>>97492798
... if only there was a DnD general or three to ask this question...

What are you even getting from posting inane threads like this?

>>97492798
He's an android.

>>97492798
He's not undead, he's a living thing. A mockery of life and an affront to god, but a living thing nonetheless.

>>97492826
Your seething. Don't you get it?

>>97492898
>doesnt answer question, just gets made slop got called slop
What's the point of escaping your containment thread if youre not even gonna do anything with it

>>97492934
ntayrt
What's the point of trying to contain anons if you're not even going to succeed at it?

>>97492798
Next time, OP, google "Flesh Golem"

>>97492934
Still the usual thing where you think anyone interacting with you is OP? You are being trolled, you have been for the past...who fucking even cares years. You are still falling for it. And still fail to realize your seething may very well be their end goal, even after people tell you. Keep going then anon, let's see how well it goes for you.

>>97492949
I get to make fun of them and watch their thread get shat on, thats the point

>>97492966
The fuck are you on about bro

>>97492968
You are a dog chained to a leash, kids throw rocks at you but you can't do shit about it, besides barking at them. They laugh and fuck off, their deed done, and you think your barking scared them away, and saying "well they're not getting their rocks back :) ". Sad on all fronts.

>>97492996
Good analogy anon, I'm going to remember this

>>97492996
>>97493045
>still cant even answer the puckee-tier question to the thread theyre desperately trying to defend
At least you were right about one thing, they do fuck off. Enjoy your empty slop thread

File: TheTactic.png (95 KB)

95 KB PNG

>>97492798
No, did you even read it? The monster being alive and sentient was the crux of the moral conflict.
>>97492989
He fancies himself an artist. The truth is trolling /tg/ is babby mode and he can't cut it on the big boy boards. If he could, he'd be there instead :).

>>97493066
>if you engage with me you are defending the thread
That's a curious leap of logic.

>>97493107
If youre not defending it then why are you so upset people arent engaging with it

>>97493112
Dude, I see some retards struggling with the concept that they are being trolled, and I'm telling them things how they likely are. Me being upset or caring about anything else here are things that you are trying to push with no basis in reality.
>anon asks a question
>I give him an answer
That's it. The basis of dicussion. AI can get behind this, why can't some anons?

>>97492798
No, because the creation is a living organism in the canon material, just inhumanly physically resilient. Regardless of setting/system, unless you're going off of pastiches, he would be a living creature.

>>97493066
ooooof they got you with the dog bit huh.

>>97493129
A lot of humans can't into more than
>Thing I like good
>All things I don't like same bad
Ifmit has more than 2 moving parts they lump everything together because it's too complicated for them.

>>97493129
>dude youre being trolled by not engaging with the puckee thread
If you didnt care you'd just stop posting here
>anon asks a question
>I give him an answer
>That's it. The basis of dicussion
So much for totally not defending the thread lol

>>97492858
He's not an affront to God or God would never have allowed his creation. The man's rejection is living proof that the arrogance of humanity in comparing himself to God is unwarranted and causes only humiliation, horror, and suffering.

>>97493204
You've been posting here anon, you are engaging. And I clearly said "caring about anything else". Of course I care about the question I answered, and what came after. I don't get how you could have trouble with this.
And again, that curious leap of logic where if anyone engages with you, it means defending the thread. Do what you like anon, report it, hide it, keep posting, whatever. Just know that, if OP's goal was to trigger your response, he succeeded. Probably not for the first time, and most definitely not for the last, because he gets positive feedback out of this.
Keep going then, by all means. Have a good day.

File: file.png (358.9 KB)

358.9 KB PNG

>>97493259
It's subtitled as The Modern Prometheus for a reason, anon. Prometheus was a titan in Greek mythology who defied the gods by giving fire to humanity, and Mary Shelly did not hold a positive opinion of Prometheus due to her vegetarian beliefs (no seriously).

>>97493261
This whole post is a mess of contradictions
>I care about the thread that I totally answered
>im not defending the thread tho
>but youre definitely being trolled by making fun of the thread
>even tho his goal was discussion
>except its actually to troll people
>but i wasn't trolled by answering it
>im not gonna talk about it tho imma just keep telling you youre trolled by making fun of it
>anyway, here's a paragraph on how much I dont care
If my posts arent engagement then stop caring about what I say in my posts, simple.

