>>129186294
Anybody have any opinions on Camel?

>>129186294
Face it, anon. It's over. This general has completely run out of steam.

>>129186297
moonmadness good

>>129186297
Not bad honestly. I need to listen to more of their discography to formulate an actual opinion on them though, do you have any recs?

>>129186294
Bill Bruford it is then

UK
https://youtu.be/MAzm-nQTw9g?si=apAWkfS9DvQz7fu7

>>129186581
>UK
>Bruford
>National Health

SHUT UP!!! EARTHWORKS MOGS ALL OF THESE!!!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSZKmNFap8k

>>129186311
GIVE ME STEAM

File: yes.jpg (34.3 KB)

34.3 KB JPG

has any prog act managed to make music as transcendental as Yes?

>>129186294
Strange Bru

File: 1759767633169687.webm (2.1 MB)

2.1 MB WEBM

>>129188910
STAND BACK

>>129186311
sorry. i was banned for 3 days.

>>129189646
My fav Yes tale is when the producer told Jon to come back when he had some real lyrics.

hey ok real question, so what's the deal with the new Lamb lies down mix?
listened to it at work today, not the most audiophile context, but... didn't notice a single thing different. Which might be a good thing, i'm not sure.

>>129189646
Genesis have more such moments than Yes as far as i'm concerned

Phil Collins names his least favorite Genesis songs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Qpqn2y9XUM

>>129194841
i'd tell that producer to come back when he has any musical talent. producers are misnomers. they do not create.

>>129195468
Calm down Albini

>>129195407
>not liking a top 2 song on and then there were three
what's wrong with phil?

>>129195407
Can't believe he said For Absent Friends and More Fool Me...

What a snare sound BB had

>>129186294
UK is pants

80s Bruford reminds me of my twin uncles

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cLoQADJnGr4

Bit of a surface level pick but holy shit Bill's drumming on this song (and the whole album) is perfect

File: IMG_4936.jpg (748.4 KB)

748.4 KB JPG

Its never been more over than it is now

>>129197019
It will be more over tomorrow than it is today. And this will be the case every day until May 12 when it is as over as it ever can be.

>>129195021
not at all
I love Genesis, but apart from Supper's Ready, they have done nothing that comes near Close to the Edge, And You and I, Heart of the Sunrise, Awaken, Gates of Delirium, To Be Over, Revealing Science of God, Remembering, etc

what is your favorite band that sings in:
english
french
german
spanish
italian

>>129197019
Peter won again
>Don't give Up

>>129186294
a time of shadow by dead heroes club

>>129197019
>I CANT DANCE

>>129197019
ill collins

File: 1757134184015798.jpg (1.6 MB)

1.6 MB JPG

His time to shine

>>129199669
He deserved better

>>129198230
Magma

>>129198230
king crimson
nemo
doesn't exist
los jaivas
banco

File: 1768763253902862.jpg (151.2 KB)

151.2 KB JPG

>>129201778
>Joins a band with Mike and Tony
>Is surprised when Mike and Tony are assholes

>>129202894
He deserved a better album, not just better bandmates

>>129195012
>hey ok real question, so what's the deal with the new Lamb lies down mix?
>listened to it at work today, not the most audiophile context, but... didn't notice a single thing different. Which might be a good thing, i'm not sure.

no one?

>>129195012
>>129203206
From what I can hear, it has a clearer and drier sound with more bleed, closer to the original mix, and fixes some of the “bolder” (putting it politely) choices of the 2007 mix.

I really like the sound of the drum kit on Selling England

>>129203509
ok, interesting, thanks.

>>129186297
One of my favorites
Also I haven't been in these threads in awhile, did everyone know Andrew Latimer released some songs on bandcamp

File: NC04NDE5LmpwZWc[1].jpg (130.5 KB)

130.5 KB JPG

Based.

>>129201778
no he didn't. he used the brand of genesis (which he had no ownership of) to propel his own career. mike and tony deserved to use genesis as a cash grab. mike and tony could have taken fat shits into that faggot's mouth every day, and he still should have thanked them.

>>129204450
Go to bed Anthony

File: 1747747158405.jpg (122.2 KB)

122.2 KB JPG

This thread needs a hero

File: magma.png (476.2 KB)

476.2 KB PNG

>>129189646
Magma honestly.

>>129207043
What's the object on the bottom left?

File: s-l1200.jpg (377.4 KB)

377.4 KB JPG

>>129207372
Looks like one of the helments from Tristan et Iseult/Wurdah Itah but I might be wrong.

