File: 1356719.png (233.2 KB)

233.2 KB PNG

First for lewd Shimmy

File: 1769007870222955.png (346.4 KB)

346.4 KB PNG

>>42972328
Aw man, I was really gunning for this one. Let's hope the jannies don't strike the header down for being too saucy.

Next time add the download link for the collab gallery
https://mypastisnot-today.sfo3.cdn.digitaloceanspaces.com/zip/mypastisnot.today.zip

>>42972328
I feel like this is gonna get removed lol

File: image_2026-01-21_180206030.png (1.7 MB)

1.7 MB PNG

>>42972328
Sunset is gonna get deported back to Equestria because she didn't bring her papers with her when crossing the mirror

>>42972454
I will get in my fucking car and block these mfs, I'll die before they take our Shimmy away

>>42972454
That.. actually brings up several questions about how she was even able to get a job or enroll in highschool? The second raises even more questions because she's in her let teens when she flees through the mirror the first time.

File: 2568744.png (950.4 KB)

950.4 KB PNG

>>42972813
Remember, this is the same girl who made ''''''''flawless'''''''' fake photos of Twilight trashing the Fall Formal.
Sunset probably falsified/forged her ID and paperwork

File: 3716418.jpg (147.9 KB)

147.9 KB JPG

>>42972813
>>42972868
Or, being more realistic, she abused Flash Sentry to help her fill out the necessary paperwork to become documented and used the excuse that she ran away from home and wanted to become emancipated to do it.

>>42972454
Based Ace Thruster deporting Shimmigrants

File: 1752116640529639.gif (308.1 KB)

308.1 KB GIF

>>42972873
>tfw you realise that Sunset was like at least 24yrs old during EqG
>tfw she technically committed statutory rape against Flash
No wonder Aria saw him as easy prey.

File: 1642715.gif (346.3 KB)

346.3 KB GIF

>everyone's favorite pony did BIG ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES

>>42972901
>statutory rape
only bad if it's older male younger female
if it's younger male older female it's 'nice'

File: 1478787.gif (665.4 KB)

665.4 KB GIF

>>42972901
I headcanon that people age slower in the eqg verse, so 16 year old are like 20. It'd explain the discrepancy between ponies and humans in the two worlds. Also sex with older woman as a young man is based,and not rape.

File: 2954920.png (509.8 KB)

509.8 KB PNG

>>42972901
Timber Spruce and Sci-Twi having sex is statutory rape.
Flash Sentry and Sunset having sex is nice.

>>42972998
Wasn't Timber retconned to be younger than her?

File: 20.01.2026b 3b.png (3.1 MB)

3.1 MB PNG

new

>>42973304
Looks really good. Can't wait for more from you.

File: 1607587__suggestive_artist-colon-ponut_joe_sunset+shimmer_human_equestria+girls_g4_breasts_clothes_female_high+res_high-dash-cut+clothing_human+coloration_jacke.png (1.7 MB)

1.7 MB PNG

So fly!

>>42973008
After Rudell got several messages asking him if he was serious when he first stated Timber is 18, yes. But my headcanon rejects this.

>>42973304
Aww yeah, that's the spice. I forget how red and green go well together.

>>42973720
Is it still called a leotard if one removes the entirety of the sides?

>>42973783
I say yes.

File: 3750819.png (1.3 MB)

1.3 MB PNG

New Shim.
https://derpibooru.org/images/3750819

>>42974294
hot off the fucking press

File: 2116627__safe_artist-colon-anonix123_sunset+shimmer_equestria+girls_equestria+girls+series_sunset's+backstage+pass!_spoiler-colon-eqg+series+(sea.jpg (602 KB)

602 KB JPG

>>42974294
I love the style, she looks like a thiccie, too, Shimmy really filled in that festival outfit.