>>97492858
Frankenstein's sin was not the creation of his monster, but that he could not love his creation like God loves us.

>>97492798
>animated from biochemically inert corpses
>hammered in as existing against natural order
Hmm I wonder

File: groomer discourse.jpg (46.1 KB)

46.1 KB JPG

>>97492989

>>97492798
Not specifying a game with a question whose answer depends on the game should be punishable by permaban and a "natural causes" death.

>>97494412
>maybe if I reply to the OP I can start over and pretend to be someone else
this board is for talking about rpg games rather than roleplaying, you should try /qst/

File: 638062024851930870.png (246.5 KB)

246.5 KB PNG

He's basically a flesh golem from D&D. Just go with whats in there.

pretty sure he counts as a Construct in dnd terms

>>97494436
And what rpg is this thread about, exactly?

>>97494391
>groomer discourse
And you expect me to know what the fuck youre talking about?

>>97494620
I'd sooner count him as aberration or monstrous humanoid, constructs in D&D tend to be unintelligent, and the creature is anything but unintelligent.

A more interesting question is whether or not in the story if God ensouled the creature, or if it's merely a manlike animal.

>>97492798
>Frankenstein's Monster
He's Frankenstein and will always be Frankenstein. Fuck your petty details.

>>97495719
Strictly speaking he would be since he's the doc's "son," anyhow.

>>97492798
the very first servitor

>>97495757
Exactly

>>97495417
>ensouled the creature
He explicitly has a soul
Mary shelley said it herself

>>97493380
By punishing them for doing something they didnt know was wrong?
Turning someone into a pillar of salt for looking at a crying child?
Oh, getting a bear to maul children for laughing at a bald man?

>>97496005
>children
more like "urban youths"

>>97496021
Nope, you lost me

Not american

>>97493380
>God loves us
lol
lmao

>>97496043
>>97496103
Why are you trans?

>>97496005
>By punishing them for doing something they didnt know was wrong?
Yes, that is how you learn it is wrong.

>>97492798
Should you post single sentence survey threads that offer nothing of substance?

>>97492798
did you miss the part where he shous “it’s alive!”

>>97496269
That's his personal interpretation of the situation, viewed by tinted lenses of wishful thinking, doesn't mean it is objectively true.

>>97496245
>that is how you learn it is wrong.
You can also tell them
Why punish before they know it's a crime?

Adam and Eve were literally incapable of comprehend a bad action

It's like putting a toddler in the driver's seat of a car then blaming them for a crash

>>97492798
It depends on the game. In Dungeons and Dragons, this makes sense. But in the Chronicles of Darkness, a Promethean and a Vampire have separate weaknesses.

>>97492798
He's a Construct. A Construct made of flesh, certainly, but a Construct all the same.

>>97495996
If she did explicitly say that she did so outside of the book because she did not explicitly write it in the novel and she can take a flying leap with her opinions on the matter, after her corpse is in some way reanimated of course.

>>97497608
Not to mention it's very much up in question how much of the authorship is her own work and how much was contributed by Percy and Byron.

>>97492798
I always got the feeling Frankenstein's Monster is more alive than your average human despite being made from corpses.

>>97492826
Palladium has undead and anti undead abilities. And to answer the question, probably not. Palladium undead abilities make a hard distinction on undead created by supernatural means and not corpses that have been juiced up until they start moving again.

>>97493319
Frankenstein is literally wrong for reviling, rejecting and despising his creation. This is made extremely clear. Did you even read the book?

>>97497672
Considering Frankenstein was written precisely because Byron wanted he, Mary, Percy, and his physician to each try writing a ghost story, it's unlikely he wrote it. What would be the point if he did?

>>97498019
Yes I have, actually, and I agree that Doctor Frankenstein is the monster.

>>97498028
Wouldn't *he* be the modern Prometheus then? Prometheus defied the gods and the one who was doing the defying here was Frankenstein (by creating the monster).

>>97498032
That's what I was saying.

>>97496005
>By punishing them for doing something they didnt know was wrong?
For lying about it afterwards when they did know it was wrong.

>>97496103
God loves us the same way a redneck loves a dog. Beats em, yells at em, chains em up outside, but WILL kill you in an instant if you try to harm or take the dog.