>>129204450
Hi Tony

File: 000421146.jpg (402.4 KB)

402.4 KB JPG

>>129186294
Benson Boone is the new Freddie Mercury
https://youtu.be/H5RpMywlZ2Q
https://youtu.be/U8QhB8_0t2g
https://youtu.be/Oa_RSwwpPaA

WE GOT THE SYSTEM TO FUCK THE SYSTEM
>WE GOT THE SYSTEM TO FUCK THE SYSTEM
WE GOT THE SYSTEM TO FUCK THE SYSTEM
>WE GOT THE SYSTEM TO FUCK THE SYSTEM

>>129207372
it's not important

>>129209544
666 mogs your favorite rock opera and All the Seats Were Occupied mogs your favorite prog epic.

>>129189646
gibberish pseud question, i guess /prog/ is officially back

>>129189646
>>129210754
What is the most euphoric prog?

>>129210932
gryphon

>>129210214
>666 mogs your favorite rock opera
yes, but
>>129210214
>and All the Seats Were Occupied mogs your favorite prog epic
nope. the basis of it is good, but the resamples and reprises that are most of the 2nd half really bog it down bad

File: cover_49538312017_r.jpg (98.9 KB)

98.9 KB JPG

>>129210932
pic unrelated. but seriously, any of the 90s symphonic prog revival would probably take the cake. (nu-)kaipa, the flower kings, spock's beard, glass hammer, transatlantic, karmakanic,

>>129211966
really? lol, i wish i could find that stuff/neo prog i heard euphoric, i try sometimes but, that damn mental block of 90s production... it's like a permanent suspension of disbelief, but for music

File: 74efcfaf-0523-4e44-a002-fd6ad597642d.jpg (436.2 KB)

436.2 KB JPG

>>129186294
Saw Uriah Heep today on their Magician’s Farwell tour. First prog (-ish) band I’ve seen live and it was an awesome show, even if Mick Box was ill and couldn’t make it

>>129211994
yeah. i guess euphoria wasn't the right word i was thinking of. for some reason i thought it meant basic cheer and happiness. i still contend roine stolt (in various bands) should be in the contention for most euphoric.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lWt1fK18EVk

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gx-0BmYg5Z8&t=2760s (skipped ahead a bit to provide a bit of a buildup right before the moneyshot)

>>129212084
i'm happy you finally made it to a show and enjoyed it.

>>129210932
any band that is compatible with hedonism and self-indulgence so probably mars volta

>>129204253
Based England enjoyer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gSQhjR9UaIA

>>129186297
>>129186533
Can't go wrong with their first four albums. I like Stationary Traveller and Rajaz beyond those, with the latter being a "return to roots decades later" album done well.
>>129204014
Appreciate the tip, I'll be sure to check that out.

>>129198230
King Crimson
Harmonium
Harmonia (or maybe popol vuh but that's a stretch)
Mars Volta
pass

File: Zašto Kafka?.png (236.7 KB)

236.7 KB PNG

Listening to >Zašto Kafka?<

Oui

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ws3EAdMpEVA

Famous prog albums turning 50 this year:
>Genesis - Trick of the Tail (February 13)
>Gong - Shamal (February 13)
>Rush - 2112 (March 22)
>Caravan - Blind Dog at St. Dunstans (April 23)
>Jethro Tull - Too Old to Rock n Roll (April 23)
>Camel - Moonmadness (April 23)
>Brand X - Unorthodox Behaviour (June 18)
>Alan Parsons Project - Tales of Mystery and Imagination (June 25)
>Jon Anderson - Olias of Sunhillow (July 9)
>Steve Hillage - L (September 24)
>Rush - All the World's a Stage (September 29)
>Barclay james Harvest - Octoberon (October 1)
>Kansas - Leftoverture (October 21)
>Van Der Graff Generator - World Record (October 22)
>Frank Zappa - Zoot Allures (October 29)
>Genesis - Wind & Wuthering (December 17)

>>129218602
>>Genesis - Trick of the Tail (February 13)
>>Brand X - Unorthodox Behaviour (June 18)
>>Genesis - Wind & Wuthering (December 17)
crazy year for Phil

>>129218602
>all that
>only one good album

>>129219078
>post 74
yeah, slim pickins going forward

>post 75
not sure if we're gonna make it to bump limit this time boys

>>129220692
we only made it last time because that faggot kept necrospamming with incest shit

File: ab67616d0000b2737ffa64f4b59587188ea53884.jpg (76.2 KB)

76.2 KB JPG

what did i think of it?

>>129221184
i think you made bank tony

>>129221184
no one cares about your solo career, Tony

Gonna have a proggy day today, perhaps get me in the mood to write some of my own... But first, ConstruKction!