File: file.png (209.9 KB)

209.9 KB PNG

After fucking 9 million years im finally finishing this
Holy shit, I drafted like a 5 part epilogue and I just finished part one, hopefully it doesn't backfire, I had to write 15 pages worth of plot haha

At least it forced me to draw a ton of things I wouldhave never done before

>>42975195
That art looks fantastic.

>>42974907
>eg Rarity teaches her about fashion across the ages

>>42973304
I would've preferred Sunset in Kim's clothes even if her character fits better with Shego

I just think the more desaturated green cargo shorts and the black top looks better with Sunset's hair than Shego's outfit

Pretty cool pose though, I do like the drawing itself quite a lot

>>42976168
IIRC, he was also going to do a version with Adagio as Shego and Sunset as Kim.

Do you think Sunset ever drunkenly/sleepily wrote something in the journal and then read it back the next day and immediately wanted to immolate herself?

>>42976232
Twily would probably be super interested in Shimmy's drunken ramblings about humans.

File: 3694885.gif (3.8 MB)

3.8 MB GIF

>>42976272
>Princess Twilight when Sunset once again drunkenly talks about how much longer human men last in bed.

File: 3751253.png (1.2 MB)

1.2 MB PNG

Perfect from every angle

>>42976295
This gif is hilarious

>>42976272
>Sunset:Hey.. hey Twilite.. I dids the maff
>Twilight:Uhh.. Sunset?
>Sunset:I'm.. I'm a bad pony.. like as bad as like ten Hitler's
>Twilight: I don't know who that is. But you aren't a bad pony.
>Sunset: Yesh I amm
>Twilight: Sunset.. have you been drinking?
>Sunset: A lil
>Twilight: *sigh* Sunset, first off you're underage. Secondly-
>Sunset: No I'm not! I'm older than u!
>Twilight: Not in the human world you aren't!
>Sunset:...
>Twilight: Sunset? Did you fall asleep?... Actually, if so good. You should-
>Sunset:...Imma bad pony?...
>Twilight:Oh Celestia damn it... I'll be there in twenty minutes.

>>42976938
Holy kek

>>42976528
Kinda forget how rocking her body looks just in the show sometimes.

File: Shimmering.png (1.9 MB)

1.9 MB PNG

>>42972328
Why is Sunset Shimmer so sexy?

>>42977795
It's a combination of her physically attractive design and her fun and passionate personality, at least for me.

>>42977795
She's Twilight with a spine and an attitude.

>>42976295
Twilight remembers the power of hands

>>42979411
How can one pony be so cute?

Any good mind control smut with shimmer

File: 3206855__explicit_artist-colon-tjpones_sci-dash-twi_sunset+shimmer_twilight+sparkle_alicorn_human_equestria+girls_g4_absurd+resolution_belly+button_big+breasts_.png (2.9 MB)

2.9 MB PNG

>>42979423
By changing into a human and back into pony to learn how to get the best of both worlds

>>42980217
Dam Shimmy, how you get all of that, in them jeans, them jeans, How'd you get all of that in them?

File: 3715578.png (17.2 KB)

17.2 KB PNG

>>42980120
TJ understands me on a spiritual level.

>>42978707
Big flank

>>42973304
>>42976168
hear me out, human Chrysalis as Shego, Sunset as Kim

File: Rednote id 5016679608.jpg (1.2 MB)

1.2 MB JPG

winter shimmy

File: 3571763.jpg (142.8 KB)

142.8 KB JPG

>>42980918
WOW!! Shimmer

>>42981263
Rude

File: 3735330.png (206.9 KB)

206.9 KB PNG

>>42981263
what compels her behavior

>>42981697
Stubborn pride. I know because I'm the same way.

>>42980647
Does this board just go from loving to hating TJ on a whim?

File: 3667223.jpg (1.5 MB)

1.5 MB JPG

>>42982072
>/mlp/ is one person
The only two reasons to dislike TJPones is because he's literally (You) but he's not fake and gay about jerkin' it to horse pussy, pubes, and futa, or you just don't like his humor and/or artwork.

