool.
Gentile or Jew
O you who turn the wheel and look to windward,
Consider Phlebas, who was once handsome and tall as you
>>
>>
>>25212981
The unconventional storytelling and constant digressions, anticlimaxes and antiheroes, the story beats that peter out and inverted tropes, all of it is to make a point about TS Eliot’s Wasteland… it’s supposed to be underwhelming because we are all like Phlebas.
>>
>>
>>
File: Bildschirmfoto 2026-04-16 um 15.21.07.png (107.7 KB)
107.7 KB PNG
does sffg have a gender ratio as perfectly balanced as r/fantasy? doubt it!
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25212551
>>25212547
Stay away from long novels. Life is too short.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 4893898948983.png (154 KB)
154 KB PNG
>>25212551
>Bit long, innit?
Yes.
I read them all a little while ago. And I'm glad I did. Great worldbuilding, well thought-out. Very immersive. The author was publishing short stories in his RS universe way back in fucking 1990 (and he must have been thinking about it since way before). And the novels surprisingly don't have a lot of info-dumping about the universe IIRC. It has a lot of descriptions of scenes and technology. Things in the immediate. And it meanders frankly. But the "big picture" and the history, you piece it back together slowly. The details don't even matter that much but you can't help but try to make sense of it. It's an interesting take on humanity spreading out to neighboring star systems, with travel and communication that take decades. The "splintering" of humanity that occurs. It also has a way of making all of those incredible developments also appear so banal in the grand scheme of things.
The books are too long. They have a lot of long descriptions that are great I think. But also chapters that could have been cut in half or dropped. Whole pages could be removed with no impact. It's a problem. Still, the prose is nice overall I think. Flows very well. Not distracting. You can git gud at reading faster with those books.
I saw pic related quote from the author a while ago. Thought it was very interesting. It's true, his novels are very visual. The scenes he describes, it's kind of psychedelic sometimes. Surreal. I wouldn't even know how to describe it desu. The novels could be described as horror-ish, gothic cyber-punk hard(ish)-science (debatable) cynical space opera. But it's not just that, some scenes are like some music video in space of some electronic music band inspired by old pulp sci-fi but with a fresh coat of astrophysics. And if you can't get into that the novels are probably going to be too long and boring I guess.
So I wouldn't recommend those novels to everyone. Not sure who to recommend them to desu.
The dialog is very often shockingly bad. A lot of people are not gonna like that. The characters communicate poorly AND the dialog is too long. Very irritating. Stilted dialogs that maybe had a bit of an Elizabethan feel to them sometimes. Not sure what he was going for there. Maybe it adds to the sense of isolation/alienation. Problem is that it's pretty much all dialog that has more than a few lines. Many of the characters feel more like accessories to the setting than real characters. Like puppets or ghosts. I wouldn't want to go into too much details, but it's just another thing that a lot of people won't like... I think you could say something similar for the plot in general. It just tragically moves along it feels like.
Look I'm just gonna say it I think those novels are probably mostly for autists. And just a particular type of autism most likely. That or use certain drugs, I wouldn't know. Anyway thanks for reading my review. In summary, maybe/maybe not read Revelation Space. Tragically too many pages.
>>
>>
File: dina2i-0d8625fd-493d-49eb-b039-188f4b1e0ae5.jpg (587.6 KB)
587.6 KB JPG
>>25213552
>no revelations in any kind of space
Huhh depends what you mean by "revelations" I guess.
I was a bit annoyed by it, how the name of the whole series is so tied to that one event in the first novel.
>the Shroud appears briefly and is later forgotten
It's a trigger for the whole thing though. There's "revelation" in the basic sense of figuring out or revealing the secrets behind certain things, and "revelation" as a sort of religious experience that can transform people. Lacaille had "revelations" alright.Turns he was manipulated to act as lure for another lure. Everyone who entered the Shroud was manipulated in some way. The digital entities that got out are nearly impossible to get rid of in a less-advanced computerized society apparently and they continue to haunt them for centuries. Lacaille was the Shrouders' plaything, but the Shrouders are not unique in that way. The whole Milky Way must be infested with the remnants of ancient civilizations like that. That no longer operate on scales of time that are in any way relatable. Any new spacefaring civilization is bound to encounter all sorts of "revelation" as to the state of their galaxy, the fate of life within it, and summon all sorts of horrors upon themselves.
IS IT a good title though? I dunno. It's not like most stories don't have "revelations" in such a general sense.
Alsothe Shroud has some impact in The Prefectbut that's spoiling it a little bit.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>25207827
Im reading it right now, got to part 3. Im liking far more than the first book, which i though was pretty generic and unoriginal. So far the only annoying part is the constant cliffhangers and switch of worlds.
>>
>>
>>25213990
I did not read the books, as for the show itself I found the humor to be awful 90% of the time and most of the cast are annoying reddit tier caricatures. Didn't make it further than 3 episodes in because I detested it so much.
>>
>>
>>
>>
There’s such a low barrier for entry to be deemed a fan of fantasy. Any unwashed retard who hasn’t read any other book by The Hobbit is deemed a fan of fantasy, for instance, but seems to also be seen as exemplary of fans of the genre. You should read way more than Tolkien or Rowling or Hobb or Redwall to be considered a fan. We know you can’t just say you’re a fan of sci fi just because you read one Star Wars novelisation. But we, for some reason or another, do not consider an illiterate Tolkiendrone as what they are: someone who doesn’t read. If you’re going to get into fantasy, you should draw from sword and sorcery, weird fiction, adventure romances, the Romantic period, and more.
>>
>>
>>