File: elp.jpg (199.5 KB)

199.5 KB JPG

kino status?

>>129214590
kino

>>129186297
I think Raindances / Breathless was their peak.

File: jane relf bio.png (1.5 MB)

1.5 MB PNG

Have you ever met a woman who was into prog?

>>129223982
Last place I worked most of the people there including all of the women had heard of and were fans of Trout Mask Replica, does that count

File: 1721147370902267.png (14 KB)

14 KB PNG

>>129223982
once in college but she was into entry level stuff.. and by that i mean literally just floyd and crimson (specifically itcotck and red)

>>129221184
>Lust Provoking Visual-Effect Image
>Irrelevant Time-Wasting Music

>>129227770
highly disciplined living space

>>129223827
absolute
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Og6vHu2oks0

>>129223827
best ELP album, sadly. no saloon/comedy song

>>129223982
Several, they're not that uncommon but then again I don't live in a wiseacre backwater

>>129218925
I think it's crazier that Unorthodox Behaviour and A Trick of the Tail were pretty much recorded back to back. I think it's this reason that 1975-1976 was probably the peak of Phil's drumming ability.

>>129229102
His work ethic in the 70s and 80s was just insane. He just didn’t stop.

>>129228246
>what is nutrocker?

>>129230862
yeah, fuck. forgot about that one.

>>129224893
At my previous job we spent a lot of time driving to and from job sites and would take turns choosing the music. Roundabout ended up being "anon's song" among the others and a girl I was driving with actually sang along to the I Get Up, I Get Down section of Close to the Edge when I played it for her.

File: Screenshot 2026-01-25 at 20-48-10.png (246.5 KB)

246.5 KB PNG

NuRush is happening and there's nothing you can do about it.

File: 1644352265432.png (254.8 KB)

254.8 KB PNG

>>129234985
this is like kc without fripper, peart was quite literally the soul
no hate for the new chick she's alright but i can't believe these boomers are even considering the idea

>>129212084
i saw them in '18 i think it was. they played all the Byron hits

>>129235573
I saw them in the same tour m8. Not a big fan, but any time I see a prog(-related) band within an hour of me, I almost always go.

>>129223982
I knew a woman who was into Magma, but she got into Magma through some online recommendation because an anime she liked had a zeuhl-ish sounding soundtrack.

bump

Hands down, who was the best bass player in King Crimson?

File: pete giles.jpg (93 KB)

93 KB JPG

>>129239499

>>129239499
Levin > Wetton > Lake > Giles > Gunn > Boz > Haskell

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2GAnb2-lYuI

>>129239551
Jakko

File: gup.jpg (43.2 KB)

43.2 KB JPG

>80's KC
>mid 80's Rush
Why is prog + new wave so good?
>>129234985
>>129235520
Yeah PLEASE just call it a new band.

File: 1694087860520460.png (2.3 MB)

2.3 MB PNG

Holy shit
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNLdMH-28yU

Caravan is actually pretty good

>>129244079
no shite

>>129244079
Pop era Caravan is actually pretty good
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3pzX5iKFsk

>>129242726
Pop prog (distinct from prog pop) is based and I'm tired of pretending it's not.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjjNvjURS-s

File: geddy.jpg (7.6 KB)

7.6 KB JPG

>>129234985
>You WILL buy the deluxe edition albums with no new mixes or unreleased material
>You WILL buy the official rush beer
>You WILL pay $400 to see me and alex play with some millennial chick

>>129212084
I saw them a couple of years ago without expecting to
>Go to see Judas Priest with the gf (90% of the audience is bald or white-haired, predictably)
>Sitting around before it starts I notice a couple of banners with Uriah Heep on them
>...
>Oh shit I never looked at who's supporting
>It was in fact Uriah Heep and for some reason this wasn't on any of the marketing I'd seen previously
>Then after they did their set there was ANOTHER supporting act
>Fukken Saxon
Good value for money, those tickets

File: Toyah-Willcox-and-Robert-Fripp.jpg (307.8 KB)

307.8 KB JPG

Is this how a man who preaches about discipline should look like?

>>129245899
no, i don't think i will.

>>129247342
I WILL CHOOSE A PATH THAT'S CLEAR
I WILL CHOOSE FREE WILL

File: The Muffins - Chronometers.png (2 MB)

2 MB PNG

This is an excellent album.

File: tonylevininterview.png (45.5 KB)

45.5 KB PNG

it's official, King Crimson ended in 1974
everything after that is nothing more than a spin off

File: 1712024628598806.jpg (164.6 KB)

164.6 KB JPG

>>129249476
King Crimson is eternal. It always finds a way back.