>>42981263
>>42981697
Teenage rebellion that's lasted into her adult years

File: file.png (331.1 KB)

331.1 KB PNG

Interesting contrast...

>>42984068
Link to the full-sized pic?

File: 3581227.gif (578.1 KB)

578.1 KB GIF

>>42984352
Don't open while at work.

>>42984375
Glad I wasn't at work when I opened this.

>>42984375
BRO DELETE THIS MY BOSS WAS LOOKING OVER MY SHOULDER WHEN I OPENED THIS

>>42984391
Just say your boss sexually harassed you in the elevator. No one will be able to prove otherwise and you'll be able to keep your job.

>>42972328

>>42978707
When he does crotchboobs I'm dying a happy man.

>>42984375
I opened it while at work. I don't care. Let everyone know

File: 3441709.gif (1.3 MB)

1.3 MB GIF

>tfw you spill your guts out about how much you love her and she gives you the ol' "yeah, so?"

>>42985091
>In other news... Why were you eating hay from the pet store behind the school yesterday? I wanted to bring it up earlier but we were in class

>>42985160
Based, you can't let Shimmy get away with bitching you out, you gotta talk about horsecocks and if she ever gets homedick, Shimmy must know she is a barnyard animal.

File: ahhhhhhhhhh.gif (1.8 MB)

1.8 MB GIF

>>42984075
in 3 weeks when I finish the other 11 pages

>>42983967
boop!

>>42985091
You're supposed to spill her guts out, faggot.

File: yum.png (204.9 KB)

204.9 KB PNG

>>42985160

File: my-image (1).png (668.7 KB)

668.7 KB PNG

your turn, green man
>https://tiermaker.com/create/f-sunset-shimmer-outfits-1604611
In my case I didn't include Pony Sunset because I don't consider it “an outfit” and I changed the picture of her sushi outfit because the one in the template is gray for some reason

File: 3753376__safe_artist-colon-nekojackun_sunset+shimmer_human_equestria+girls_g4_breasts_bust_busty+sunset+shimmer_clothes_jacket_jewelry_leopard+print_looking+at+.png (1.1 MB)

1.1 MB PNG

New nekojackun

>>42985270
Well, hop to it, man! I want to see the finished piece.

>>42985944
It's rare that he draws Sunset, but when he does it's always great.

File: my-image.png (735.2 KB)

735.2 KB PNG

>>42985919
Here's mine.

File: large.png (921.9 KB)

921.9 KB PNG

>>42985884
EQG Stream this sunday!!
We'll be watching Rainbow Rocks and playing SRB2 Kart + Cards Against EQG!
>Countdown
https://www.tickcounter.com/countdown/9282833/eqg-stream
Hoping to see (You) there!

File: file.png (158 KB)

158 KB PNG

>>42986080
Wish I was faster, I have a lot of shims in the oven, but I gotta keep my sleep schedule in check, I can only afford like 2 hours a day right now

>>42986658
>I can only afford like 2 hours a day right now
Damn, I wish I could afford to pay all artists a living wage to draw cute Shimmies all day.

File: file.png (1021.2 KB)

1021.2 KB PNG

>>42985919
Other than Beautiful, they are in no particular order within the tiers.

>>42986226
Excellent, looking forward to it

>>42987381
this is really cute

>>42987099
>Sushi Shim and Vampire Shim at the bottom
Monstrously terrible taste

>>42988193
Hnng festival outfit is so fucking fashionable

Does anyone have the screen cap of the book where Sunset breaks Sci-Twi's shirt with her bust? I can't seem to find it.

File: 1750892.png (167.6 KB)

167.6 KB PNG

>>42988301

File: 3215680__safe_artist-colon-sozglitch_sunset+shimmer_human_g4_big+breasts_breasts_busty+sunset+shimmer_clothes_daisy+dukes_dialogue_female_heart_huge+breasts_hum.jpg (255.3 KB)

255.3 KB JPG

>>42988308
The best bit of lore ever dropped about Sunset

>>42988313
Of course Shimmy has massive titties, can't take over a school with nothing.

