Thread #23735386 | Image & Video Expansion | Click to Play
File: s-l1200.jpg (278.5 KB)
278.5 KB JPG
Did they try to pull a Reccoa Londe with Puru's powers?
Z had 50 episodes to make her somewhat compelling but still undeniable stupid, CCA had only 2 hours and she comes across as an insufferable schizophrenic retard
35 RepliesView Thread
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
Runaway Newtype abilities without a strong sense of humanity and authority to ground her. She latched on to Amuro, then Char, and dragged Hathaway into her wake, at everyone's expense. She was also written to be hated, hence her last name: Paraya, a homonym for "pariah".
>>
>>
>>
>>23735386
>Did they try to pull a Reccoa Londe with Puru's powers?
No, she's a Kamille Bidan lacking any guidance. She shows that, despite being leader of Neo Zeon, Char's ability to actually guide others has diminished.
>>
>>
>>23736219
>Char's ability to actually guide others has diminished
No?
He literally rallied all neo zeon behind his cause, manipulated the earth officials, secured the director of the newtype labs and groomed quess to fight for him
CCA shows him as a strong (but insincere) leader and a master manipulator
>>
>>
>>23736226
>>23736228
Manipulating =/= guiding
Kamille was able to grow out of being a brat, Quess didn’t have a chance, Char couldn’t understand her and ended up just using her without trying to temper her strong feelings
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>23736302
She's written to be an annoying impulsive brat, so I understand why she is received the way she is. I don't think the problem is that audiences didn't get Quess so much as it is that not everyone is going to find a 14 year old girl acting on impulse and getting caught up in a conflict she genuinely cannot understand sympathetic or interesting. But ultimately that's irrelevant when the point is that Char is taking advantage of her naivety and infatuation with him because he's a lunatic trying to blow up Earth with a giant asteroid.
>>
>>23736410
holy shit gundamfags are so retarded. did you even watch the film? she is a child, she doesn't grasp the concept of war or nuclear winter. She is clearly disturbed by the deaths around her and feels pain after her father's death. No adult in the film treats her well with care, she is pitiful.
>>
>>
>>23736100
>She was also written to be hated
>>23736423
>She's written to be an annoying impulsive brat
No, that's just lazy audience washing their hands off from introspecting. It's pretty indicating that the film ends with discussion about Quess searching for father figure, being used and Char finding her annoying.
>>
>>
>>23736435
>non sequitur
You said
>mixed up kid meeting her hero and fangirling out
>she is a child, she doesn't grasp the concept of war or nuclear winter
as it that excuses her wanton murders
It doesnt
She gets no sympathy because she doesn't deserve it. Being groomed by char doesn't absolve her from all her wrongdoings
>>
File: quesss.jpg (653 KB)
653 KB JPG
It is so weird that Hathaway is obsessed with Quess and acts like Char, but Char was responsible for what happened to Quess, and Quess cared for Char but took Hathaway for granted.
>>
>>23736430
Did I say her being written that way was a bad thing you jackass? I actually liked Quess, although I feel like the movie could have spent a little more time exploring her issues than it did, and the way Char treats her is one of the biggest tragedies of the movie.
>>
>>
>>23736465
She liked Char, he's obsessed with her, so he uses Char as a inspiration. It makes sense.
Yeah. you could have Hathaway reacting badly to Char using her and attempting to kill everyone on Earth, but... barely any character seems to hold what the Zeon factions do against them. This is a problem even in Tomino's UC, although it becomes even bigger later on. The fight against Zeon never feels very personal even though considering the scale of the conflict and number of deaths it very well should be. It's hard to believe all these people haven't been touched directly by it at all.
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: SmartSelect_20250522_225704_X.jpg (1015.2 KB)
1015.2 KB JPG
>>23736465
>>23736471
Some people are like that.
>>
>>23735386
Daddy (+stepmom) issues and she latches onto older men because of that. You see that in real life as well. CCA just didn't have enough time to tell enough about her backstory, but it's kinda implied she's rebelling against her daddy.
>>
>>