File: plumpton.jpg (44.8 KB)

44.8 KB JPG

>>129249476
this, but December 1969

>>129249489
it's a cover of itself

File: attachment-Peter-Sinfield-King-Crimson-GettyImages-1314622637-e1731762308220.jpg (140.6 KB)

140.6 KB JPG

>>129249476
this, but 1971
King Crimson was and will always be Sinfield's band

File: unnamed-93.jpg (127.3 KB)

127.3 KB JPG

New Karnivool single

https://youtu.be/py8cq1eNgf8?si=bpeHyfRCeBI-eDSA

Album in less than 2 weeks

File: 189a8095e11c0e65919e77bc9fe271e2.jpg (85.1 KB)

85.1 KB JPG

>>129249476
King Crimson never existed.

File: sMTM8UMqXdc4Efftwyq6JK-567-80.jpg.png (314.9 KB)

314.9 KB PNG

>that pose
I've seen people joke about it, but it's safe to say that Fripp is on the spectrum, right?

>>129249810
good ending

>>129249676
>what's the deal with cat food??

>>129249818
he smol

File: CT-The-Tubes-Spooner-Quay-Early-scaled.jpg (755.9 KB)

755.9 KB JPG

Why no one told me about 70s era Tubes?

>>129250775
it's not important

It would've been cool for KC to have done a 50th anniversary tour with tons of cameos from the various lineups coming out to play songs from their respective eras. The documentary was already happening by then so Fripp had more or less made truces with the likes of Giles and Belew and others, so it was probably doable.

File: IMG_5464.jpg (2 MB)

2 MB JPG

Got this beauty today (I will financially never recover from this)

File: peel.jpg (67.7 KB)

67.7 KB JPG

>completely throws prog under the bus the second the ramones come along
What was his fucking problem?

>>129252515
his skull would expand too much from more prog

>>129252515
BBC nonce, following orders

What are your favourite albums that have low rating on progarchives?

>>129252853
https://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=382

>>129252515
I ran across this the other day. I don't know much about Peel, but I guess that sort of explains his quip at the end.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w40W2_iBfOI&t=180s

File: 1740140853495436.jpg (239.4 KB)

239.4 KB JPG

Prog peaked with Firth of Fifth.
We can thank the genius Anthony (Tony) Banks for his brilliant Piano playing and writing of the Flute/guitar solo melody.

Atheistbros how do I cope with the ending of Supper's ready being pure, absolute kino

>>129252853
Most of my favorite low-rated albums are pop albums put out by prog bands. And since it's a prog website, pop albums should have low ratings, even if it's good music. Invisible Touch takes the cake at 2.52.

If you're looking at reviled albums that most will still admit is prog, but just bad, then it's The Astonishing by Dream Theater at 3.22.

For the most part, I am very much a prog normie. In 99% of cases when rating a prog album, my personal rating is within 1 star of progarchives'.

File: market.png (169.1 KB)

169.1 KB PNG

listening to Grendel

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3v25JWma-HU

How many more years do you think Magma has left in them?

File: frippy.jpg (86.6 KB)

86.6 KB JPG

You may not like it, but this how a musician looks like when he reaches peak discipline

>>129249818
You just know Bill and John just wanted to leave asap

File: ca-camel-1-0312-assanta-anacamel-guitarist-andrew-latimer-performs-wednesday-evening-at-1167415876.jpg (31.9 KB)

31.9 KB JPG

>>129253795
Many such cases

>>129252515
He was always kind of a contrarian
As soon as something got mainstream he would just forget about it
He would have loved early 10s /mu/

>>129252515
Thought it was Phil for a second
Peel Collins haha

File: 91pU1pZ1p-L.jpg (571.3 KB)

571.3 KB JPG

prog peaked here, actually

File: Magma_-_Freyming-Merlebach_-_16-10-2010_-_Christian_et_Stella_Vander.jpg (2.8 MB)

2.8 MB JPG

>>129253549
>77 years old
hell be fine

>>129254027
pretty good first song, almost makes up for the wet fart of the remaining 40 minutes attached to it

>>129254056
You bastard
F

david lost

>>129253406
the accusations of plagiarism are VASTLY overblown

>>129253549
they'll probably keep going without christian as long as he gives his blessing. i kinda hope that happens soon desu. i think christian's age/health are what's preventing them from going overseas.

>>129254233
seems like you got a weird pressing that puts earthrise as the opener.