>>42989136
uwoh

File: 1743851434123065.jpg (588.2 KB)

588.2 KB JPG

>>42988344
POWER

File: Sunset Outfit Tier List.png (517.1 KB)

517.1 KB PNG

Made this a few years ago, still agree with most of it.

File: 1660311__safe_artist-colon-rustyartist_sunset+shimmer_equestria+girls_spoiler-colon-eqg+series_abstract+background_blushing_crossed+legs_cute_female_ge.jpg (1.6 MB)

1.6 MB JPG

>>42990059
Man, people can get upset about Shimmy's last moments being dressed as a fucking carrot, but I am so happy her final outfit was the spiky skirty style you would expect from Shimmy, FG was absolutely beautiful but we were first introduced to Shimmy skirty shirty mark and it's what we fell in love with.

>>42990225
Someone on the art team was a genuinely inspired individual. Sunset having the punk exterior (studded jackets and jewelry, black accessories) while the inner clothes are light, loose, and even girly fully captures her entire character. She’s trying to bring out the good in herself, but that meanness of hers is too defining of a character trait to lose. It’s like how >>42990555 does so much to capture Starlight’s character. The skater outfit nets Starlight as a rebel playing by her own rules, which means trying to reform isn’t something that’s forced upon her; she’s using her own agency to become a better pony, even though she could just walk away at any time.

>>42990680
I'll agree that the design team were absolutely cooking with gas when it came to Sunset's outfits.

File: 3360073__safe_artist-colon-nire_sunset+shimmer_human_equestria+girls_g4_bare+shoulders_black+lipstick_blushing_boob+freckles_boots_bracelet_breasts_busty+sunset.png (2 MB)

2 MB PNG

>>42990680
She's a genuinely good and kind person deep down, but no matter what that punk rock attitude is also a part of who she is too! So it's always going to show no matter how girly the base outfit is. (also yes, shey may also have *sliiiiight* anger issues too, but hey we're not all perfect)

File: 3739665.jpg (1.7 MB)

1.7 MB JPG

>>42991018
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8aBC3SdzFQ

>>42991828
she can be as mean as she wants to me

File: 3583077.jpg (935.9 KB)

935.9 KB JPG

>"We're more ponies than people."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECApKexE3fQ

>>42991978
>loses 40% of her stream revenue for siding with the Legion because she thinks she can “fix” Vulpes

>>42972328

Pregnant Sunset is the best kind of Sunset

File: 1888288.gif (3 MB)

3 MB GIF

>>42991828
I love mad Shimmy

File: 3750354.png (43.9 KB)

43.9 KB PNG

>>42992666
okay, satan

>>42993040
I really love this pic.

File: sunny_butt.jpg (3.7 MB)

3.7 MB JPG

You just looked at Shimmy's butt

You are now hard

>>42993917
Damnit! And the surgeon said not to have sex for two weeks! Why must Shimmy tempt me so?

File: 1054651.jpg (246.5 KB)

246.5 KB JPG

You just looked at Shimmy.

You are now hard.

File: 3436580.png (2 MB)

2 MB PNG

>>42991828

File: sunset jiggle.gif (239.4 KB)

239.4 KB GIF

>>42993917
Understandable

>>42972328

File: 2277780__safe_sunset+shimmer_solo_female_clothes_breasts_equestria+girls_alternate+hairstyle_shimmerbetes_hair+bun_crossed+legs_cheongsam_schröd.png (581.6 KB)

581.6 KB PNG

It's soon to be the year of the horse in China! 馬年快樂!

>>42995484
>gamer gurl
>comic book artist
>illegal graffiti artist
>has a sci-twi photo covered in glitter
hmm...!!

>>42995665
You know shimmy flicking the bean to her Sci-Twi picture.