>>97492850
Flesh golem*

>>97492798
>should a creature made of stitched together corpses be weak to anti-undead
Yes, even if he's not flagged as "undead".

>>97492996
Nta but if you're so happy and not here, then why are you still here getting so mad at the barking dog for not playing along with your gay little "pretend I actually play traditional games" roleplay thread?

>>97498105
Anon is neither the chained dog nor the children. He's the tired neighbor listening to the dog barking again.

I love how everyone who goes ERMMM, IT'S FRANKENSTEIN'S MONSTER NOT FRANKENSTEIN never actually calls him Adam. Buncha fucking nobooks posers

>>97498010
>summon lightning to jump-start a corpse
>resulting creature is not supernatural or undead
Skeleton archers in shambles.

>>97498108
>im so above it all and just tired of all the noise!
>i know! Let me jump in the center of it all and start screeching! That'll fix things!
Smurrt

File: df4668e0dc7660f1495129237a110b72.450x352x1.png (88.9 KB)

88.9 KB PNG

>>97498119
Yeah pretty much sums it up

>>97498022
Mary did the writing while Byron was doing Percy.

File: Junji Ito Frankenstein.jpg (507.4 KB)

507.4 KB JPG

>>97492798
Not usually, they are classified usually as alchemical creations (Promethean: The Created) or supernatural constructions (D&D).

Since we already have this thread: remember when in the book Victor destroys the almost ready Bride for the Creature since he is afraid that they move to some desolated part of the world (the Creature mentions jungles of South-America) and start to breed, and that this new race of creatures will conquer the whole world since they are bigger and stronger than baseline humans.
Just thinking that it would be an interesting alternative history tabletop setting/scenario.

>>97498119
I would talk with the dog's owner or the children's parents, but that's not an option here. The children themselves are untouchable because they run away. So I shout at the dog to shut the fuck up.

>>97498109
His name isn't actually Adam, either.

>>97498060
Also because once you introduce the idea of evil to an immortal, you're fucking them up forever. Life and death and the sacrifice of Christ are meant to separate us from the grievous error of first sin.

>>97498171
>this new race of creatures will conquer the whole world since they are bigger and stronger than baseline humans
This isnt what would happen though. The children would be normal humans with the genetics of whatever dead people's gonads he stapled into them.

>>97493319
>it's subtitled as The Modern Prometheus for a reason, anon.
Victor is modern Prometheus.

>>97498205
In the novel, the creature is not a resurrected man. It is a new form of life that resembles a man. This is why Victor finds him beautiful before he brings him to life but feels atavistic disgust afterwards. He can sense on a base bestial level that this is not a man.

>>97498205
>gonads he stapled into them
Actually transplanted testicles will produce hybrid DNA

File: by mossacannibalism.jpg (519.5 KB)

519.5 KB JPG

>>97498205
Like that one anon already said the novel never discusses how Victor created Adam but in the book Victor did say that he used to creep around graveyards and slaughterhouses so the "Flesh Golem" archetype of the Universal movie version has some base in the book.
>The children would be normal humans with the genetics of whatever dead people's gonads he stapled into them.
Well, yes, that would probably be the most logical conclusion if the Creature is a Flesh Golem and not a new form of life. But for the sake of the scenario, if you will, let us assume that the Creature and the Bride can breed and produce a monstrous race that will threaten mankind.
Of course if the creature is created late 18th century and they breed as fast as normal humans they don't have a big enough population to fight before mankind invents stuff like atomic bomb etc. so that is also a problem for an apocalyptic monster war scenario.
>>97498233
In this particular case I would assume that a lightning bolt to the assembled corpse would also cause some supernatural mutations (if we go with the Universal classic).

>>97498222
The book can call it whatever it wants, the book can't change what it is, and it is an organism made from transplanted parts from cadavers.

>>97498197
I'm sorry your janny application was rejected

>>97493319
>Mary Shelly did not hold a positive opinion of Prometheus due to her vegetarian beliefs (no seriously).
That has to be a joke.

>>97499614
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Modern_Prometheus#Modern_Prometheus Nope.

>>97498299
Could animals, particularly carrion eaters, sense that he was made from cadavers?

>>97492798
I dunno, ask /5eg/