>>129253406
>wot if genesis but with shitty vocals and production

>>129254658
>Implying Genesis doesn't have shitty production
Their pre-Trick albums have terrible production

>>129254469
i mean yeah they're ripping off Genesis but they also rip off pink floyd and yes and introduce some post-punk elements to the fold. It all combines into something quite characteristic

File: 11.jpg (86.5 KB)

86.5 KB JPG

RIGHT (RIGHT) YOU'RE BLOODY WELL RIGHT
YOU GOT A BLOODY RIGHT TO SAAAAAAAY

>>129198230
>english
Many bands, hard to choose
>french
I'll say Gojira because some of their lyrics are in French
>german
Rammstein, since they're alright, and I haven't listened to much else with German lyrics
>spanish
The Mars Volta, who have quite a few Spanish lyrics
>italian
I don't think I've listened to any bands that sing in Italian

>>129256872
>I don't think I've listened to any bands that sing in Italian
that's insane. based on the other bands you listened, you should listen to museo rosenbach right now. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1DjVWWagwo

>>129254795
>i mean yeah
don't talk like that, it makes you sound insecure

>>129254658
Fish is a great vocalist though way better than Hogarth

File: 1755252626569906.jpg (54.6 KB)

54.6 KB JPG

>Genesis

>>129258293
ew, this guy sucks

>>129253795
>>129253901
these faces are pure kino and anyone who feels otherwise doesn't understand the essence of Prog.

>>129259200
People who make fun of “guitar face” have no clue. Working your hands and fingers like that creates tension in the muscles that you’re just reflexively going to react to, some more than others.

>>129258193
thanks dad

>>129253549
i like Magma's current lineup desu prob the strongest they've been since the Paganottis left even with Philippe gone and James dead RIP

>>129260793
come to think of it why did they even get rid of Bussonnet? or did he leave on his own? Jimmy is good but it was a downgrade imo

File: FHVS_gTVkAgpSCm.jpg (114.2 KB)

114.2 KB JPG

>>129259249
Based poster

File: Y7YSgbnuuqTyVeARhhmo8d.jpg (10.1 KB)

10.1 KB JPG

>>129258293
>doesn't like Genesis
>still likes Hackett, Gabriel and Collins solo work
Yeah, I think I know what exactly he doesn't like about Genesis

File: 2394641822_1b87a8eeeb.jpg (41.5 KB)

41.5 KB JPG

>>129253795
>>129253901

File: pdf.jpg (298 KB)

298 KB JPG

>>129261299
Ya these guys

>>129258338
But enough about Tony Banks

File: sad old man.jpg (46.5 KB)

46.5 KB JPG

>>129261412
Just rubbish ... nonsense from beginning to end...

File: tits.jpg (72.9 KB)

72.9 KB JPG

>>129261412
Still waiting on the Calling All Stations Trainwreckords

File: cddb22fdab53f6b62f536e6d2f0dad62.jpg (329.4 KB)

329.4 KB JPG

>>129261320
kino

File: Love Beach.jpg (195.4 KB)

195.4 KB JPG

>>129261674
fuck that, i'm waiting on that Love Beach

File: Jethro-Tull-Under-Wraps.jpg (124.2 KB)

124.2 KB JPG

>>129261674
I'm waiting for this one

>>129223982
A girl i know is really into pink floyd (her favorite is ummagumma), and my other friend is mostly into Yes

>>129262882
They literally won a grammy one album after this so it doesn’t count.

>>129223982
I was raised by one

>>129261620
Enough about Rogers solo career

>>129263074
you gotta admit its pretty good, eh?

>>129263497
Yeah, that's why he's touring with The Wall

>>129263638
The Wall is a solo Roger album played by his backing band, Pink Floyd

>>129263638
the wall is a well known album, and thats what people want to hear. of course hes going to play it

>>129261620
Enough about Tonys solo career

File: sakura-c3.jpg (565.8 KB)

565.8 KB JPG

Anyone else enjoy Derek Sherinian's solo albums? I don't really care about Dream Theater at all, but his solo stuff (which may as well be an outright collaboration with Simon Phillips since he plays on, co-writes and produces most of it) is some great jazzy prog wank.

https://youtu.be/RcOJ_JqzZ_w?si=dQ0zHLWMkn2MBu-3
https://youtu.be/ejja0bGL-vw?si=SyShgUpv3Tt2Ehr1
https://youtu.be/Tp_KnkDGJpE?si=wua14IuINOg5X6Il
https://youtu.be/V4gclTXiseo?si=NnjmrcGYCA8nsczH

>>129264321
tony's solo career in the 20th century*

File: b8effccab0cf36e9867062207ee73faa.jpg (166.9 KB)

166.9 KB JPG

>>129263663
>>129263764
>saves your misery porn album by composing one of the best songs in rock history
https://youtu.be/knVgzHiU0-c
David always win

>>129266490
I'm thoroughly surprised by how great a guitarist Gilmour is
was he a studio musician before joining Pink Floyd? what was he doing and how did he meet the guys?