>>42995484
I like how she has two pics for Twi, one for Pony Twi in the group shot and Sci-Twi individually

File: 3743861__safe_artist-colon-ridumax_sci-dash-twi_sunset+shimmer_twilight+sparkle_human_pony_unicorn_equestria+girls_g4_animated_blushing_close-dash-up_duo_extrem.gif (777.3 KB)

777.3 KB GIF

>>42986226
this sunday!

File: 3751408.png (1.5 MB)

1.5 MB PNG

>>42984375

>>42996992
>Sunset gets accidentally reverted back into a pony for a few days
>Her friends can't help but scratch her ears and give her belly rubs
>All the while, Sunset is struggling not to cum buckets from the overstimulation and is too embarrassed to say anything.

>>42997809
Kek imagine Shimmy gushing that yellowy mare liquid out of her pussy when she gets excited, and she can't decide to explain to friends she just fucking came and this is how it looks when ponies do it, or just tell them she just fucking pissed.

File: Gag4AwYXgAAJndT.jpg (612.3 KB)

612.3 KB JPG

>>42987099
Imagine having this bad taste

File: 3754651.png (219.7 KB)

219.7 KB PNG

How did they perfectly balance how cool and cringe Sunset is? She's like the Vergil (from the Devil May Cry series) of MLP.

File: 2580293__safe_screencap_sunset+shimmer_equestria+girls_equestria+girls+specials_g4_my+little+pony+equestria+girls-colon-+better+together_my+little+pony+equestri.png (344.7 KB)

344.7 KB PNG

>>42998691
When you see someone at their lowest, when they're at their most pathetic, rejected and sad, that's when you cheer for them to rise to the top again

And once they do, you believe them when they act cool, because they are cool. Even when they're cringe

>>42998223
Couldn't be me.

File: 1751140738355397.png (1.2 MB)

1.2 MB PNG

I could use a warm drink.

>>42999740
>coffee too dark
>Shimmy lifts her shirt a little and gives it a squeeze

File: 2552029.jpg (295.3 KB)

295.3 KB JPG

>>42999909
Replace the coffee with tea, and that's the dream.

File: 2036364__safe_artist-colon-dino_horse_artist-colon-malphee_sunset+shimmer_equestria+girls_clothes_collaboration_human_jacket_leather+jacket_looking+at+.png (980.3 KB)

980.3 KB PNG

>>42999996
True, I would love some hot chocolate with some Shimmy milk in there.

>>43000020
Hell, just drinking her milk straight from the source would be fantastic.

>>43000186
Based from the teat enjoyer.

>>43000186
Finally, someone gets it.

File: 1270387.gif (206.5 KB)

206.5 KB GIF

>>43000186
>>43000214
>>43000290
Pinkie...

>>43000338
I'll bet Pinkie loves making treats from Shimmy's tit milk, probably has to regularly pump Shimmy's tits when they get engorged so her chest doesn't hurt.

File: 2474819.png (346.9 KB)

346.9 KB PNG

>>42999740
She looks like a character from a Kodaka game in this

File: 1650503470048.jpg (19.4 KB)

19.4 KB JPG

>>42997816
>It happens while Twilight and Celestia are there trying to figure out what happened.

File: Year of the Horse.jpg (928.6 KB)

928.6 KB JPG

New art from Sozglitch

>>43000821
He earned the right to call Sunset his wife years ago, yet he refuses to rest on his laurels… what a legend.

>>42972328

>>43000821
People are posting their year of the horse art already? Damn

File: lel.png (176.4 KB)

176.4 KB PNG

>>42986226
1.5 hours to go!
>Countdown
https://www.tickcounter.com/countdown/9282833/eqg-stream
>Cytube
https://cytu dot be/r/EQG-Stream

File: carl.png (105.3 KB)

105.3 KB PNG

>>43001451
Starting!
>Cytube
https://cytu dot be/r/EQG-Stream
https://cytu dot be/r/EQG-Stream
https://cytu dot be/r/EQG-Stream

>>43001892
God would it have been cool for not only Shimmy to get the Sci-twi as gf, but Twily get the pony Shimmy that was the original Shimmy as her gf

File: [Disgusted Horse-girl noises].jpg (70.6 KB)

70.6 KB JPG

Who keeps sliding threads?

File: 1643289__suggestive_alternate+version_artist-colon-lil+miss+jay_sunset+shimmer_equestria+girls_big+breasts_breasts_busty+sunset+shimmer_cleavage_clothe.png (342 KB)

342 KB PNG

>>43002614
>reverse rape

File: 3622966.jpg (706.2 KB)

706.2 KB JPG

>>43002894
>anon's unconscious body is discovered severely dehydrated and nude with numerous black lipstick smears covering his genitals, anus, nipples, and face

>>43003231
>anus
No thank you.

>>43003237
>no thank you
that's why it's rape anon

>>43003400
Why would she kiss my asshole when my lips are there and asking for it?

>>43003403
Because it makes you squirm cutely

File: Motherly Sunset.png (759.8 KB)

759.8 KB PNG

>>43003231
>nine months later

File: Ray.png (1.2 MB)

1.2 MB PNG

Ray

>>42972328

>>43003237
>>43003403
there's lots of girls in this family with different needs

>>43004134
This is why Anon feeds him the crunchiest crickets and the juiciest wax worms.

>>42972328

>>42972328

>>42992666
Damn, look at that bacon sizzle!

>>42992666
>Sunset was swiftly rushed to the ER after her little outburst
>As it turned out, the human body was not actually capable of being as comically expressive like an Equestrian, so when Sunset's face went that red it was because she accidentally forced dozens of blood vessels to burst under her skin and WASN'T a comical depiction of anger.

File: 3660759.jpg (347.9 KB)

347.9 KB JPG

>>43005777
>>43006134
She's so cute as a pony, and sexy as a human.

>>43006348
That's the cutest fucking Shimmy pose I've ever seen in my life

>>43006516
It's because she's such a cutie.

does anybody got that new preg shim tsudashie made yet?

>>43006741
This one?
https://files.catbox.moe/4jzs1v.png

File: 3065594.jpg (153.5 KB)

153.5 KB JPG

>claim to have a preg fetish
>not drawing it yourself so your fetish is literally someone else impregging your waifu
you don't have a preg fetish
you have a cuckold fetish

>>43006781
>t. cucktard going to great lengths to project his fetish onto everyone else

File: 2648253.png (463.4 KB)

463.4 KB PNG

>>43006799
I know what you are.

File: 1716094386489.png (3.1 MB)

3.1 MB PNG

>>43006813
I'm the guy who's going to breed Sunset and drain her tits of Shim milk daily, yes. You caught me.

File: suddenly shimmer.jpg (2.8 MB)

2.8 MB JPG

>>43007079
Still hilarious to this day
Sunset didn't deserve to be held back from getting more appearances; she's still one of the most popular ponies despite appearing in FiM for a microsecond

>>42972454
There is a native EQG Sunset.
She can literally just use her ID and no one would know. Probably not even the native Sunset Shimmer unless she got audited by the IRS for not reporting the additional income stream from Pony Sunset's job. Given that they both would make minimum wage i doubt anyone would give a shit since they'd be below the income level that they'd owe anything.

>quality learing center
You'd be surprised how many government institutions don't check anything other than whether or not your credentials are valid. Canterlot high probably wouldn't give a shit that two girls with the same credentials go to two different schools because they probably didn't check for that in the first place, they very well may only care that you have credentials and the EQG Sunset's school might send academic records to Canterlot high simply because they asked them to without even caring that their student didn't actually transfer there afterwards. So pony sunset would even have a background to use as well.