File: prog trainwreckords.png (1.3 MB)

1.3 MB PNG

>>129261674
>>129262829

>>129266670
what were they thinking core

>>129266670
Calling all Stations is actually good tho

>>129199145
phil coffins

Colin Phillips

>>129266490
always wins what?

>>129266670
>Momentary Lapse of Reason
>Moody Blues comeback album
I don't think you know what trainwreckords means

>>129267658
Should it be Final Cut instead?

File: Steven_Wilson_-_The_Future_Bites.png (30 KB)

30 KB PNG

>>129266670
Did it desere the hate?

I'm still disappoionted he cancelled the tour, it would have been hilarious shithow

>>129267658
That one is actually good
division Bell on the other hand

>>129270460
Division Bell has High Hopes at least

>>129267731
A trainwreckord is supposed to be an album that's either so bad or bombs so hard that it tanks the artist's career or at least sets it back a ways, a creative and often commercial fumble that does longterm damage to one's reputation and popularity. It's not meant to be just any misstep or sellout in a band's discography. The Pink Floyd, Moody Blues and even Yes albums were pretty popular and in at least two cases actually revitalized the bands' careers even if they divided the fans. A few of the others are notorious but not very important in their bands' long and illustrious stories. Calling All Stations and Love Beach are textbook examples though.

>>129266670
I actually think Giant for A Day is decent. It's a better attempt at doing something "mainstream" than the Missing Piece at least.

>>129270743
If anything it should be Union for Yes

File: 1769728518977.jpg (190.7 KB)

190.7 KB JPG

>>129267658
>>129270460
>>129270478
>With all due respect to the people who went out and bought those records, they are just rubbish. Particularly The Division Bell; it's just nonsense from beginning to end. A Momentary Lapse of Reason had a couple of really nice tunes on it that, had I still been in the band, those chord sequences and melodies would have been made it onto a record that I was involved in. But conceptually and lyrically, it's just rubbish, partly because it's not true. It's like, "Let's try and write songs that sound as if they're Pink Floyd and make records that sound like Pink Floyd records."

>>129271471
>With all due respect
wow, such a polite gentleman

>>129271471
My favorite Rog spergout is when he chastised Billboard for changing its rules for the album chart so old catalog albums wouldn't hang around indefinitely and keep newer albums out. Of course his only concern was that DSOTM wouldn't be in the charts anymore and that bruised his ego for some reason.

>>129271471
Roger Tears crying about Pink Floyd albums after he left in a hissy fit has absolutely zero credibility.

>>129266534
>was he a studio musician before joining Pink Floyd?
He had a blues band that never made it but still managed to last a couple of years and record a couple of songs
https://youtu.be/Zrn1rSKifRE
>how did he meet the guys?
He was an old friend of Syd and one day he invited him to the studio. When Syd started to become a problem, the rest of the band asked him to play his parts on gigs, and the rest is history.

>>129271471
>A Momentary Lapse of Reason had a couple of really nice tunes on it that, had I still been in the band
I wonder what songs he's talking about
My guess is Sorrow and On The Turning Away
Funnily enough, Gilmour played a bit of Sorrow during the Live 8 rehearsals
https://youtu.be/pkpvJizgNPo?t=11

>>129271972
It's the same as
>No offence but

>>129272832
rog was being sincere though

>>129273328
Why do you think so

>>129273337
because hes a genius

File: inglasshouse.jpg (176 KB)

176 KB JPG

Almond status: activated

>>129273651
>glass breaks

>>129249489
You reckon Fripp wiped down his Les Paul after this or just left the ball juices on there?

File: SCR-20260126-pvdn.png (1.4 MB)

1.4 MB PNG

>>129247196

File: philcollins.jpg (58.4 KB)

58.4 KB JPG

Phil Collins is 75

>>129271471
He's right and we all know it.

>>129278034
If we all know it why does it need to be said

File: 1769794316328.jpg (127.2 KB)

127.2 KB JPG

>>129271471 Continued
>Let me put it this way: They made a live video of one of their shows a few years ago, and I thought it was really awful. It became obvious to me that they never understood any of it at all. And neither did quite a large number of the great unwashed -- as long as there are lots of lights going off, and they can recognize the tunes, they're relatively happy.
>I just don't think they understand the songs or what they're about. If you read old interviews, they actually say that. I can remember interviews from Dark Side where Rick was saying, "We really don't care about the lyrics." They remain connected to the numbers, the money, and so that's what you get, that's what you feel through it all.
>What you don't feel is the connection with the magic, because there isn't any. The working relationship I had with Dave and Nick and even Rick to a certain extent up to and including Dark Side of the Moon was very exciting and interesting and worthwhile, but after that it became very problematic. We'd done everything we had set out to do, and we kind of clung together from that point on in a very uneasy marriage because of the name, because it was easy, and we'd created an enormous audience.