If one of them filed for college financial assistance or loans then that would probably be the point where it would cause problems with credit history or aid limits. But we don't know if Sunset would have stayed in EQG land for that long or if she even go to college. Principal Celestia probably knows that Sunset is not a legit denizen by now, but she may be simply waiting for Sunset to graduate and then it's not her problem anymore, so she may not really care.

File: confalone eqg s2 finale.jpg (343.5 KB)

343.5 KB JPG

>>43007164
>She can literally just use her ID and no one would know.
People always headcanon things about human Sunset but the facts as they are in the series are that nobody knows anything about her. We have no reason to believe Sunset met her or did anything to her. Based on Confalone's proposal for the finale she was actually displaced at the same time that Sunset entered the human world on accident and stuck in Equestria.

>>43007170
That post doesn't really mean that EQG Sunset was sent to Equestria, although if that happened that would have been incredible to see and she would have probably been an instant hit with sunset fans.

It could just be that Pony Sunset took her place in the world and she just got shoved to the side in her own life so to speak as Pony Sunset commandeered it.

>>43007192
I guess it seems like a no-brainer to me because she surely would've tried to interfere at some point on her own if she were still in the human world. The Rainbooms were popular enough to have their music video air on TV and have proper gigs outside Canterlot during the shorts, so she would be seeing a sussy imposter of herself rising to fame ("WORLDWIDE, Y'ALL" as Spike famously said in that cringekino song)
Plus I could easily see more pony content after Backstage Pass and Holidays Unwrapped were purely human-centric stories. Imo Human Sunset probably had to settle into being a pony after having no way to get back and became a forgotten wage slave Manehattan or something.
>tfw isekai'd to a magical unicorn realm and still working 9 to 5 retail

>>43007223
The one problem with that kind of story is that they'd have to find a way for human Sunset, who would have been like 13 years old at the time, to make it completely alone in Equestria.
And even if she gets back to the human world, she won't just get her childhood back that is now just totally gone.
All the girls are like 16-17 now, they are juniors, maybe going on seniors in high school. Pony Sunset spent two whole years making everyone's lives hell before Twilight came around and straightened her out.

They'd have to just resort to
>Actually I'm just gonna stay in Equestria
Which still isn't ok because you just abducted a 13 year old girl, threw them onto an alien planet and made them a literal horse. That's just supposed to be OK somehow because now they have gone native and probably have PTSD for life from it, right.

It would just be outrageously cruel to human Sunset no matter what, too much time has passed to just fix things for her and the implications would practically condemn pony Sunset to be a monster no matter what for doing all of that to her.

It's easier to just say that human Sunset is just living an alternate life elsewhere and if pony Sunset had not come around then things may have been different for her, maybe she'd be at Canterlot high with everyone else right now instead of wherever she wound up.

>>43007273
>Which still isn't ok because you just abducted a 13 year old girl, threw them onto an alien planet and made them a literal horse. That's just supposed to be OK somehow because now they have gone native and probably have PTSD for life from it, right.
Honestly, despite you being right that it would be fucked up, it's on brand with the ideas presented with Sunset's character. There are some misdeeds you can't ever properly "fix" just like how she can't just take all the magic fucking up the human world back after she unleashed it with the crown.

File: sci_twi_meets_princess_twilight_sparkle_2_by_benjirivera1991_dfj0jqo-pre.jpg (108.9 KB)

108.9 KB JPG

>>43007279
The missing piece here is sci-twi
If not for the magic she would have just went on that solo study thing she was working on and no one would have ever heard from her again, definitely not the M6 crew, they likely would have never met her.

Her life had it's course altered by Pony Twilight and Sunset's presence, there's no reason to think the same didn't just happen to human Sunset.
After all, I'm pretty sure Sunset just took the mirror to get to the human world, Twilight didn't send her human counterpart anywhere when she did that.

>>43007307
The text stated it was a byproduct of Sunset casting a spell on the mirror. I assume it could've been something she dug up to open it shortly outside of the 30 moons timer

>>43007337
Pony Twilight also did that to no apparent I'll effect, so that would be a massive stretch.