Listen to progressive metal / jazz metal right now

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=19zFHmz1F6k

>>129279739
go away

>>129279739
stay awhile and listen

>>129279739
never understood why these guys never learned to improvise, it could've sounded much more individual and unique

File: 1667127848029917.jpg (62.5 KB)

62.5 KB JPG

>>129266250

>>129279841
No
>>129279934
Listen to what in particular?
>>129280369
I would say their songs are already quite unique compared to other bands

>>129280378
Thanks for the response asshole

>>129279739
Enough with this shit band.

>>129279739
I don't listen to bands with cringe names.

>>129279739
I only listen to bands that have single-word names

>>129280584
>3% jazz
>7% prog
>90% wank
youre welcome

>>129279739
>math rock chords with djent rhythms = jazz
no wonder so many people hate jazz music, they don't even know what it is

>>129266250
Sounds like video game music from the 90s. Mildly good, but I'd never seek it out. A Change of Seasons is the only song he's recorded that I thoroughly enjoyed. The rest of the EP sucks, and so does Falling into Infinity.

>>129281931
this nibba gets it

>>129280384
>I would say their songs are already quite unique compared to other bands
Why? It's djent metal and math rock.

File: 1_Pc31MmxbLQ-4krgLY6qnLQ.jpg (188.5 KB)

188.5 KB JPG

how do you guys feel about Renaissance? I used to love Ashes Are Burning and Scheherezade

What other Eloykino should I listen to after Dawn and Ocean?

>>129282750
Their entire discography front to back, except for their first album. They are a consistently solid band.

File: minoans.jpg (82.9 KB)

82.9 KB JPG

>prog metal can't be kin-ACK

>>129282580
>love Ashes Are Burning and Scheherezade
both good albums. i feel like they really needed someone to tell them to calm the fuck down though, a lot of songs would've benefited from just a bit more structure. even by prog standards, they can get pretty aimless
i think azure d'or is pretty underloved and one of the better prog sellout albums

>>129282580
I think they're a really good and under-appreciated band, but sometimes the meticulously composed neo-classical style and Annie's particular way of singing can get a little overbearing after a while of continuous listening.

>>129273651
What's with people complaining about the production on this? It sounds great, crystal clear

File: pedo floyd 2.png (283.9 KB)

283.9 KB PNG

What's with Epstein and Pink Floyd?

File: 1751836986060425.jpg (163.1 KB)

163.1 KB JPG

>>129284004
are these legit? i just saw one where he was gooning to fnaf futa porn on 4chan and im like.. what is reality anymore lol

>>129284052
It's on the United States Department of Justice's website.

>>129280817
They're good
>>129281622
Wikipedia refers to that album as "jazz metal"
>>129282216
I haven't found another band which sounds similar. Other djent bands have vocalists for one thing.

>>129284112
That doesn't answer the question

>>129282580
as much as I enjoy some of their most dense and crafted music, I think they could have benefited for sticking to a simpler folk-rock sound, like they had on most of Ashes
the orchestral stuff can be overbearing at times

>>129285381
>I haven't found another band which sounds similar.
Thank God. Stop torturing the threads with these shit bands.

>>129283679
what is this cheap comic book shlock?
any genre may have their ugly covers, but the overall tackiness and lack of aesthetic sense in metal music and modern prog are baffling
it's always the cheapest cheesiest shit you can find

File: images.jpg (30 KB)

30 KB JPG

>>129284004
They make good music together.

>>129286295
the Paul - John of the 70s
top lads

>>129282580
Turn of the Cards and A Song for All Seasons are both really good too if you haven't checked those out

>>129284004
Dave bros...

>>129279739
i'd like to like this but it's tryhard grooveless wank

>>129286277
what baffles me is bigger bands who could afford something legit but still choose to have the cheapest, dumbest sounding "orchestral" keyboard sound mixed in with otherwise decent production for everything else. ruining the entire thing

File: dino glove.jpg (42.3 KB)

42.3 KB JPG

Gimme some occult prog
>pic unrelated

>>129277870
Happy birthday and preemptive F
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVRHiSIeuAI

grop

yeah i mean i like them, or want to like them, but it's true that most of National Health is a pure caricature of proggy noodling, have to admit

wait no i meant Hatlfield and the north.
i always get em confused

>>129285381
>Wikipedia refers to that album as "jazz metal"
I know. How exactly does this address my point instead of helping prove it

>>129289279
porg

>>129288015
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wknGnV8thYE
magma- eliphas levi

>>129186297
Snowgoose is my favourite album of all time

>>129273651
their best album
>>129186297
Mirage is their best, then Moonmadness, most of The Snow Goose and later is better live.

>>129290700
i really really really like Never Let Go, though, it's the only Camel song that i like with the vocals

>>129290743
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNayU-egR1g

File: giant-for-a-day-55b3b364776ac.jpg (772.6 KB)

772.6 KB JPG

I don't give a fuck if it's not prog. It's a solid album and I don't give a fuck what anyone says.

>>129291348
Words from the wise

>>129247196
>>129276114
I think that Fripp its just pussy whipped beyond any repair or something, i have the impression that Toyah puts convince him that this was a good idea, but he has a pass because he is based and King Crimson is great.

I surrendered to the temptation of another reaction slop video. Lord help me.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VTemKrpQ2pM

>>129293204
Too bad he's listening to the dogshit remixes.

>>129293204
my favorites are the "Classical Composer Reacts to ____" videos
the audacity of these people to refer to themselves as "classical composers" amazes me.

>>129294663
He also listened to the early Beatles albums in stereo

>>129294676
hey, doug is a chill guy..

>>129294927
He might be chill but he's also one of the most soulless motherfuckers alive.

File: cover_552141762025_r.jpg (119 KB)

119 KB JPG

Camel or Caravan?

>>129186294
never knew Lex Luger played the drums

>>129296903
Neither.

>>129296903
Caravan easily

File: Picchio Dal Pozzo.png (746.5 KB)

746.5 KB PNG

I'm enjoying some Picchio Dal Pozzo

>>129293204
>>129294676
>MUSICIAN REACTS TO
>COMPOSER REACTS TO

>host of the video is a Literally Who
>has either not been in a band in over a decade, is in a shitty cover band that plays in a garage/basement, or is a solo soundcloud "musician" with no followers
>doesn't play in an orchestra, closest he got was a high school band class but still has the gall to call himself a "composer"
>or it's a neckbeard who's composed maybe a few chiptune tracks and remixed some video game or anime songs
every time

>>129298644
>blocks your path

File: i-kneel-trigun.gif (100.9 KB)

100.9 KB GIF

>>129298644
magma's still kino as fuck

File: ab67616d0000b2739d2ff3fc2590549e13f17670.jpg (139.3 KB)

139.3 KB JPG

>>129253795
>>129253901
not guitar obviously but still very applicable

gorp

>>129291348
This doesn't get enough hate

Giles and MacDonald were true geniuses.
Shame they only did one album.

>>129301522
they were able to make this too
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tgm0M64yYAg

>>129187891
I wanted to call my band Earthworks and thought I'd just come up with it and then remembered Bill had already done it. Such a good band name

>>129296903
Caramel

what i feel with prog and the rejection of it is that it's like a broken promise.
Beatles go psychedelic, Day in the life etc, so then it's 'oh, with the studio a song can really be anything'...
then King Crimson explodes, setting the bar for what can be done with a Mellotron, Yes are just there ready to go, Genesis, etc...
it sorta works for a quick few years, but by the time other countries really get into it like Italy and the Scandinavians, then all of a sudden 'yeah well thanks but no thanks we don't want that anymore'

>>129302720
gibberish

>>129294676
The funniest is that "Critical Reactions" neckbeard who's allegedly a trained composer who says he's been studying music his whole life then when he's shown something really basic and common like The Beatles or John Coltrane or Beethoven he's all dumbfounded, "what's this!? what's going on!?"

>>129302959
While you were busy listening to the Beatles he studied the blade

>>129302720
hello sir! I too very am a prog fan

>>129302959
His helicopter parents probably forced him to study nothing but classical 24/7.

File: Genesis__1976_press_photo.jpg (490 KB)

490 KB JPG

Fuck it, I don't care if you call me Tony, Hackett was a stubborn, high-maintenance brat who could never be satisfied. He contributed a good amount of writing to Trick of the Tail and Wind & Wuthering, even having a productive collaboration with Banks on a few tracks, but I guess that wasn't enough. He does one solo album and suddenly thinks all his throwaway ideas are too precious to compromise in a democratic band. He was just as whiny and obstinate in GTR too which tells you all you need to know.

I THINK PULL ME UNDER IS A PRETTY GOOD SONG but I haven't heard anything else from Dream Theater
Metropolis is supposed to be pretty good too

NEW
>>129309000
>>129309000
>>129309000