Starswirl and a few others have also evidently done it before when the Dazzlings and other magical artifacts were exiled from Equestria in the past.

>>43007351
>Pony Twilight also did that to no apparent I'll effect, so that would be a massive stretch.
Twilight is smarter than Sunset and her machine only works thanks to the journal already being in the human world. She didn't have that convenience.
>Starswirl and a few others have also evidently done it before when the Dazzlings and other magical artifacts were exiled from Equestria in the past.
Yeah but those are legendary mages from centuries before her time. There's no telling if they ever made those spells available to learn; it at least seems like something on the same level as Starswirl's time travel spell which was locked up and kept under guard.

File: sd.jpg (593 KB)

593 KB JPG

https://vocaroo.com/1b4tzQDvgfUW

>>43007987
she bounced right into my heart

File: 753326(1).jpg (1 MB)

1 MB JPG

>>43007351
>>43007366
My headcanon remains that human Sunset is a runaway and the plot of her movie is finding the gem Starswirl the Bearded gave to Princess Celestia when she was a filly to help her control her unbelievable magical powers while she was still a magical novice. Once Celestia mastered her magic beyond her talent of raising the sun, she put it into storage, and it naturally became misplaced and forgotten in the Castle of the Two Sisters. The longer that pony Sunset stays in the human world, more and more portals are opening between the two worlds to try and "catch" pony Sunset to restore balance. However, the portals can't tell the difference between human and pony Sunset, and since the high school portal is so close to pony Sunset, portals have been opening haphazardly around human Sunset. A portal opens connecting the Castle with a cold, damp, dark alley where human Sunset is sleeping, landing next to her. It's full of pure fire magic, and human Sunset finally has the power she's been desperate to have since she was a child. As a child, human Sunset's parents fought so much, every achievement she had in grade school was overshadowed by their shouting. All she wanted was to make people pay attention to her, but she never could unless she was getting in trouble or breaking things. She's become a delinquent and a villain because negative attention is the only attention she is used to getting. With the gem full of Celestia's magic, she can make people pay attention to her, but she has a more important task first. She needs to snuff out the imposter who's been living the life she deserved, and no amount of empathy from pony Sunset will stop the burning anger that's boiling over within human Sunset.

>>43007170
>Original Shimmy comes back through the portal with a vengeance for being sent to the land of hay and horse shit
>fucking people as Shimmy to start shit with her people
>Shimmy has to reform herself again
What a cool thing that could've been

File: 1509221720536.webm (2.8 MB)

2.8 MB WEBM

The mention of Starswirl also reminds me that the motherfucker himself was actually brought back in FiM and they did next to nothing with him. I always thought Sunset confronting him would make for a good story, the conflict practically writes itself.
>Sunset is outraged that Starswirl and his students treated the human world as a dumping ground, which is the source of several conflicts in EqG (Sirens, memory stone, and probably the time twirler)
>Old boomer threw dangerous magical WMDs into the human world because he knew it was magicaless and they would be completely inert there. Blames the thoughtless whippersnapper for introducing magic and thus making all of those threats get revived and become dangerous again

File: file.png (140.3 KB)

140.3 KB PNG

My accurate representation of all the discussions around human Sunset here virtually spoiling what i've been working on for weeks, fuck

>>43009992
based

>>43007125
Why does Mayor Mare know Sunset though

>>43007164
Canterlot High is canonically a public school, which are known for their less strict rules and enforcing of them

>>43007307
Having Sci-Twi discover and reform pony Sunset would be kino though, it'd be closing the one remaining loose end with the perfect bookends and message at the end. How watching a pony redeem a pony can help a human redeem a human.

>>43009624
This desu ne
>>43009992
Take it as inspiration and rework it into your ideas

>>43009197
Big stretch

File: 2435363.png (169 KB)

169 KB PNG

>>43010708
big stretchy! big stretchy!